4 ms·
> Also, if you think this should be changed, what should the law be, exactly? You're not allowed to make insane profits in a Roth IRA? Why? I'd go with a cap o
by tzs 5y ago
> Also, if you think this should be changed, what should the law be, exactly? You're not allowed to make insane profits in a Roth IRA? Why?
I'd go with a cap on the amount of returns that are tax free. Put after-tax money into a Roth, and you can take out the original investment plus up to some limit tax-free. Anything over that would be treated just like a regular IRA withdrawal.
> In my opinion (and it is an emotional judgement), I think America is based on freedom, and Roth money is money you already paid taxes on, and you should be allowed to invest it however you want. It's your money after all.
But you don't pay tax on the earnings of your Roth investments. That's the whole point of the Roth. Your investment choices are:
1. No IRA. You pay tax on your income, and when you invest after-tax money you pay tax on the investment earnings. You can withdraw investment money at any time.
2. Regular IRA. You can defer tax on some of your income and invest that money. You pay tax on the investment earnings and on the original income when you withdraw them from the IRA. You also pay a penalty if you withdraw money before age 59 1/2.
3. Roth IRA. You pay tax on your income, and when you invest after-tax money you do not pay taxes on the investment earnings. You also pay a penalty if you withdraw money before age 59 1/2.