3 ms·
Is it any different than training a human? What if a person learned programming by hacking on GPL public code and then went to build proprietary software?
by yjftsjthsd-h 5y ago
Is it any different than training a human? What if a person learned programming by hacking on GPL public code and then went to build proprietary software?
- woodruffw 5y agoA human being who has learned from reading GPL'd code can make the informed, intelligent decision to not copy that code. My understanding of the open problem here is whether the ML model is intelligently recommending entire fragments that are explicitly licensed under the GPL. That would be a licensing violation, if a human did it.
- 10000truths 5y ago> A human being who has learned from reading GPL'd code can make the informed, intelligent decision to not copy that code. A model can do this as well. Getting the length of a substring match isn’t rocket science.
- akavel 5y agoActually, I believe it's tricky to say if even human can actually do that safely. There's the whole concept of "cleanroom rewrite" - meaning, if you want to rewrite some GPL or closed-source project into a different license, you should make sure you never ever seen even a glimpse of the original code. If you look on GPL or closed-source code (or, actually, code governed by any other license), it's hard to prove you didn't accidentally/subconsciously remember parts of this code, and copy them into your "rewrite" project even if "you made a decision to not copy". The border between "inspired by" and "blatant copyright infringement" is blurry and messy. If that was already so tricky and troublesome legal-wise before, my first instinct is that with the Copilot it could be even more legally murky territory. IANAL, yet I'd feel better if they made some [legally binding] promises that their model is based only on code carefully verified to have one of an explicit (and published) whitelist of permissive licenses. (Even this could be tricky, with MIT etc. actually requiring some mention in your advertising materials [which is often forgotten], but now that's a completely different level of trouble than not knowing if I'm infringing GPL or some closed-source code, or other weird license.)
- toastal 5y agoBut wouldn't a machine learning AGPL code it be hosting AGPL code in its memory?
- yjftsjthsd-h 5y agoPretty sure merely hosting code hoesn't trigger AGPL; if it did, github would have to be open-sourced.
- Hamuko 5y agoHow do you distribute a human?
- yjftsjthsd-h 5y agoA contractor seems equivalent to SaaS to me
- praptak 5y agoIt is different in the same way that a person looking at me from their window when I pass by is different from a thousand cameras observing me when I move around city. Scale matters.
- throwaway2037 5y agoThis is a lovely analogy, akin to "sharing mix tapes" vs "sharing MP3s on Napster". I fear the coming world with extensive public camera surveilance and facial recognition! (For any other "tin foil hatters" out there, cue the trailer for Minority Report.)
- Hamuko 5y ago>I fear the coming world with extensive public camera surveilance and facial recognition! I fear the coming world of training machine learning models with my face just because it was published by someone somewhere (legally or not).
- heavyset_go 5y agoYou can rest assured that this is already the case if your picture was ever posted online. There are dozens of such products that law enforcement buys subscriptions to.
- jonny_eh 5y ago> a thousand cameras observing me when I move around city. Scale matters. reply While I certainly appreciate the difference, is camera observation illegal anywhere where it isn't explicitly outlawed? Meaning, have courts ever decided that the difference of scale matters?
- praptak 5y agoNo idea. I was not trying to make a legal argument. This was to try to convey why someone might feel ok about humans learning from their work but not necessarily about training a model.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- twobitshifter 5y agoWhat if a person heard a song by hearing it on the radio and went on to record their own version?
- mkr-hn 5y agoThere is already a legal structure in place for cover song licensing. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Cover_version#United_States_copyright_law https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Cover_version#United_States_co...
- twobitshifter 5y agoExactly so it needs licensing of some sort - this is closer to cover tunes than it is to someone getting a CS degree and being asked to credit Knuth for all their future work.
- IncRnd 5y agoWould you hire a person who only knew how to program by taking small snippets of code from GPL and rearranging them? That's like hiring monkey's to type Shakespeare. The clear difference is that a human's training regimen is to understand how and why code interacts. That is different from an engine that replicates other people's source code.