2 ms·
> If the whole world decides a random rock in your back yard is worth $10M, you shouldn't need to give the government $3M while the rock just sits there. Why n
by bryanlarsen 5y ago
> If the whole world decides a random rock in your back yard is worth $10M, you shouldn't need to give the government $3M while the rock just sits there.
Why not?
General taxation is done on two principles -- ability to pay and the principle of fairness. Those who have more pay more.
If you have a rock worth $10M in your back yard you can certainly pay. You'd have to get a loan or sell the rock to do so, but you have more ability to pay than anybody who isn't a millionaire.
And by not selling for $10M, you're demonstrating that the rock is worth more than $10M to you. So the government is doing you a favor by only taxing on the $10M rather than on the actual value to yourself.
- abakker 5y agoBecause if the world later decides the rock is worth $5, the government doesn't give you the taxes back. Taxes levied at the time of transaction are sensible and reduce the risk that people who own volatile assets will end up paying taxes without realizing gains.
- bryanlarsen 5y agoThey currently don't tax unrealized gains, so how do you know that they won't rebate losses if they ever started to tax unrealized gains?
- abakker 5y agoBecause the government doesn't have a history of reducing property taxes when house values decline. In Fairfield county, CT many of the local municipalities left property taxes at 2006 levels straight through 2007-2010 even though real estate was worth less if it were to be sold. Other areas did the same thing. Think about this - I have un unrealized appreciation in an asset, and I am a normal person, the only way I'd be able to pay the taxes on my $10m rock would be by selling the rock. Wealth taxes can force a sale to cover the taxes. Practically, this is not something we want. In fact, most cities have laws designed to help people NOT be forced to sell. If every long time owner of an apartment in Oakland had to pay taxes on their real-estate appreciation, the majority would be forced to sell. Net: Wealth taxes are strongly regressive, and pro gentrification.