7 ms·
No, it should be fully legalized, not just decriminalized. Decriminalization is this weird grey area where it's legal(ish) to possess small quantities, but gen
by TylerE 5y ago
No, it should be fully legalized, not just decriminalized.
Decriminalization is this weird grey area where it's legal(ish) to possess small quantities, but generally not to produce, sell, or distribute.
- austhrow743 5y agoIt’s weird as fuck to me that decriminalisation is even considered because one of the (or just the?) largest negative effects of people doing illegal drugs is the large crime organisations built to provide them. As well as the then poor quality control resulting in people overdosing because they didn’t know what they were using, although not really a problem with weed specifically. Decriminalisation keeps the organised crime and dodgy product while removing any sort of demand reducing effect keeping it illegal had.
- nine_k 5y agoAt least it decreases the number of people sent to prisons for possession and consumption. This is not a sufficient step, but a likely first step in normalizing the use of weed in the eyes of the public. Abrupt changes scare people (and for a good reason).
- rantwasp 5y agowhen this is selectively enforced and only people of a certain color or ethnic group have to pay the heavy price of possession I call bullshit on the "war on drugs". this is not and has not been about drugs from day one.
- nine_k 5y agoIt was an anti-Left and anti-Black plot from the beginning, according to some. Unfortunately, hard proofs of that are absent. In any case, were it about health and well-being, it likely won't look like a war.
- Gustomaximus 5y agoThe idea of decriminalisation is the cops don't focus on end users (and the negative effect of this to them) and the resource goes toward organised crime. I think makes sense for drugs govt won't legalise like Heroin, while they should legalise lower end drugs like pot.
- TylerE 5y agoThe problem with decrim is that it forces users to interact with criminals to get their fix.
- efnx 5y agoAnd the interaction can't be monitored - the user has no guide through dosages besides the person directly benefiting from the sale.
- PaulDavisThe1st 5y agoWho where they interacting before decriminalization to get their fix?
- Jcowell 5y agoI don’t get the point of this question. Obviously criminals? The expectation is that regulated avenues will serve to divert.
- PaulDavisThe1st 5y agoParent (now GP) said: > The problem with decrim is that it forces users to interact with criminals to get their fix.
- cloverich 5y agoThey just left out that context, i.e. decrim doesn't change the fact that you are forced to go through a criminal to obtain them.
- rantwasp 5y agolol. here is a crazy idea: make them legal. also, decriminalization is usually a step towards legalization. because it's too much to straigh-up legalize them. also, it's beyond me how some people can get on their high horses about what drugs are okay (alcohol? coffee?) and what drugs are not okay. we should have figured this out by now - but seems that we're going to need more time /s
- sharken 5y agoActually not that crazy an idea and the aspect that decriminalization makes interaction with criminals necessary, should be enough to skip this idea. So legalization seems to be the way forward, i do wonder what organized crime will do in response. The most lucrative crimes are Counterfeit goods, drug trafficking and human trafficking according to this source. https://www.occrp.org/en/daily/6240-ngo-transnational-organized-crime-groups-make-us-2-2-trillion-a-year https://www.occrp.org/en/daily/6240-ngo-transnational-organi...
- rantwasp 5y agoanecdotal evidence: in WA state where weed is legal, I have not heard of anyone buying weed on the street. Why would you risk it when you have good quality stuff that you can buy in a safe location? so you decriminalize it first and after that you make it straight up legal. Organized crime is going to move to other things in response. There is a risk/reward curve.
- sharken 5y agoAbsolutely, and here the reward for legalizing some drugs seems greater than the risk. I suppose Meth and Crack are not on the list of legalized drugs, which means that half of all drug offenses will not be affected. Still, halving drug offenses is not a bad result. Source: https://www.ussc.gov/sites/default/files/pdf/research-and-publications/research-publications/2021/FY20_Overview_Federal_Criminal_Cases.pdf https://www.ussc.gov/sites/default/files/pdf/research-and-pu...
- austhrow743 5y ago
- IMTDb 5y agoIt's weird as fuck to me that legalization is even considered because one of the (or just the?) largest negative effects of people doing illegal drugs is the added legal consequences on them and our inability to help them because they are considered criminals. Allowing businesses to legally sell, develop, and advertise addictive psychoactive substances seems dangerous to me. History has shown that if they come up with a new compound that is 20% more addictive but 15% more dangereous, you can bet that this will be their next best seller. On top of that, we should welcome their "innovation" for tax dollars and give them a legal shelter ? We already have seen what it leads to with opioids, even when we gate it behind doctors prescriptions: a usage crisis. We need more control, not less. And we need a legal framework that does allow us to help users instead of putting them to prison, that does not pack the courts with addicts, and that allows the police to focus on more pressing issues. That is what decriminalization is about. Extreme repression is as bad as extreme indulgence, there is a middle ground.
- Semaphor 5y agoThat depends on the implementation, though, doesn’t it? After all, in the Netherlands, it’s only decriminalized, yet there are stores selling it all over the country.
- big_youth 5y agoIt is also deeply tied with criminals organizations providing them a healthy revenue stream. Look to the commercialization in US states like Colorado as a better (but not perfect) model.
- edgyquant 5y agoIs there somewhere I can read more the criminal organizations being apart of the legal cannabis scene in Holland?
- Smithalicious 5y agoI don't have a source, but as a Dutch person: there is no legal way to actually grow cannabis in this country, nor to sell it to stores ("coffeeshops") that sell it to consumers. Thus all cannabis sold necessarily[0] comes from illegal growth operations, which is the kind of thing that's very lucrative for organized crime. [0] if you want to be pedantic about it, owning up to 5 cannabis plants is decriminalized, but nobody is under the illusion that such personal use scale agriculture is fueling the commercial trade
- jrnichols 5y ago> Look to the commercialization in US states like Colorado as a better (but not perfect) model. reply Sounds crazy, but one of the best models in the United States right now is actually the state of Oklahoma's. It's fairly straight forward, easy to apply, and barrier to entry is low. Fees are low. Not a lot of red tape. It's working well.
- vincentmarle 5y agoThe coffeeshops are allowed to sell small quantities for personal use. But growing marijuana in large quantities and supplying those stores is still considered illegal and punishable with fines / jail time.
- busymom0 5y agoAs someone who used to be against drug (including weed) legalization, I had my opinion changed completely by this article few years ago. I shared it with a few of my right leaning friends and several of them also had their opinions changed: Legalize It All: How to win the war on drugs https://harpers.org/archive/2016/04/legalize-it-all/ https://harpers.org/archive/2016/04/legalize-it-all/ It's an excellent read which addresses both sides of the drug legalization debate, side effects of the legalization and how to prevent the bad side effects and presents similar actions in other countries. A significant majority of my conservative friends are also moving in this direction. Conservative leaning Justice Clarence Thomas today said federal laws against marijuana may no longer be necessary: "The federal government's current approach is a half-in, half-out regime that simultaneously tolerates and forbids local use of marijuana,” the conservative Supreme Court justice wrote. https://www.nbcnews.com/politics/supreme-court/clarence-thomas-says-federal-laws-against-marijuana-may-no-longer-n1272524 https://www.nbcnews.com/politics/supreme-court/clarence-thom... Now, I am for legalizing and pardoning (non-dealing/manufacturing) weed, cocaine and mushrooms. The only reason I am hesitant for heroine, meth and fentanyl is because if I remember right, heroine and meth get laced with fentanyl which is very easy to overdose on. But I am willing to be corrected if that's not the case. The last month's ban on menthol cigarettes and flavoured tobacco is a step backwards unfortunately. Considering menthols are preferred by 86% blacks and 46% hispanics, it will just create a new black market and put more of them in prison. With that said, I don't want everywhere to devolve into San Fransisco either where you see needles everywhere and addicts tweaked out everywhere. Most people who are against legalization aren't going to agree with it if they see things like how San Fran is turning out. So the legalization must be done correctly. If they are legalized and provided via stores which check ID, that would reduce the black market, reduce cartels across the border, reduce gangs, drug dealing and reduce the prison population which had played a major role in wreaking havoc on many families. It would also reduce policing gone wrong / corruption and have less "rebellious" kids doing it.
- owlninja 5y ago>Now, I am for legalizing and pardoning (non-dealing/manufacturing) weed, cocaine and mushrooms. The only reason I am hesitant for heroine, meth and fentanyl is because if I remember right, heroine and meth get laced with fentanyl which is very easy to overdose on. But I am willing to be corrected if that's not the case. The argument you usually hear back is that if those harder drugs were more regulated, there would be no accidental overdoses where the street drug has been cut or consists of unknown quantities, safer places to consume, no drug deals gone wrong, etc... I am still not sold on the solution there. I know other countries have some sort of program that gets pointed to, but I don't know enough to comment. I do only know that those drugs have absolutely wrecked the lives of people I knew. If they were legal they still seem to be so addictive that the user's life is 100% focused on getting high as often as possible. So maybe some regulation so that certain people can get those drugs but without risk of overdose? But isn't that what methadone is for? I am sort of rambling here as I try to form a better opinion - because if we just outlaw those certain, very-addictive drugs, a black market will always exist. But that is also something I would never want my family members to try on a whim.