3 ms·
> Can you figure out by inspecting the chemical formula that H2SO4 will be an acid if you didn't already know that ahead of time? Strictly speaking, the answer
by jcranmer 5y ago
> Can you figure out by inspecting the chemical formula that H2SO4 will be an acid if you didn't already know that ahead of time?
Strictly speaking, the answer is "no", because it's not the formula that matters but the shape. And something like C₆H₁₂O₆ doesn't tell you how all of the bonds hook up--are we looking at esters, alcohols, ketones, aldehydes, carboxylic acids? There's several distinct molecules that have that formula, and those distinctions matter for chemistry.
But given the actual structure of the compound? Yeah, we can compute a lot of stuff. That list of words that probably meant nothing to you--that's different kinds of functional groups, and functional groups tend to react in very similar ways when given several compounds. And organic compound is basically all about identifying these groups and the ways in which they react.
> Is there a way to figure this out from first principles?
"First principles" in this case would basically be a large dose of molecular orbital theory, derived from quantum mechanics. And yes, we can develop a good deal of explanations by recourse to molecular orbital--for example, why aromatic and antiaromatic compounds exist, despite the fact they superficially look like the same structure.
> Can you look at a reaction and tell whether it will "compile" and what it does, the same way you can look at a program and figure out if it will compile and what it does? If you can't, why not?
Typically, the difficulty is in figuring out how selective reactions are. If you've got a molecule with a couple different C=C bonds in it, and you're doing an addition reaction across those bonds, predicting how many of those bonds, and which ones specifically, change in the reaction is more of a crapshoot. So it's not foolproof, but it is generally reliable enough at this point that organic synthesis has moved from "here's a Nobel Prize for figuring how to synthesize vitamin B12" to "congratulations on being hired; why don't you synthesize this molecule while we ramp you up on the job."