3 ms·
Including "solar-radiation management" among sensible activities, and omitting essential gating technologies such as energy storage, taints the whole article. T
by ncmncm 5y ago
Including "solar-radiation management" among sensible activities, and omitting essential gating technologies such as energy storage, taints the whole article. The howlers suggest that it is a "feel-good" piece, or a marketing exercise aimed at making certain tech approaches seem to have the established merits of solar and wind build-out.
Solar-radiation management, in particular, is another name for geo-engineering. It would be a clear disaster if we ever came to depend on it, as any hiccup in performance would subject Earth to a sudden rollback of any benefit, a far worse outcome even than what we are experiencing. (This is as distinguished from, e.g., spreading olivine to absorb atmospheric CO2, or scattering iron dust on the deep ocean surface, where suddenly not doing it anymore would not set us back at all.)
Hydrogen-powered aviation is a clear technical win in the longer term, but any money diverted to that from, e.g., energy storage would be a setback, just as would diverting money from solar and wind build-out in favor of nukes.
Removing CO2 from the atmosphere seems to attack the problem squarely, but fully 10% of the increased heating comes from the remarkably small amount of sulfur hexafluoride, SF6, already released into the atmosphere. (SF6 is 25k times as good at trapping heat as CO2.) There is an industrial replacement for SF6 available now, and apparatus to extract as much as possible from existing equipment for disposal, but what is already in the air is there for many centuries, and it is still being added to.
Similarly, if the existing stock of HFCs were vented, that would produce as much forcing as all the CO2 now in the atmosphere. (HFCs are >2k as good at trapping heat as CO2.) People have instructions to carefully extract HFCs from refrigeration systems being dismantled, but in many places those instructions are ignored. So, some substantial fraction of the HFCs will leak. A replacement for HFCs is in the pipeline, but not in full production yet.
So, just bringing CO2 back to pre-industrial levels would not suffice, even without considering the now-reduced reflectivity at the north pole and increased CH4 emission (25x) from melting permafrost. We need more. Mirrors in space are a dangerous fantasy, as noted above. We can't get the SF6 out of the air. We can't get the HFCs out of the air. We can't remove enough CO2 from the air to compensate for those without causing a different sort of eco-catastrophe.
As it is, it is everything we can do just to build out solar and wind power extraction systems, and, soon, storage for them. We will get electric-fired ammonia production going to fuel ships, and LH2 for aircraft, and carbon-neutral cement, and electric steel production, and get control of CO2 emissions.
But we will need to discover something more.