5 ms·
I wouldn't mind video conferencing with computer generated avatars. I don't video conference to know what the other person looks like, and in fact knowing what
by wongarsu 5y ago
I wouldn't mind video conferencing with computer generated avatars. I don't video conference to know what the other person looks like, and in fact knowing what they look like just creates lots of unnecessary bias. I do it for the cues from their gestures, facial expressions, the direction they are looking, etc. With a good tracking setup that works perfectly well today with digital avatars.
- lwhi 5y agoI like faces. Why deny a key part of being human?
- dheera 5y agoIf you don't know why one might want this, you might be a white male, or at least white, or at least male, or at least a member of the majority race in your locality. I've definitely wanted this on a few occasions, to avoid being discriminated.
- batch12 5y agoSo following this logic train, the only actual faces one may see would be white males. Everyone else gets a mask?
- dheera 5y agoMaybe? But I'm going to get what I wanted.
- batch12 5y agoWould that then just be a proxy for not being a white male and present the same problems? I am not sure what this solves to prevent discrimination.
- dheera 5y agoIt doesn't prevent discrimination, it just allows me to do what I want to do in the short term, e.g. raise funding for startups or get dream jobs or whatever. I mean if a VC hands me a term sheet or a hiring manager hands me a job and the ONLY thing I misrepresented is my face, I don't think they have any ethical grounds to retract their offer. Solving the discrimination problem is another matter, and will take years if not decades, my dreams cannot wait for that.
- batch12 5y agoGood luck to you. I am not convinced people would be more likely to give money or a job to someone when they have only seen an avatar, but what do I know.
- dheera 5y agoThey don't have to know it's an avatar. For most jobs if they make any decision based on how the candidate looks they are in the wrong. It's not any different from make-up, really, which is also hiding your real face, in a different way.
- batch12 5y agoIf you deceive someone by wearing a different face during an interview, I expect that you would not be hired. How do you prove you were the person interviewed?
- dheera 5y agoThere are plenty of ways to prove that, including stating a public key during the interview, interviewer signs it with their key, vice versa is done with the interviewer's key, and then the same is demonstrated in person with the same keys. Hell, how to do that can even be an interview question.
- 5y ago
- djmips 5y agoLooking white male, isn't enough if you go down that road. Accents, tone, pitch of the voice would also need to match
- dheera 5y agoThat's much easier if you've spent enough time in the US and basically "sound white" (whatever that means) but don't look white. But I imagine accent change could be another subject of a future deep learning project.
- pezezin 5y agoWhy is everything about race nowadays? Anyway, your comment is bullshit. I'm a white guy (actually from Spain, so I don't know if I qualify as "white" from the USA point of view) living in Japan, so I am the discriminated minority here (and yes, I have been a victim of minor racism), and I agree with GP. We humans evolved for face to face conversation, if racism is the problem, hiding behind a mask is not the solution.
- thaumasiotes 5y ago> I'm a white guy (actually from Spain, so I don't know if I qualify as "white" from the USA point of view) No, Spanish-speaking countries are considered nonwhite.[1] Portugal and France are both white; Spain not so much. Brazil is a hazier issue. (The reason is that Spanish speakers in the US don't tend to be Spaniards, and the laws were written in a sloppy way.) [1] Technically, the "Hispanic" category is not supposed to be exclusive with the various race categories. But that is how it is treated.
- user-the-name 5y ago> Why is everything about race nowadays? Because racism exists and is a real problem for lots of people. You don't fix that by pretending race doesn't matter, because in the lived experience of all of those people, it matters, a lot. They would love it if it didn't matter, but that is not what happens in reality.
- lwhi 5y agoThis is no solution. What happens when you need to meet face to face?
- vortico 5y agoAh yes, the solution to bias: Hide everyone's faces. That'll teach everyone to celebrate our differences.
- tyingq 5y agoThere is a crappy movie called "Surrogates" that goes down this path.