3 ms·
> The Smartest Man in Europe Is Very Cautious I first thought it was going to be an article about Grigori Perelman and about how we are all one step closer to
by paganel 15y ago
> The Smartest Man in Europe Is Very Cautious
I first thought it was going to be an article about Grigori Perelman and about how we are all one step closer to Apocalypse because he was very close to finding that there is indeed no foundation for Mathematics (or any similar conclusion that is way over my head in even trying to explain). Instead I stumbled upon an article about a rich heir to "a mercantile family" who talks about money, money, money. Not that's anything wrong with talking about money, but if that's we consider as the "smartest thing" in an entire Continent I think we have a problem.
- singular 15y agoThere is no foundation for Mathematics [1] :-) [1]: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Godel%27s_incompleteness_theorem http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Godel%27s_incompleteness_theore...
- praptak 15y agoGoedel's theorem is not about nonexistance of foundation in mathematics, it's about existence of true but nonproveable statements in every nontrivial formal system. One could imagine a hypothetical stronger result - maybe every nontrivial set of axioms can actually derive p^(not p)?
- singular 15y agoIANAM, but I do know it was an unassailable problem in Russell + White's efforts to found mathematics on a firm basis in Principia Mathematica [1]. [1]:http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Principia_mathematica#Consistency_and_criticisms http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Principia_mathematica#Consisten...
- oelewapperke 15y agoYou want to actually understand mathematics, here's what to do. Reading any theory, any theory at all. Look at the author. Do a wikipedia search. If the article starts with what a great philosopher they are, burn the article, wash your hands in holy water and beg for forgiveness. Their articles and books do not actually have a basis for their consistency except "LGTM", they're less than worthless, and can easily convince you that idiocies are real if you're not careful. And if you're careful you'll find a massive unproven leap in logic in the first sentence of the first page and you'll be unable to continue reading. Avoid philosophers like the plague. Including Russell, including Principia mathematica. Rip them to shreds if you find them in a bookstore. You'll be doing the world a big favor.
- yequalsx 15y agoProvided the axiom set is recursively enumerable. The second order Peano axioms for the natural numbers are complete.
- oelewapperke 15y agoEuhm ... sorry to doubt you here, but it does seem like you're flat-out wrong. Second-order peano arithmetic contains all the axioms you'd need for Godel's proof ... And frankly, though not 100% proved (yet?), it seems to me very clear that any numbering and arithmetic system that contains any form of infinity is doomed to be incomplete. So the only useful arithmetical fields that escape Godel are Zn.
- Estragon 15y agoBased on the biography and attitude, I assumed it was George Soros, who is pretty damn smart, financially. I could be wrong, though.