4 ms·
I wish sites would just disable commenting altogether, at least on certain topics. That's what CBC up here does on anything that's in any way related to race, g
by barbazoo 5y ago
I wish sites would just disable commenting altogether, at least on certain topics. That's what CBC up here does on anything that's in any way related to race, gender, climate, first nations, etc.
- jonny_eh 5y ago> CBC The Canadian Broadcasting Company: https://cbc.ca https://cbc.ca While it's a TV station, and a set of radio stations, they also provide a news website. > up here That would be Canada. Like Americans, many of us assume we're talking to Americans when writing online.
- prawn 5y agoI've run a sports forum for almost 20 years. For 18 years of that, it was with no-registration-required to post. There are methods and wordlists to discourage spamming and shadowbanning, but it was surprisingly tolerable all things considered. In recent years, anything pertaining to race or pandemic has been an absolute shitshow from local commenters and foreign agitators, but both are occasionally relevant to the forum (sports events being postponed or moved, etc) so I've been reluctant to can them completely. I eventually switched to registration-required, but in a way that no one noticed. But the other feature I added was flagging particular conversations as requiring a higher privilege level to post. Regular contributors can request a privilege upgrade to participate. This has helped.
- motogpjimbo 5y agoThe BBC News website similarly disables comments on any article that's even remotely controversial. While some would undoubtedly consider that a good thing to protect the quality of the conversation, I'm not so sure myself. UK citizens are forced by law to fund the BBC through what is effectively a tax on television ownership. In addition, the BBC's takes on certain issues are known to be quite out of step with the feelings of the majority of the UK population. Allowing the BBC to selectively disable comments on such articles, which are forcibly funded by the people who might like to comment on them, seems wrong on some level. I'd rather the BBC removed commenting across the entire site than have the power to remove comments on specific articles they know are going to result in disagreement.