4 ms·
"Censorship" has become incredibly tiring as a topic lately. Sure, freedom of speech is important and all, but in video game circles, if the skirt-length of a f
by dragontamer 5y ago
"Censorship" has become incredibly tiring as a topic lately. Sure, freedom of speech is important and all, but in video game circles, if the skirt-length of a female character is increased by a few inches, you'll get a bunch of trolls calling "censorship" of said character.
Case in point: Dead or Alive 6 vs 5, or Guilty Gear Strive vs Xrd. Apparently "Sony" is the big bad and is forcing developers to cover up more female characters or something. I honestly don't care but... really, this sort of thing is coming up these days. (Actually, the newest costume change was Pyra & Mythra's costumes in Super Smash Bros Ultimate, now that I think of it).
Its gotten ridiculous, and I can't trust the face of these "censorship" complaints very much anymore. Its like "Censorship" is used as a complain for anything and everything these days.
-----------
I think there can be a discussion about the appropriate amount of sexuality / sexiness in video game characters (especially the female characters). But as soon as the "censorship" trolls enter the discussion, its all over. Its just trolls all the way down, and the discussion dies.
-------
Anyway, I realize this is completely tangential to the discussion on this particular science blog. But I'm more of a video gamer, so I'm seeing more and more of this "censorship" talk around video game sites.
- lmilcin 5y agoIt might be tiring but it is also important. Believe or not, whatever we (people, collectively) decide to allow or disallow is very likely going to profoundly affect shape of freedom of expression for future generations.
- dragontamer 5y agoHere's my problem. If a developer (lets say, Koei Tecmo games), decides to make a video game (such as Dead or Alive 6) slightly less sexy than a previous video game (such as Dead or Alive 5), is that "censorship" ?? Or is this a *COMPLETELY DIFFERENT* discussion, and the "censorship" trolls are just trying to cause outrage in a completely unrelated subject matter? Ditto with Nintendo and their treatment of Pyra & Mythra in Xenogears vs Smash Ultimate. Its like Smash Ultimate is aimed at a younger audience, so Nintendo wanted those characters to have slightly less sex appeal in Smash Ultimate, while having slightly more sex appeal in Xenogears. So yelling "censorship" at the top of your lungs because you don't like Pyra's tights in Smash Ultimate is just... counterproductive. (For those unaware: The original character design doesn't have tights, so she shows a bit more thigh in Xenogears. So the controversy is whether or not adding the tights to Smash Ultimate is "censorship"). -------- That's the thing about "censorship". Its outrage trolling these days. You yell censorship not to make a point or to move the discussion forward. You yell it to close off the discussion and derail it. Its a troll move, not really about discussing underlying issues.
- lmilcin 5y agoNo, making your game slightly less sexy is not censorship if it was your own choice. If you decide not to say something, this is not impinging on your freedom of speech, it is you using your freedom to make that decision. Some people call this self-censorship which I do not count as censorship. When I decide not to talk politics at the office or at home party that might be self-censorship but in reality is my own choice. Yes, censoring trolls that say vaccines are harmful is still censorship, regardless of how sure you feel about being right. Understand that any idea had to start at some point with a single person or small number of people. Women demanding their right to vote, it had to start somewhere. It also means everybody else was of another opinion. Suppressing speech, beliefs, just because you don't agree with them risks to cut those movements before they have ability to gain traction and in effect slow human progress.
- vorpalhex 5y agoSelf-censorship is censorship. If you know stating some position (I support candidate X) is going to result in being harassed, death threats or other injury and you choose to not engage in speech, that is still being censored.
- lmilcin 5y agoYou made decision to not get involved in the conflict. That's not censorship. Have others been allowed to state that position? Has some body tried to suppress that speech? If yes, then they (but not you) have been subject to censorship.
- vorpalhex 5y agoI was trying to remember the name for this when I wrote the original comment, and now I recall it. A chilling effect. It started as a legal concept but it applies to censorship as well. It's sufficient to count as censorship if you simply punish legal speech sufficiently that the populace self-censors. [1]: https://mtsu.edu/first-amendment/article/897/chilling-effect https://mtsu.edu/first-amendment/article/897/chilling-effect
- AdmiralAsshat 5y agoPossibly. But I think most of us would rather pick another hill to die on than deciding that removing visible cleavage on a hyper-sexualized 13 year-old is "censorship".[0] [0] https://kotaku.com/xenoblade-chronicles-xs-director-on-localization-change-1796157409 https://kotaku.com/xenoblade-chronicles-xs-director-on-local...
- lmilcin 5y agoYou are not forced to comment on a HN post dedicating to censoring comments if you "would rather pick another hill to die on".
- Jiro 5y agoNo Japanese creator is going to reply "well, I would rather that the company that pays my salary not censor me", unless they have such star power that they know they can say this with no repercussions, so I'm skeptical of such claims. Not to mention that Japanese creators often don't know much about a problem other than what the company tells them. If Nintendo tells them "we need to do this or people in the West won't buy it," the creator will believe them, and say that they don't mind the censorship because it's necessary, even if Nintendo is lying through their teeth when they say that.
- dragontamer 5y agoNintendo is a bad example actually, because a lot of the "sexy" games are moving to Nintendo Switch and away from Sony PS4/PS5.
- FriendlyNormie 5y agoThank you for your completely irrelevant rant about a totally different definition and context of “censorship” that has nothing to do with censoring comments or speech which you somehow use as your entire justification for dismissing complaints involving that. You. Fucking. Retard.
- vlunkr 5y agoI'm sure you already know this, but that is not censorship. By definition, censorship is done by a government or some other outside entity. In the case of video games, it's the companies themselves making these changes to make them more marketable. TLDR: Capital G Gamers are idiots.
- vorpalhex 5y ago> Censorship is the suppression of speech, public communication, or other information. Censorship can be self imposed, eg Hollywood. And please don't throw ad hominem attacks at groups of people. Not only are you incorrect but it's childish.
- commandlinefan 5y ago> By definition, censorship is done by a government or some other outside entity That's not the definition of censorship - by definition, the video game maker in that case chose to self-censor. It's debatable whether or not that was a stupid decision or a wise decision, but there's no other word to describe it.
- kbelder 5y agoI hate it when companies do this, and they've been doing it a lot recently. I think my irritation comes from the fact that they're not doing it to make their customers happier with their product; they're doing it to avoid a storm of controversy from people who in large part aren't their customers. They have the right to do it, I understand it, and I might do the same in their place, because who wants a twitterstorm against their new product? But it's still annoying.
- dragontamer 5y agoIn the case of DOA6, it was before the alleged Sony "censorship" rumors of recent years. So keep that in mind, DOA6 was released a couple of years ago. The DOA6 example is almost entirely a case where Koei Tecmo wanted to be taken "more seriously" as an eSports game. Now maybe you can argue that "eSports players don't play Dead or Alive", and only "casual players looking for sexiness play Dead or Alive". But... I know that's not true either. Some of my friends who were into fighting games were "serious" about their Dead or Alive combos / practice regiments / matchups / etc. etc. There are plenty of serious players in that group. On the one hand: you got the "casuals" who pay $1000 for hundreds of costumes (Dead or Alive 5 was very famous for its DLC costumes). "eSports" players didn't do this, because they were more focused on the combo practice rather than playing dress-up with these characters. (In contrast, the players who did find the characters sexy, probably did play "dress up" more often and were into buying these costume packs). Frankly: its not a clear cut case. I could very well see Koei Tecmo wanting to appeal to the eSports players, hoping that it'd propel their game to newer heights in the "serious" eSports ring (ex: Marvel vs Capcom 3 / Street Fighter 4). Furthermore, the "casual" audience argued that they deserved more influence than the eSport ambitions BECAUSE they spent all of this money on DLC costumes with no in-game effect aside from "playing dress up". --------- In contrast, Bandai's "Soul Calibur" series never really had this issue. Soul Calibur can remain "sexy costume / dressup" for casuals, because Bandai's "serious" esports game was Tekken. (And while Soul Calibur's "serious" players definitely held side tournaments, they were always seen as 2nd class citizens compared to Tekken at the eSports events). --------- Nintendo's "Smash Ultimate" example is kinda funny, because its clear that Nintendo doesn't really want Smash Ultimate to be an eSports title (despite it taking up a big eSports following). Nintendo's eSports ambitions are Pokken Tournament (Pokemon fighting game) and Splatoon. Despite not wanting to be an eSports title, Nintendo clearly is aiming the game at younger audiences, so various characters are a bit more covered up in Smash Ultimate (ex: Bayonetta, Pyra, etc. etc.)
- ttt0 5y agoWhat I find weird in our current status quo is how "sex work" and having an OnlyFans account is considered empowering, but a game about fictional characters like DOA is considered sexist and misogynist. I never played it, so I might be wrong, but isn't that why people play DOA in the first place? To see sexy women? So how's that trolling?
- dragontamer 5y ago> I never played it, so I might be wrong, but isn't that why people play DOA in the first place? To see sexy women? So how's that trolling? There's a fair number of players who were hoping that DOA would become an esport: akin to Marvel vs Capcom 3, Street Fighter 4, or Smash Ultimate. There's a discussion that must be had about DOA's excessive "sexiness" and whether or not that is hurting it from becoming a mainstream esports game. DOA 6 focused on the "cinematography", which caused an outrage because their fans wanted more emphasis on the sex-appeal (which was absolutely the focus of DOA2 through DOA5: "boob physics" was front and center in a lot of marketing) Now don't get me wrong, the discussion should be had. But... this isn't about censorship at all. This discussion ultimately comes down to the skirt length and bust size of Kasumi / Marie Rose (and other characters). To derail the discussion by yelling "censorship" is unnecessary, and unhelpful hyperbole.
- slg 5y ago>What I find weird in our current status quo is how "sex work" and having an OnlyFans account is considered empowering, but a game about fictional characters like DOA is considered sexist and misogynist. The difference is consent. A person is free to objectify themselves and doing so can be empowering. A person should be extremely cautious about creating fiction to objectify a group of people to which the author does not belong as this can be exploitative and have societal repercussions. I know next to nothing about the developers for the DOA franchise, but I am guessing there would be less controversy if the studio had a larger female presence.
- ttt0 5y agoWhat consent? We're talking about fictional characters here. Is Dwarf Fortress an immoral game, because the authors are not a part of groups like dwarfs, elves and goblins? And some in-game events may occur without the consent of those characters? edit: Got rate limited for some reason and can no longer respond, so I'm just going to edit this post: What does the "consent from the group" even mean? Do you have to make a poll, write to the CEO of Women™ or something? Seriously. Can I even include women if I'm making an amateur video game as a one-man effort (no pun intended), and I myself am not a woman? And for dragontamer, I guess you got your answer. I don't personally care about video games at all, but some people believe this is immoral and rape-like (no consent), so it's not surprising to me that someone calls it censorship and points out the parallels to back when people tried to censor violence in video games and whatnot. edit2: > You are free to make whatever game you want. The public is free to respond to your game however they want. You aren't going to get many complaints if you "even include women". If you objectify those women, you might get met with those complaints. If you were a women objectify women, you can at least claim that your are taking control of the objectification. That is viewed as a valid excuse by a lot of people much like how I mentioned people in a minority group are generally allowed to make jokes at that groups expense. So I should take it as roughly "the consent from the group means that the group isn't going to cancel you"? But if that's the case then why is it called "consent"? Isn't the entire point of consent to ask before you take action? It's like saying "I'm going to force you to have sex with me, if you don't go to the police then it means you consented to it". And from my understanding that's literally what rape culture is.
- alisonatwork 5y agoI think the complaint of "censorship" might have some basis if the reason why the company changed the character models is to comply with obscenity laws in the most conservative country in which that particular game will be distributed. There is a case to be made that in a world where creators sell their content globally, conservative regions with a lot of potential customers might influence content that ends up also being sold in liberal regions. This might not be censorship, exactly, but it is an annoying side-effect of a globalized information economy. Instead of the world opening up and becoming more liberal, it might actually end up becoming more conservative, if transnational corporations decide that catering to the lowest common denominator is a more profitable route. I suppose the workaround for consumers is the same as it is for movies - to avoid the content designed to appeal to the broadest audience, and seek out indie creators who are still willing to cater to a more local or specialized audience. In the mean time, I do think it's fair for consumers to advocate for generally more liberal themes in games, although I'm not sure the sexiness of an outfit is really the hill to die on.