4 ms·
It's not like people didn't warn that this would happen. You need to have principles on your side and back those principles even when "bad" people enjoy those
by mc32 5y ago
It's not like people didn't warn that this would happen.
You need to have principles on your side and back those principles even when "bad" people enjoy those principles.
You will not go far if instead of principles you back people because they agree with you on a particular topic.
- BugsJustFindMe 5y agoWell, if the principle is "don't lie", then "expose people who lie" doesn't violate the principle. It remains to be seen, however, whether Google actually has any principles other than making money.
- mc32 5y agoConspiracy theories are the bane of any society. But, the problem is often one does not know in advance if a conspiracy theory is just a crackpot theory or there is something to it. To wit: SARS-CoV-2 lab origin. mRNA vaccine heart inflammation. Both were denounced as conspiracy theories by the CDC and flagged by YT (and other social media) the CDC has revered on both examples.
- BugsJustFindMe 5y agoI agree with all of that. And there's a big difference between e.g. "dismissing lab leak out of hand is wrong because there's a lot of circumstantial evidence of government suppression and coverup", which many people currently say based on available evidence, and "this is definitely a Chinese bioweapons program" which many people also currently say without any factual evidence whatsoever. I worry a lot about people and organizations who lump them together, but I'm fine with silencing the latter. The CDC is a political organization controlled by the executive branch that happens to be staffed partly with people who call themselves scientists[0]. The unwavering faith that people put into political organizations is its own tragic issue. [0] - In the same way that many programmers are terrible at being programmers, many scientists are terrible at being scientists.
- nwienert 5y agoThe only difference is that you personally believe the evidence to be less strong than others… there’s no fundamental difference, just difference of opinion. If a socialist candidate is assassinated in South America and someone on YouTube says “this was the American imperialist regimes doing” without evidence, I wouldn’t assume they are right, but I’d see it as an opinion based on historical evidence that I’d hate to see censored. This applies even if someone claims it was aliens!
- BugsJustFindMe 5y ago> The only difference is that you personally believe the evidence to be less strong than others… there’s no fundamental difference, just difference of opinion. The differences are in the type of claim being made and in whether the reasons given are real or made up and in whether the reasons actually support the claim and in the systemic harm caused by being wrong. All of those differences matter.
- nwienert 5y agoI never made a claim they had more or less evidence, you ignore the South America example entirely which is that it’s ok to have circumspect evidence but extrapolate based on priors. There’s no place for silencing opinions, and those are opinions that all have different levels of evidence. That you tend to weigh certain evidence differently is your own stance, not objective fact. To try again, let’s say someone is a “body language expert”. I don’t really believe that to a large degree, but fine. They post a YouTube clip showing the Chinese gov denying the lab leak and say “oh man I can tell based on X, Y, and Z their body language is a total giveaway that this was intentional!” Again, I don’t believe it. But it doesn’t matter. Whether they think it’s aliens because they saw some cloud trails or tea leaves or whatever, it’s all a matter of degree. The lab leak was shut down under the same premises. “Our” evidence is strong, and “their” evidence is conspiracy theory. Except it wasn’t. So I don’t trust anyone, you included, to be the decider of valid evidence. I’ll sort through it myself.
- 5y ago
- BitwiseFool 5y agoCompounding the problem is that much of the knowledge we hold today was once considered outlandish and false... often with great conviction from those in trusted positions of power. Plate tectonics, doctors being required to wash hands, babies cannot feel pain and don't require anesthesia, and so much more. This doesn't mean all fringe theories are true, of course, but I do caution people in thinking that our current understanding is unequivocally correct just because there is a scientific consensus.
- a_conservative 5y ago> Conspiracy theories are the bane of any society. Can you provide some examples of this? I'm having a hard time understanding how or why conspiracy theories are so problematic. Have they always been problematic? I would love to hear some historical conspiracy theories and their deleterious effects.
- jml7c5 5y agoTwo that come to mind immediately: Jewish blood libel, and conspiracy theories about Christians that led to Roman persecution.
- a_conservative 5y agowouldn't the target of the conspiracy theory have to be in power somehow? What differentiates between false beliefs and a conspiracy theory?
- jml7c5 5y agoConspiracy theories are a subset of false beliefs. (Well, except where there actually is a real conspiracy.) The target need not have actual power - as long as the belief involves some form of "people are colluding secretly" (aka "conspiring"), it's a conspiracy theory.
- mc32 5y agoI don’t have any specific. But I imagine that rumors about illegitimate heirs would have been one in order to get access to or deny power. Also Ancient Rome and demonizing political opponents (some the depravity ascribed to some of the emperors were exaggerations).
- elliekelly 5y agoDid YT or anyone else ban comments or posts about the lab leak theory or vaccine heart inflammation? Sure people initially dismissed it but the proponents of those theories seem to have not only kept talking but have presented enough credible evidence to change minds about dismissing their theories out of hand. And it seemed to hit a tipping point almost overnight. One day the lab leak was nonsense and the next it was put forth as a possibility worth considering. Isn’t that a sign that things are working? Don’t get me wrong, it absolutely sucks to feel “silenced” and I’m sure it sucks even more to feel silenced when you are indeed correct or at least aren’t as dead wrong as others claimed. But isn’t the crux of the free speech “marketplace of ideas” that the “good” ideas will find listeners and gain traction anyway? Even when “everyone” initially disagrees or thinks you’re crazy. Because that’s free speech, too. You have a right to say things even if they sound kind of crazy and I have a right to say “hey, that sounds crazy!”
- bananabiscuit 5y agoYes, talking about COVID lab leak on Facebook could get you banned until very recently. https://www.msn.com/en-us/news/politics/facebook-lifts-ban-on-wuhan-lab-leak-posts-amid-renewed-debate-over-theory/ar-AAKq24i https://www.msn.com/en-us/news/politics/facebook-lifts-ban-o... Also if you scroll down about 40% of the way here: https://m.facebook.com/help/230764881494641/ https://m.facebook.com/help/230764881494641/ you will see that claiming that the vaccine has negative effects is still a bannable offense.
- seattle_spring 5y ago> SARS-CoV-2 lab origin How come the folks who keep bringing this up don't also mention that the original "censored" claims were that the virus was both engineered and intentionally leaked?
- barbacoa 5y agoThis is the first major article about covid lab release dating to Jan of 2020. It was also the first article to be censored. Doesn't mention either of those. https://www.zerohedge.com/health/man-behind-global-coronavirus-pandemic https://www.zerohedge.com/health/man-behind-global-coronavir...
- seattle_spring 5y ago> the real reason behind the viral spread is because a weaponized version of the coronavirus was released by Wuhan's Institute of Virology (accidentally or not) Literally claims it's a manmade weapon released intentionally in the first paragraph. Edit: it seems pretty obvious that article was banned because it's an unsubstantiated witch-hunt. It even gives the guy's number and urges the reader to harass him. Fwiw "they were just asking questions!" is not a valid argument.
- alentist 5y ago> Literally claims it's a manmade weapon released intentionally in the first paragraph. Do you know what the word "accidentally" means?
- seattle_spring 5y agoThe term "or not" is them suggesting it may not have been an accidental leak. Edit: ah you're the troll I unfortunately encountered yesterday. Won't be engaging further, have a good evening!
- alentist 5y ago
- filoleg 5y agoLies as they are online are not absolutes, just look at fact-checking. Tons of things can be misinterpreted (whether intentionally or not) as a lie or truth depending on your leaning even by "authoritative" fact checkers. Here is a concrete example from NBC[0]: their fact-checkers say Trump's statement about Clinton "acid-washing" her email server was a lie, because her team actually just "used an app called BleachBit". Do you see the point I am making? 0. https://twitter.com/NBCNews/status/785299709342654465 https://twitter.com/NBCNews/status/785299709342654465
- mc32 5y agoThe funniest of these I saw what a Satire site getting a suspension because their satirical take wasn't literally true. That's one of the main tools of satire.
- ehutch79 5y agoGoogle is a for profit business, not a person. Profit is it's sole purpose for existence.
- Mountain_Skies 5y agoIt's quite common, almost to the point of universality, that employees of a company have motivations that aren't 100% inline with those of the company. Google might care about profit above all else but many of its employees care about using the power of Google to advance their own interests rather than maximizing Google's profits.
- peakaboo 5y agoGoogle is also getting rid of all privacy and doing research into robots and AI that will patrol the human race in the near future. They are the backbone for a future where humans are constantly watched.
- prestigious 5y agoDon’t lie is very difficult to determine though. The vast majority of things are unknown or unknowable. Did Epstein kill himself? No one knows.
- splistud 5y agoSo your assumptions are so correct that any response by Google that you don't agree with are about principles rather than your assumptions?
- ohhhhhh 5y agoNot Youtubes job to determine what is truth and a lie, but they obviously think it is
- Noos 5y ago...what did they even lose by this? What's the point of right wing watch when more or less the entire news culture constantly puts focus on right wing conspiracies to debunk them, to the point of probably giving them more visibility than they rightly should get. If anything they could probably point out and say "hey, we are balanced!" in the same way reddit could by banning chapotraphouse after thedonald, but people who are on that site still know which way the wind blows.