6 ms·
These are neither the engineering nor political problems at the core of climate change, however. The biggest, at least in the US, is land use and allowing hous
by epistasis 5y ago
These are neither the engineering nor political problems at the core of climate change, however.
The biggest, at least in the US, is land use and allowing housing to be built close to jobs, in multi-use zoning, that allows people to go about their day without a car. That's the political third rail that even environmentalists fear to touch. Suburbia is unsustainable and we must allow more urbanization, and that will make all the rest of the challenges far easier than even stopping population growth. Because urbanized populations consume far less resources, need far less carbon even with current technologies. And it will make the transition to renewables much easier.
Meat is an order of magnitude less impact than our bad land use, at least in the US.
And nuclear is a lost cause. Even if we double our construction rate every year, it's not going to catch the tail of storage, solar, and wind in the time span we need to shift off carbon. And our current nuclear fleet is aged and ready to be decommissioned, even replacing our current nuclear fleet would require huge growth in an industry that doesn't know how to complete projects, much less scale and get cheaper. This is not a political problem, it's an industry problem.
Population growth, similarly, isn't much related to our immediate climate action. We need static change in the next two decades, and telling everybody that there are no more kids entering the workforce in order to actually execute this transition would be disastrous. Say no more children are born for the next 20 years, and population drops, I don't know, 20%. I don't see that she distribution being set up to tackle the future challenges of the world. Population growth is already peaking, and the best thing to accelerate that is to industrialize the high population growth countries with green industries, and urbanize their populations.
- chickenpotpie 5y agoGonna need a citation on that one. Commuting doesn’t hold a candle in CO2 production compared to industrial manufacturing and agriculture
- epistasis 5y agoI'm mainly focused on California, with a bit of a look at the US. Transportation is the biggest single sector source of emissions, and completely dwarfs agriculture: CA (41% of emissions): https://ww2.arb.ca.gov/ghg-inventory-data https://ww2.arb.ca.gov/ghg-inventory-data US (29% of emissions, PDF page 3): https://www.epa.gov/sites/production/files/2021-04/documents/us-ghg-inventory-1990-2019-data-highlights.pdf https://www.epa.gov/sites/production/files/2021-04/documents... Industry is a big emitter as wel, but it also dwarfs agriculture. And since California is such a major agricultural exporter, it's not like it's offloading their agriculture emissions. When I see people talking about meat as a big contributor to emissions, I assume that they are trying to drive a political wedge to stop any climate action. Not eating meat has a small effect for the climate, but causes absolutely massive political and cultural backlash. And it's quite likely that we will become carbon negative by 205-2060 without decreasing meat consumption.
- chickenpotpie 5y agoThat’s because those statistics are ignoring CO2 from economic activity. A Californian buys a computer manufacturered in Asia and these statistic only count the CO2 created to move it from the harbor to their house. All the CO2 from manufacturing, mining, and transporting it across the ocean are ignored.
- epistasis 5y agoSo I take it that you agree that transportation dwarfs agriculture? As far as Foreign imports of consumer goods accounting for a huge chunk of our carbon, that claim has never held up when I investigated it. In particular, Our World in Data had some fantastic plots showing that, though I don't have time to locate them at the moment. Could I turn the tables on you and ask for some substantiation of the claim that import of consumer goods is a major source of emissions attributable in the US? Because the amount of carbon that goes into making a computer seems pretty trivial compared to that of making a car, and from burning a gallon+ a day. Also, for evidence of the inherent sustainability of urban areas over suburban areas, check out these maps: https://coolclimate.berkeley.edu/maps https://coolclimate.berkeley.edu/maps I forget if they account for carbon from imported goods or not, but it's a consumption based inventory, rather than the typical production based inventory.
- epistasis 5y agoI found a bit of time to do some digging. My conclusion: US transportation is about 7x the emissions of the products we import from China. The embodied carbon in Chinese exports peaked in 2008, and has been decreasing, the most recent estimate I found was 1.4Gt in 2015 [1]. This is already less than the US transportation emissions of 1.7Gt in 2015 (from the EPA PDF I linked above). And the US share of that 1.4Gt is only about 18% (409/2273B$ [2]), for about 0.25Gt of CO2 equivalents. [1] Fig 1C https://agupubs.onlinelibrary.wiley.com/doi/full/10.1029/2018GL077915 https://agupubs.onlinelibrary.wiley.com/doi/full/10.1029/201... [2] https://wits.worldbank.org/CountryProfile/en/Country/CHN/Year/2015/Summary https://wits.worldbank.org/CountryProfile/en/Country/CHN/Yea...
- 5y ago