4 ms·
Calling the presentation "playful and light" is not how I, or most of the internet, would describe it. The presenters felt like they were on the verge of tears,
by gjsman-1000 5y ago
Calling the presentation "playful and light" is not how I, or most of the internet, would describe it. The presenters felt like they were on the verge of tears, it was strangely off-putting, and the corporate emotion in the presentation was cringeworthy. And that's if you could even watch it without the stream crashing.
- intellirogue 5y agoIt really was off-putting the way the main guy was saying words like "this is so exciting" while having zero facial emotion and a dead look in his eyes. Felt like somebody was holding a gun to his head and making him read off a prompter.
- gjsman-1000 5y agoI'm actually wondering if Stratechery watched the same presentation. I don't think anyone could watch the same presentation and call it "playful" or "light."
- prepend 5y agoIt reminds me of the new customer support script where they make them use empathetic words. “ Awesome, let me help” and “ Thats frustrating” sound worse coming from humans that don’t care.
- agumonkey 5y agoI've seen this pattern often in the last decade. This era is reciting not living
- vxNsr 5y agoIf you don’t know, that’s just how his face always looks, he’s not a super emotive guy.
- signal11 5y agoYou don't always have to smile or emote to project engagement. If you look at him introducing the Surface Laptop 2 at about 1m30s[1] through to 2m -- the passion and energy is unmistakable. Listen in particular to his voice and how he's moving around, and his palms. Compared to that, and especially to a casual observer, he looked disengaged at the Win11 launch event. But it's probably a consequence of having to perform in front of a camera and not be able to move around as much. [1] https://youtu.be/UtmTlcr1NkU?t=90 https://youtu.be/UtmTlcr1NkU?t=90
- smcl 5y agoAll the Microsoft presentations have that now - every second sentence describes something as “awesome”. It’s really off-putting, I don’t mind if someone is feigning enthusiasm but they lay it on so thick
- signal11 5y agoThat was Panos Panay who’s usually extremely engaged. I don’t know if it was a conscious decision — he did look like he was speaking at a funeral.
- tupac_speedrap 5y agoDefinitely, the whole presentation had a weird culty vibe to it. I couldn't take it seriously when the presenter was gushing over Windows so much.
- gjsman-1000 5y agoReddit thinks of a lot of things, but now they are mocking Panos by calling him Thanos, and Microsoft didn't help considering over 50% of PCs don't meet the system requirements.
- dcastonguay 5y agoI enjoy watching Apple's keynotes with the presenters delivering extremely polished and scripted rundowns of each new product and feature; they come across as having tailored their emotions to fit the desired tone of the presentation. It's very different to me from the way that Panos comes across when he presents things. I must be in the minority here, but I actually find it very refreshing to watch him speak in these sorts of events. I'm guessing that you are mostly talking about Panos when you mention that "presenters felt like they were on the verge of tears" since the other presenters seemed to me much more relaxed and "normal", for lack of a better term. From my own perspective he comes across as genuinely being excited about the work they're doing and doesn't seem to have a problem falling into his own rhythm while presenting. Intellirogue's comment mentioning his facial expressions also made me realize that his presentation style might just be closer to what I see in myself; I find myself in situations quite frequently where I am genuinely excited about something and those around me think that I'm feigning excitement. Whether or not his delivery style is universally more palatable to people, I personally feel more connected to it and there is something about it that ends up coming across to me as more relatable and sincere. I also think it might be a positive thing for us to leave open the possibility that some of these execs are as passionate about these things as anyone on HN would want them to be. I would love to have people at Microsoft and Apple and Google creating things that they feel are so incredible that they're on the verge of tears.
- gjsman-1000 5y agoI would wish that people would be that excited and felt that it was that level of incredible too. However, the presentation felt, to be honest, forced. Like the entire emotion was an act. Nothing in the presentation was something to cry over. Nobody in the audience is ecstatic, nearly crying, about how Teams is built in to the OS, or that the Start Menu button is now in the center and how that now puts you in the center (his words). We all know this isn't a big deal and yet he's so emotional about it, and that's off-putting and makes it feel fake and forced. It's an extreme reaction to details that, frankly, most of us are looking on in horror over. Upsetting 26 years of muscle memory is a good idea? Building Teams into Windows, which almost no family uses and is a resource hog, is a good idea? A good idea so good it's worth trying not to cry over?
- 5y ago
- andix 5y agoThey tried way too hard to copy Apple events. And they failed really bad.
- krferriter 5y agoApple events can be pretty cringe too
- birdyrooster 5y agoBut they are cringe in the way a Pixar movie is, its kinda meant to be hokey at times to humanize the presenters without trying to be too smart. They understand the image they are presenting really well whereas Microsoft has no idea what they are fumbling into.
- whywhywhywhy 5y agoFew things are more cringe than that mission impossible sequence from the one last year. Worrying the amount of yes people that must have got through to be made.
- jiriro 5y agoMission Impossible?! :-o That’s James Bond of course :)
- mjfl 5y agoyeah I was going to say Tim Cook puts on an excited hopeful demeanor that can also be interpreted as being terrified, which is probably true.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- sgerenser 5y agoStream crashing was pretty bad. I work at Microsoft (not in anything related to Windows) and had to watch it on YouTube.