3 ms·
"Although he wears a Nazi uniform and speaks German well, he gives himself by a minor detail: his fingers." I thought perhaps the author was going to discuss c
by 1vuio0pswjnm7 5y ago
"Although he wears a Nazi uniform and speaks German well, he gives himself by a minor detail: his fingers."
I thought perhaps the author was going to discuss comparison to real world fingerprints. Here's are a few questions for readers: First, how much can a "device fingerprint" be used to identify a person. Is it identifiying a device, or only the person who is using it. How do we know who is that person. Second, is a "device fingerprint" like a real world one where someone can chop off someone else's finger and, as seen in popular TV/film entertainment, use it to gain entry into some highly restricted area. Third, assuming the answer is yes, what stops the collector of a "device fingerprint" from mis-using it. As long as she can make network connections appear to be coming from a plausibly genuine IP address, how would anyone distinguish a fraudulent user of the "device fingerprint" from an "authentic" one. (For example, the collector of the fingerprint could use it to impersonate the true owner of the device.) At least with real world fingerprints, they are physically attached to our person. Neither copying and re-using them nor stealing someone's finger is trivial. And generally online advertising firms are not in the practice of collecting real world fingerprints; those taking real world prints are often government agencies. We may have certains protections under the law against the government. We cannot make the same claims about "device fingerprints".
As a user, I have not found that very many websites/endpoints that I use require any sort of complex fingerprint. I can retrieve the data I want without using a bloated graphical browser, running Javascript or sending a bunch of gratuitous HTTP headers. I send only two: Host and Connection. I cannot remember the last time this did not work. I never see any ads. As such, I struggle to understand all the fuss about "device fingerprints". This is voluntary data transfer to advertisers. If we send all sorts of data to websites/endpoints every time we make a simple HTTP request, then obviously that data is going to be used for something. The user generally has no legal/contractual control over how the data will be used. For example, the user may see ads as a result. Whereas if we keep requests brief and do not send heaps of gratuitous data, it stands to reason we would see less advertising, and certainly less targeted advertising.
- 1vuio0pswjnm7 5y agoNo answers just a couple of downvotes. If cookies can be stolen, so can cookies that contain "device fingerprints". "Identity theft" keeps getting easier through no fault of the consumer.