4 ms·
Binance is built and run by a nation increasingly seen as a foreign adversary. Fiat is run by democracies with elections, they're not pay-to-play oligopolies l
by echelon 5y ago
Binance is built and run by a nation increasingly seen as a foreign adversary.
Fiat is run by democracies with elections, they're not pay-to-play oligopolies like crypto.
Monetary and fiscal policies can be used to control the health of the economy. It's part of a wide system that also offers education, medical care, transportation, and many other utilities for actual people. Crypto offers what, exactly?
NFTs are worthless garbage nobody can legislate. Digital barcodes. Nation states have robust IP laws to protect and transfer ownership.
Crypto wastes energy. It also wastes human brains that could be solving more pertinent problems.
Gambling on crypto is as dangerous as it gets, and it's best we keep those without money to lose and financial knowledge away from these things. This isn't just a MLM, it's people's lives.
Quantum computing will render all of the blockchain useless anyway.
Crypto is a religion like meme to some and get rich quick scheme for many more.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- BuckRogers 5y agoTo address a few of your points. Crypto isn’t the new fiat, it’s the new gold. Most of the world does not have a robust nation state ensuring identities and ownership. It’ll be a massive boost to the world economy. NFTs will enable new interconnected markets that we haven’t even dreamed of yet. Not all crypto wastes energy, look into Cardano. Quantum computing will change everything, this isn’t exclusive to blockchains. There’s far more good that’s going to come out of this than bad with people gambling. The gambling is bringing attention to a major advance for humanity. Any press is good press in this case.
- echelon 5y ago> Quantum computing will change everything, this isn’t exclusive to blockchains. Governments will regulate it. They'll protect banks and financial institutions and jail anyone breaking into them. They won't give a shit about crypto.
- zkldi 5y ago> NFTs will enable new interconnected markets that we haven’t even dreamed of yet. How? My understanding of it is that it's a JSON document that points to a URL (which is just some webserver 99% of the time). How does this allow anyone to do anything novel that couldn't be done with a centralised database and an API?
- BuckRogers 5y agoOther than it's decentralized, it doesn't do anything different. That's a huge difference though. It will just enable true ownership and "liquidity", the same thing moving from the gold standard to fiat did. Liquidity, or increasing movement within the market did a lot of good. This conversation, and entire confusion around the utility of blockchains eerily reminds me of the now infamous challenge to Drew Houston that Dropbox was nothing more than a simple FTP with a share.[0] That's right, but also very wrong, missing the big picture. [0]https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=8863 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=8863
- echelon 5y ago> It will just enable true ownership and "liquidity", the same thing moving from the gold standard to fiat did. Liquidity, or increasing movement within the market did a lot of good. You can do that with a central clearing house much easier. In fact, then you'd be covered by US and probably international law against theft. > This conversation, and entire confusion around the utility of blockchains eerily reminds me of the now infamous challenge to Drew Houston that Dropbox was nothing more than a simple FTP with a share. You don't know the future, and this is a cop out of an argument. I'd be willing to bet you $1000 that the crypto market fizzles out in ten years. That it's no bigger than the banks and classic institutions, and that it's no larger than 2x its present market cap on June 28th, 2021. Including any new entrants. I'd also and separately be willing to bet you $1000 that there's a cryptographic attack (quantum or not) that scares everyone away from crypto. (And I think the US and China already know this.) I'll define "everyone" as a loss of institutional support by at least ten major stakeholders worth over 1B USD. (I think it would be much broader, but I want to define a measurable metric.) Ten years - want to make that bet?
- x4e 5y ago> Fiat is run by democracies with elections, they're not pay-to-play oligopolies like crypto. Cryptocurrencies are far more democratic: every time a transaction is submitted the network votes on whether or not it is valid using consensus mechanisms like proof of work or proof of stake. Fiat currencies are far less democratic: we can only vote for the people that will control them, not for what they will actually do with the currency. In the UK we do not vote for any positions in the Bank of England. > Monetary and fiscal policies can be used to control the health of the economy. It's part of a wide system that also offers education, medical care, transportation, and many other utilities for actual people. Crypto offers what, exactly? Monetary and fiscal policies can still operate without control of the currency, see Eurozone members having local policies. All it means is that they can’t arbitrarily print the currency. > NFTs are worthless garbage nobody can legislate. Digital barcodes. Nation states have robust IP laws to protect and transfer ownership. You misunderstand NFTs. It is not about intellectual property, it is about property. I can prove I have ownership of any token instantly and trustlessly. > Crypto wastes energy. It also wastes human brains that could be solving more pertinent problems. Many cryptocurrencies have negligible energy usage even over the entire network: see Nano. Even in Bitcoin, how is the energy usage a “waste”? It is holding the entire network together. And with human brains, cryptocurrency research has had very beneficial impact in other fields, see for example Monero’s development of RingCT and Bulletproofs+. And that is ignoring the fact that these brains are reshaping our entire financial infrastructure. > Quantum computing will render all of the blockchain useless anyway. Not really. Even if quantum computing was possible now Bitcoin would still be usable. And advancements are being made across all cryptocurrencies to secure them better.
- echelon 5y ago> Cryptocurrencies are far more democratic: every time a transaction is submitted the network votes on whether or not it is valid using consensus mechanisms like proof of work or proof of stake. When the votes take money or resources, that's not democratic. > Fiat currencies are far less democratic: we can only vote for the people that will control them, not for what they will actually do with the currency. In the UK we do not vote for any positions in the Bank of England. It's still representative democracy. You broadly know what politician's platforms are with respect to taxes, priorities, etc. If they do stuff you don't like, you vote them out. > Monetary and fiscal policies can still operate without control of the currency, see Eurozone members having local policies. All it means is that they can’t arbitrarily print the currency. So you lose your largest levers so you can make rich cryptowhales happy. Not good. > You misunderstand NFTs. It is not about intellectual property, it is about property. I can prove I have ownership of any token instantly and trustlessly. I don't respect your ownership. Neither does anyone else. When your keys leak - and they will -, you don't own it anymore. I'll much sooner use actual laws with records to buy my next house or car. > Many cryptocurrencies have negligible energy usage even over the entire network: see Nano. None of the major cryptocurrencies do despite claiming they would for years. I'm not holding my breath. > Even in Bitcoin, how is the energy usage a “waste”? It is holding the entire network together. When it's a network that many of us think is pointless, we're simply scratching our heads at this. > Monero’s development of RingCT and Bulletproofs+. More crypto junk and not a cure for cancer. > And that is ignoring the fact that these brains are reshaping our entire financial infrastructure. It doesn't need changing! We're increasingly building tools to serve the underbanked, and we need the government to continue with AML, KYC, etc. They serve a very valuable purpose of stopping terrorism, preventing bribery, etc. > Not really. Even if quantum computing was possible now Bitcoin would still be usable. If Satoshi's keys, or the Winklevoss keys, or Coinbase keys leak, it's game over forever. > And advancements are being made across all cryptocurrencies to secure them better. Better hurry. I don't think you realize the clock is ticking. If quantum beats you, it's game over. The network has no value when the trust and ownership can't be proven. Once crypto can attack keys, parties can't prove they own the address. Even if the network is forked or reverted, it's forever broken.