4 ms·
Her network didnt produce this, a friend who had a kid with the same disease produced this. Stop mis-attributing individual connections as being performed by th
by rektide 15y ago
Her network didnt produce this, a friend who had a kid with the same disease produced this. Stop mis-attributing individual connections as being performed by the collective. Those Nazi photographs that made the rounds recently? At the time they were heralded as a "wisdom of the crowds" moment, some great network shifting in to gear to crunch a hard problem. The case here & there are the same; it's not about the network, the collective knowledge, it's connecting to the right individuals.[1]
[1] http://lens.blogs.nytimes.com/2011/06/22/world-war-ii-mystery-solved-in-a-few-hours/ http://lens.blogs.nytimes.com/2011/06/22/world-war-ii-myster...
- Mz 15y agoActually, as a former homemaker who was routinely made to feel like an idiot by doctors and often felt like showing up at the hospital with a list of my academic credentials stapled to my lapel, my read on it is a little different. It looks to me like one of the big things was not the diagnosis per se but shoring up her confidence to stand up for her child and insist on being taken seriously. In addition to the excerpt below, earlier in the article she indicates her spouse was dismissing it as nothing. I called my family doctor and told him I was heading to the hospital. "I just have a Spidey sense," I said, "that he's really sick." Not a lie, but not the whole truth, either, though what was I going to say? Three of my Facebook friends think my kid has an extremely rare childhood auto-immune disorder which I just read about on Wikipedia, and since they all contacted me after I posted a photo of him on my wall, I'm going? It seemed … wrong! Reactionary. And yet as much as I wanted to be my usual mellow self, the immediacy of the Facebook feedback was enough to push me out the door.
- sneak 15y agoArguably the network vastly increases the chances that we will connect to the right individuals by disseminating information quickly and broadly. All "collective knowledge" exists in someone's brain somewhere, just like your gmail messages exist on three hard disks in three servers scattered somewhere among the millions. Hivemind? No. Individual mind, plugged into the hive, as a participant? Yes.
- nl 15y agoYes, the wisdom of the crowd is often about connecting with the right individual. One can argue that overall wisdom is always a function of speed of thought, and network effects often speed up contacting the right individual. But.. there are counterpoints too: For example, this is what Kasparov said about his 1999 chess match against "The World": It is the greatest game in the history of chess. The sheer number of ideas, the complexity, and the contribution it has made to chess make it the most important game ever played. Many critics agree with him. The important thing here is that no participant on "The World" team was remotely as highly rated as Kasparov on their own. http://michaelnielsen.org/blog/kasparov-versus-the-world/ http://michaelnielsen.org/blog/kasparov-versus-the-world/