3 ms·
I see a lot of comments from Americans criticizing this (with what seems like a knee jerk reaction to the title only) without actually knowing anything about th
by vlovich123 5y ago
I see a lot of comments from Americans criticizing this (with what seems like a knee jerk reaction to the title only) without actually knowing anything about the history of this law, how hate speech is defined, how enforcement works, what the limits are, what is defensible, and what cases have been tried under this law. Hint: controversial ones go up to the Supreme Court so it’s not even that hard to find the boundary cases of the law that paint it in the worst light.
I wish the discussion here was more interesting with people pointing out their problems with the law specifically rather than using vague arguments from first principles. Heck, one of the commenters implied this law makes Canada a shit country. Yet Canada has had a peaceful transition of power my entire lifetime and has tried to curb all extremist conduct in its society, whether Quebec separatists, white power bikers, or Islamic fundamentalists. I don’t recall hearing any stories indicating the RCMP or Canadian military has been infiltrated by white supremacists, whereas American law enforcement institutions at all levels seems to have this as a perennial problem.
Now it’s totally fine to say “these are the trade offs and this is the society I want to live in” but it’s important to acknowledge what those trade offs are and important to consider that few people actually want to live in a society run by libertarians ruling everything from first principles. The first amendment already has limits (eg yelling fire in a crowded theater).
These rules are about how to keep the discussion civil in public life and “hate” here means primarily speech that incites violence. It can also mean speaking disparagingly over any identifiable minority but that’s really a much narrower definition with smaller penalties, easier to defend, and fewer and lesser repercussions. I’m sure there are bad parts of the law but I would love to hear what the specifics are and how the law might be better constrained. Having lived in both places, I think America would benefit greatly from such a law. The challenge is that such constraints generally are non-starters within the framework of the US political and legal system because of the challenges in changing the first amendment. This has good and bad things and it’s entirely possible that US culture is not amenable to what works in Canada and that’s ok too. American laws that don’t work in Canadian culture wouldn’t be appreciated in Canada. For example, apologizing in a car accident in Canada used to be an admission of guilt which is something that was imported from America - that was reversed after massive popular protests against that.