11 ms·
Surfside official told residents building was safe, despite engineer's warning
- handmodel 5y agoI have no idea how these things work - so I'd really like some data on what percent of reports come back with similar warnings? Was this like the only building in the city to have such a bad report? Or do a sizable amount of buildings get warnings like this?
- WrtCdEvrydy 5y agoPublic records requests might get us this first info. It's probably not the only one to get such a report. I'm sure those have already been filed with the state if they exist, we'll see a fancy visualization from a major newspaper.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- xwdv 5y agoA lot of buildings have similar warnings but since they don’t collapse typically they will be ignored. The millennium tower in SF for instance, has been sinking and tilting for years, could probably just suddenly collapse one day not unlike this building in Surfside. The carnage would be immense though, as it is a massive building. At the end of the day, if you want full peace of mind you need to live in your own detached home and be aware of your own buildings issues and correct them.
- anm89 5y agoThis feels like "the front fell off". Why did this building collapse? Well, typically, they don't collapse.
- MattGaiser 5y agoDoes anyone have a copy of the report?
- KyleBrandt 5y agohttps://www.townofsurfsidefl.gov/docs/default-source/default-document-library/town-clerk-documents/champlain-towers-south-public-records/8777-collins-ave---structural-field-survey-report.pdf?sfvrsn=882a1194_2 https://www.townofsurfsidefl.gov/docs/default-source/default...
- MattGaiser 5y agoThank you.
- cm2012 5y agoI can see why the condo didn't jump on this. There's not a lot of urgency on the repairs in the letter, and certainly no warning of "do this or the structure will collapse".
- MattGaiser 5y agoWould that normally be in such a document? Plenty of engineering type documents I have read don't lay out threats in plain English nor do they try to add emotional urgency to them. Reminds me of this comment about how scientists sometimes understate how certain they are: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=7VG_s2PCH_c&t=785s https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=7VG_s2PCH_c&t=785s.
- acomjean 5y agoI was on a condo board. “Structual problems” in any report is a major red flag. Most buildings like this hire a management company to deal talk with the engineers and beside the report let the building know what it happening. a resident in the article says they took a 15 million dolllar assessment for repairs. So it’s not like it was being ignored. Also I’m wondering how the building insurers were handled. We had to replace a beam after extensive water damage in our 35 unit building. The units above were evacuated. Nothing collapsed but between the mold and water damage it was a nightmare. The building that collapsed had an twin. Supposedly better maintained but it will be interesting to see what’s going on with it. https://www.nytimes.com/2021/06/26/us/miami-building-collapse-neighbor-evacuations.html https://www.nytimes.com/2021/06/26/us/miami-building-collaps...
- diego 5y agoI'm sure every day in the US there are many, many reports of structures with damage that needs to be fixed immediately (my house was one of them). Almost all of them don't collapse. Obviously there is a problem with the credibility of the reports because of conflicting incentives. Inspectors are usually from construction companies who want to get work, so they will always find something wrong with a building. Edit: I don't understand the downvotes. Care to explain where you disagree? If thousands of daily reports warn of damage that must be fixed immediately and most are of no consequences (obviously) then the problem is that the reports don't accurately reflect the severity of the damage and the consequences of ignoring it.
- marcinzm 5y agoThis was an independent report done on behalf of the condominium by an engineering firm they chose to do the report.
- diego 5y agoThat does not contradict at all what I said. Why the downvote? Also, have you read the report?
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- marcinzm 5y ago>Also, have you read the report? Yes, it's publicly available and even linked to in this thread.
- diego 5y agoThat’s why I asked. I just read it myself and it doesn’t say that a catastrophe is imminent. It looks relatively mundane.
- acomjean 5y agoThe report is signed and stamped by the principal PE (professional engineer) not a construction company. These PEs are licensed by the state. It’s linked in the thread and is very readable. The report is rather matter of fact and lays out on page 7 what the problem was and what needs to happen to fix. This was 2018. Because a lot is unknowable these reports don’t tend to give a timeline for structural failure, but it does give some serious warnings.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- anonuser123456 5y agoHaving read the report, I am stopping my monthly contributions to NPR. This is straight up quote mining as far as I'm concerned. Nothing in the report would lead me to believe the structure was in imminent danger if I were a resident / board member / inspector etc. This is trash journalism. Edit: I would like to note the following for people following this story: The report author has stated: “among other things, our report detailed significant cracks and breaks in the concrete, which required repairs to ensure the safety of the residents and the public.” [1] However, such language about 'safety of the residents' is not present in his report. It has further been reported that the report author did not make such disclosures to residents at a condo board meeting. "Not once did Morabito share with us any sense of urgency, at least not the residents," Alvarez said, who lived on the 10th floor. "He never said the building was falling apart. He said the repairs were to bring the building up to today's standards of beauty." [2] 1. https://www.msn.com/en-us/news/us/surfside-condos-neighbors-fear-for-their-safety/ar-AALu6FO?ocid=uxbndlbing https://www.msn.com/en-us/news/us/surfside-condos-neighbors-... 2. https://www.msn.com/en-us/news/us/surfside-official-was-sent-disturbing-report-he-told-board-condo-was-in-good-shape/ar-AALvTOq https://www.msn.com/en-us/news/us/surfside-official-was-sent...
- cryptoz 5y agoAs an uninformed outsider, from the grand scheme of things, I wouldn't consider any coastal Miami property to be 'safe' regardless of any reports or ratings. The whole area is sinking, quite quickly overall. It's just common sense to disregard the results of any report deeming any building in the area 'safe', when the local government has been religiously denying that climate change even exists at all, and the insurance companies and report writers all have a short-term incentive to pretend nothing is wrong. I have not read the report. But I also don't need the report to know that no building in the area is safe enough for me to want to live there.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- cm2012 5y agoAgreed. That report was absolutely not a call to urgent emergency action. The closest is a warning that the building was built wrong and will eventually need to be fixed, 2.5 pages in.
- lxe 5y agoLooks like the flat waterproofing was only applicable to the pool deck slab according to the report... is NPR's interpretation misleading here?
- mdoms 5y agoThe report was issued in 2018 and warned that without expensive remediation the structural damage would expand exponentially. It may have started in the pool deck.
- phnofive 5y agoSomeone correct me here - the PE report identified multiple structural(?) concerns with the concrete in the parking garage, and this is conflated as evidence that the inspector knew the residential building was unsafe? Are they not separate structures? Did the garage collapse as well? The report makes clear that the integrity of the balconies on the residential structure couldn't be verified due to additional flooring materials installed by condo owners.
- robocat 5y agoHere's the report: https://www.townofsurfsidefl.gov/docs/default-source/default-document-library/town-clerk-documents/champlain-towers-south-public-records/8777-collins-ave---structural-field-survey-report.pdf https://www.townofsurfsidefl.gov/docs/default-source/default... Page 7 talks about the parking garage: "Abundant cracking and spalling of varying degrees was observed concrete columns, beams, and walls. Several sizeable spalls were noted in both the topside of the entrance drive ramp underside of the pool / entrance drive / planter slabs, included instances with exposed, deteriorating rebar Though some of this damage is minor, most of the concrete deterioration needs to be repaired in a timely fashion." Page 8 has relevant photos. The NPR article seems to focus on the deck slabs, but they are not particularly load-bearing so are unlikely to be the cause of the building to collapse. Edit: I guess it is possible the failure of a deck slab could collapse the columns inwards, but my guess is that the columns failed (bending or collapsing). Spalling on columns is a problem, especially if it is due to the column starting to fail. Disclaimer: I am not a structural engineer.
- nielsbot 5y agoOMG why is this not searchable text?! (Instead of pictures of the report's pages)
- cagey 5y agoOn the same site there is a file "email-related-2018-structural-field-survey-report.pdf" which contains/embeds the same report in searchable format, and on page 18 includes a table "ENGINEER'S ESTIMATE OF THE PROBABLE CONSTRUCTION COST" whose bottom line is TOTAL SUMMARY OF REMEDIATION PROBABLE CONSTRUCTION COST $9,128,433.60
- nielsbot 5y agoThat's a very specific number for an estimate :)
- aurizon 5y agoThe owners were tax evaders and bribers. Truth had no place in their vocabulary. They are dead and gone, current owners have to cope with this shitstorm A concrete slab, with water penetrated rebar will progressively fail in an exponential manner because rebar oxidizes = irrestible expansion and progressive expansion of the corroded area. Concrete and steel in these situations turn to dust and gravel with zero residual strength. If the other building has a pool in the same relative position it needs inspection ASAP. If no pool, they may be OK as that mechanism of failure would be absent. That said, the owners were such scumbags that other structural shortcuts may be hidden and will need to be dealt with
- pas 5y agoHow do we know they were bribers and tax evaders? Who were the owners exactly?
- aurizon 5y agoThey died a few years ago, and they were charged and settled. Root among these... https://www.google.com/search?q=florida+collapse+lawsuit&rlz=1C1CHBF_enCA924CA924&oq=florida+collapse+lawsuit&aqs=chrome..69i57.26025j0j15&sourceid=chrome&ie=UTF-8 https://www.google.com/search?q=florida+collapse+lawsuit&rlz...
- VortexDream 5y agoI'm disappointed at the level of discourse on HN about the topic. This amount of inane argument about "but the report doesn't seem that urgent" is what I would expect from Reddit.