2 ms·
The Ariane 5 failure was much more interesting than that. The designers recycled the Ariane 4's "inertial platform" IMU but neither adjusted its parameters for
by ncmncm 5y ago
The Ariane 5 failure was much more interesting than that.
The designers recycled the Ariane 4's "inertial platform" IMU but neither adjusted its parameters for expected Ariane 5 conditions, nor bothered to test it in such conditions. When flight accelerations exceeded Ariane 4's design parameters, the inertial platform sent debug messages down the channel meant for input to the engine gimbals. The engine gimbals interpreted those error messages as measurements, and steered accordingly, triggering destruction of the rocket and its payload of two (then) $200M+ satellites.
Many things could have prevented the failure. Checking the IMU specs against, or actually testing the IMU under, projected flight conditions would have revealed the problem. Not building the code in debug-mode, or not sending debug messages down some random control channel, or (on the receiving end) ignoring ill-formed input to the steering system, would have allowed the mission to complete.
In subsequent flights the software on the IMU was adjusted to expect accelerations that had been originally projected and did occur, and all was well. I don't know whether it will still send debug messages to the engines in case of a booboo, or whether the engines would ignore debug messages now.
Note that there was no actual need for the checks that resulted in the error messages. They were assertions of the sort that most Europeans of the time believed should be left in production code. I doubt this experience changed many of their minds.
- spr93 5y agoThe (possibly apocryphal) version I was told includes another layer: The problematic code was part of a last-minute kludge for the Ariane 4. The kludged code violated the Ariane 4's specifications. The Ariane 4 team knew this, but the code "couldn't" be triggered under the Ariane 4's conditions. A few years later, the code is pulled out for re-use in the Ariane 5. Apparently the kludge wasn't documented and no one bothered to confirm that the Ariane 4 code was actually up to the Ariane 4 spec. Had the Ariane 4 code been up to spec, the code reuse would have been fine.