2 ms·
> The catch22 has always been, nobody is using the software on Linux enough for enough people to be submitting feedback, while simultaneously, not enough people
by mschuster91 5y ago
> The catch22 has always been, nobody is using the software on Linux enough for enough people to be submitting feedback, while simultaneously, not enough people believe Linux is worth moving to.
The problem is somewhere else: Most Linux software doesn't have commercial backers but is written by people to a "works fine enough for me" standard, often with no UX/UI design at all or copying from Windows/OSX at best. As a result, "ordinary" people used to the Windows/OSX get frustrated because of wildly differing design principles between programs, no design principles at all (hello GTK), basic stuff (hello Bluetooth, suspend, audio) not working or atrocious performance. I'm nearly 30 now and don't have the free time to deal with kernel recompilations, trying out forks or whatever just to have a basic system I can work with anymore.
"You get what you pay for" is a thing you might look past when you're young and only have to choose how to divide your time between experimenting with hardware, gaming and getting wasted.
And in most of the time, I can't even pay for proper support because the developers only make their project on their own as a side gig, which means no project management and issue handling either other than filing issues in a pile of issues in Github (or, worse, mailing lists)...
Edit: another thing that comes to mind... people always complain why schools aren't using FOSS but proprietary software (Windows, MS Office). Well guess what, teachers don't have the time to waste on bugs (Libreoffice is nowhere near as polished as MS Office is), explaining to parents why their kids have to learn something different to what everyone else uses at home or to maintain a FOSS-based AD. Samba is decent for a setup in which you have a team of experienced engineers (since you save on licensing costs heavily), but nothing beats the simplicity of a MS Server GUI.
- eitland 5y ago> often with no UX/UI design at all or copying from Windows/OSX at best. This might be correct but also misleading. Since Ubuntu 6.06 the time to productivity and intermittance factor of Linux compared to Windows has been heavily in favour of Linux for many of us. Also UX has become one of the strong points of Gnome 2, later Mate and KDE 5/Plasma: reliable, no nonsense, just works, no designers using you as lab rats for their next great idea. I remember installing Windows back then and it was 4 hours solid work from starting what should be configuration of a "pre-installed" OS through one or two hours of waiting for actual installation to finally removing the last McAfee scareware. Windows keeps getting better in some ways but still struggles with confusing control panels (yep, plural) and a mix of old, reliable menus, that Office "menu" thing and the newer "cleaner" approaches without menus. Yes, this is one sided, but this is my view. PS: I use Windows at the moment and I have used it on and off since 1995 so I know it all too well.
- mschuster91 5y agoI don't get why you're downvoted, you got a very valid point. Personally, my daily drivers for the last six years have been various generations of Apple devices due to their supreme hardware build quality on the one side and Windows' nastinesses from "BIOS manufacturers and hackers can hide malware in ACPI tables" to "Windows 10 has no way to disable telemetry and has ads in the OS". > Windows keeps getting better in some ways but still struggles with confusing control panels (yep, plural) and a mix of old, reliable menus, that Office "menu" thing and the newer "cleaner" approaches without menus. Worst thing about the control panels is... it's been over 9 years since MS introduced the "new" Settings app. And yet, in 2021, it is still a mess with stuff hidden in old-style panels, somewhere in the new-style app, and other stuff deep within Group Policies. Why isn't everything available in Group Policies (which could also use a re-organization -.-) by default, with a well thought-out UI in the new Settings app by now?
- cptskippy 5y ago> Why isn't everything available in Group Policies (which could also use a re-organization -.-) by default, with a well thought-out UI in the new Settings app by now? It's a valid question but also not easily answered. The Control Panel still exists for a myriad of reasons. The Control Panel goes all the way back to Windows 3.x and contains interfaces to adjust things that while still supported are no longer relevant. The Control Panel also allows vendors to inject their own interfaces for managing settings, famously Synaptics Mouse Drivers and Flash. Getting rid of the Control Panel is easier said than done. Unless or Until they cut support for legacy systems, the Control Panel will probably persist even if the UI is hidden from the user behind Feature Activation or something else.
- binarybanana 5y ago>I can't even pay for proper support Have you actually tried? I guess it depends on what you consider "proper support", but if you made a reasonable offer I'd be surprised if most devs wouldn't be happy to add this or that feature, prioritize fixing some bug for you, or troubleshoot some other issue. I mean a lot of them do it for free (me included). I wonder what kind of software you expect support for, because in my experience most commercial end-user software has meh to terrible support. Exceptions are from small shops with passion projects or large companies, but only if you pay enterprise bucks. Like, how do you get Microsoft to fix a bug in Windows unless you are a big business customer yourself? You can certainly report bugs on their public forum and they might even acknowledge them, but some issues I've had were never fixed after years.. Ironically, with their open source stuff on GitHub you can directly report to their bug tracker where devs see it and it's more transparent what will get fixed and what won't. And then you could at least pay someone. No doubt, if you pay big money you get great 24/7 support but as an individual it's a mixed bag. YMMV.