3 ms·
I’m not arguing against these findings but the whole subject of nutrition leaves me frustrated at times. Ever tried to have 100% daily recommended intake of ev
by Waterluvian 5y ago
I’m not arguing against these findings but the whole subject of nutrition leaves me frustrated at times.
Ever tried to have 100% daily recommended intake of every nutrient? I suspect almost nobody achieves that.
And yet, despite this, and magnesium issues among likely many other issues, our species has never lived longer, grown taller, survived infancy, etc. more than we have now.
That being said, as we understand and overcome specific issues, I imagine we can become even healthier.
- canadianfella 5y agoI don’t understand what your point is.
- _tom_ 5y agoThat was 20 years ago. Life spans are falling, as is height.
- inglor_cz 5y agoNot everywhere is USA. In most developed countries, lifespans were going up until start of Covid, even though our vegetables are watery too. If I had to guess, I would say that life expectancy in USA would start climbing again if all the obese people managed to shave, say, 5 points off their BMI. Morbid and supermorbid obesity is horribly widespread there. Of course, it is more likely that the rest of the world catches up than that the US slims down.
- LAC-Tech 5y agoIn the United States? Average height in Central America quite a bit lower than the US, which is where most migrants to the US come from.
- opportune 5y agoYes, I've done it [0]. It's not too hard, surprisingly affordable and not bad-tasting, but you are limited in what you can eat, and it takes some research/optimization that I think is too much for 90% of people. First you need to learn how to get complete nutritional info. A lot of packaged food does not have a full nutritional profile on its packaging, and will omit many vitamins and minerals that could even be abundant in that particular food. To work around this you should use software like Cronometer [1] that allows you to look up nutritional info against various databases. In my experience the most comprehensive data source is the NCCDB, which has all important vitamins and minerals plus amino acid profiles. You can then estimate full nutritional info for most whole foods you buy in a store by converting the store-bought brand's nutritional info to the NCCDB info. For example if you buy oatmeal that says it has 150kcal per 0.5 cup, and the NCCDB info says 100kcal per X grams, you track your store-bought oatmeal as 1.5X grams per 0.5cup you eat. Note this only works for whole/single-ingredient foods, for processed foods with multiple ingredients the ratios of ingredients will vary too much from product to product for the NCCDB to be useful. You should also get a food scale so that you can properly measure food that has its nutritional info based on mass rather than by volume. They're pretty cheap, and you can do before/after measurements to make it less tedious to measure small things. Now that you can get full nutritional info for each whole food, the rest is an optimization problem across macros, micros, amino acids (important if you get a lot of protein from plant-bases sources), price/availability, and your personal preferences. Here is an example of a set of foods I eat almost every day which gives you a very strong macro/micro base: 80g (1 cup) rolled oats, 1 cup unsweetened soy milk, 1 tbsp chia seeds, 1 container Oikos Triple Zero yogurt, 0.5 oz pumpkin seeds, 0.5 oz sunflower seeds, 2 mandarin oranges. Try entering that to Cronometer, you'll see it's about 800kcal and makes good progress in a lot of vitamins and minerals - relevant to the article, it already has 84% of the RDA of magnesium. You can easily max all other micros by eating a dinner consisting of fish, rice and beans, 1 carrot, and some broccoli - and still have room left over for additional macros (which will of course themselves contain extra micros) if you exercise. Of course, this is much more cognitive work than the majority of people want to put in, and because it only works when you buy most of your food in the form of single-ingredients that you then prepare yourself, it's not compatible with a lifestyle of eating lots of prepared foods or dining out. However once you invest the up front time in learning how to do all this, it's not very hard to do, especially if you eat a consistent diet or combine things into set meals you can mix and match [2]. [0] The major exception is I usually don't hit 100% of the RDA for dietary Vitamin D. Dietary vitamin D in non-supplemental form (as found in milk and milk substitutes) is only present in very few foods - oily fish and sun-exposed mushrooms. I do eat these somewhat regularly but not enough to hit 100%. But I think as long as you get adequate sun exposure it's not a big deal. [1] cronometer.com [2] For example, in the example set of foods I provided, the rolled oats + soy milk + chia seeds are eaten together in the form of overnight oats almost every morning.
- lucb1e 5y ago> Ever tried to have 100% daily recommended intake of every nutrient? I take soylent (that is, a European fork of it) with some regularity. Mainly out of laziness, but also I hope that it's good for whatever I might have been deficient in when eating other foods. It doesn't reduce how healthy I try to eat, but with a picky partner and semi-picky self, it probably helps. It's also just convenient. Would recommend. The flavored versions, that is, not the cardboard variant. In case anyone wants to get started and isn't sure what to try first, some of the variants I tried or know people that tried it: - Jimmy Joy (previously: Joylent), their Plenny Shake powder: I like all flavors that I tried (that is chocolate, vanilla, strawberry, and banana). - Nano: not a big fan of it, and neither is friend A that gave it to me iirc. - Huel: friends B and C liked it a lot better than JJ, but the Huel Black (B,C didn't try that one) is absolutely disgusting to me as well as to friend D. I and friends A,D never tried the regular Huel. Not sure how close each is to the original Soylent, but Joylent as a name probably says enough. If you read their blog, the updates to the powder seem to be about things like "uptake was found not to be great for X so we increased that" and some such. I also liked SoylentLife which iirc was closer to Soylent than Joylent was at the time, but they went out of business. One interesting data point is that I am much less vitamin D deficient than my girlfriend who doesn't eat any soylent variants (she doesn't like any). We eat many meals together / the same stuff, and if anything she sees more sunlight than I do, so that might say something or nothing. There have also been a lot of people that do Jimmy Joy only (eating nothing else) for months and then have their blood checked and it comes back clean. From what I've been able to find, it's quite fine as a food replacement, but of course you don't have to (and I don't) use it that way. Other brands probably have similar tests done on them but I didn't look into those as I only ever ate them experimentally.
- opportune 5y agoThe issue I have with soylent and some of their competitors is that they get to their RDA amounts by directly adding vitamins and minerals, some of which have low absorption depending on how they are bound - for example zinc and magnesium oxides have poor absorption compared to other zinc and magnesium salts - and which is not substantially better than just taking a multivitamin as far as I can tell.
- alliao 5y agoextending quality of nutrition to lifespan is adding another layer of abstraction... maybe it's the taoism stuff talking but my intuition is these two things are not related and can possibly hinder.