3 ms·
Access is what matters. Consider two groups of ten people. Group A consists of ten people, who each have a Ferrari. In this group, the average car is a Ferrari
by tialaramex 5y ago
Access is what matters.
Consider two groups of ten people. Group A consists of ten people, who each have a Ferrari. In this group, the average car is a Ferrari. But in Group B there are also ten people, one of them has ten Ferraris, nine others own a 2CV. In this group the average car is also a Ferrari.
But Group B's cars suck. 90% of people in Group B do not have access to the "average" of a Ferrari.
There are two elements to access and the US doesn't do great at either of them. One element is: Can you actually get a decent service? If the best service you could actually buy is a 2Mbps ADSL connection then, "No", you can't, even if your best friend has 1Gbps symmetric. The US is almost inevitably going to suck in this respect for some of its most rural residents, but nobody in a suburb let alone inside a city ought to be suffering this under a rational approach. Second element is: Can you afford decent service? Maybe 1Gbps is technically on offer in your neighbourhood, for the same price as your rent. Obviously you won't buy that. In some cases this is going to be impacted by other economic decisions. If your country's idea of a "living wage" doesn't include paying for Internet service then that's maybe a problem in 2021.
- Zarel 5y agoThe best way to handle all these issues is to use the median rather than the mean. If most people have no Ferraris, then the median person has no Ferrari. If most people can't afford gigabit, then the median person has no gigabit internet. And yes, the US has much lower median speed (Speedtest.net reports an "average" of 191 Mbps in 11th place, and FairInternetReport reports a "median" of 30 Mbps in 23rd place) https://fairinternetreport.com/research/internet-speed-by-country https://fairinternetreport.com/research/internet-speed-by-co... The US's median speed doubled during the pandemic, though – it was apparently much lower before that.
- tialaramex 5y agoInteresting about the pandemic. So that suggests the access problem was less bad than I had thought, since presumably lots of people were able to buy better Internet service, once it was important to them. 30Mbps seems fine to me. I only have slightly more than that here, and I have never felt the need to buy more even though I could afford it. Of course that's for one person, the median US household size is considerably more.
- 29083011397778 5y agoI've only given the following a cursory glance, but it doesn't look like consumers had much to do with the speed increase. Instead, Comcast was concerned with being called out on price gouging in Baltimore [0]. Or they increased their minimum speed without increasing the price [1,2] - which I'd think implies Baltimore had a point about the price gouging. So while some people may have been able to buy better internet before, the data doesn't support that it was affordable, if it was even available at all. [0] https://baltimore.cbslocal.com/2021/02/02/comcast-internet-speed-changes-price-gouging-claims-latest/ https://baltimore.cbslocal.com/2021/02/02/comcast-internet-s... [1] https://corporate.comcast.com/press/releases/internet-essentials-low-income-broadband-coronavirus-pandemic https://corporate.comcast.com/press/releases/internet-essent... [2] https://philadelphia.chalkbeat.org/2021/2/4/22266246/after-pressure-from-advocates-comcast-boosts-internet-speed-for-low-income-users https://philadelphia.chalkbeat.org/2021/2/4/22266246/after-p...