4 ms·
Revisiting webcam covers
- maliker 5y agoI’d be way more worried about someone putting a keylogger on my laptop versus them taking control of the webcam.
- colejohnson66 5y agoExactly. If someone can see through my webcam, I have more to worry about than them seeing my room. I get the appeal of webcam covers; they’re a quick and simple alleviation to the idea of a “peeping Tom”, but if someone can see through your camera when you don’t want them to, they probably already have control of other things on the computer. They could install a keylogger and siphon my documents/photos for more blackmail material. Maybe I’m just dense because it never happened to me (AFAIK), but am I wrong?
- batch12 5y agoWhy not defend against both scenarios?
- colejohnson66 5y agoI’m not saying we shouldn’t. I actually think manufacturers should go a step further and add physical kill switches to webcams. That would allow cutting off the audio as well. I’m just saying that a sticker seems to be a bandaid on a possibly bigger issue.
- ghaff 5y agoThere are very few physical switches and ports on most modern laptops. How many people out of the 99 who don't care are willing to pay for the physical (and not just "physical" as in triggers software) killing of audio and video for the one (if that) who cares? I know I'm not.
- jimhefferon 5y agoI am, for one.
- XorNot 5y ago"Someone" getting control of my webcam bothers me a lot less then "my workplace's invasive monitoring software (which can be deployed at any time in the future if its not there now) is collecting images of my home workplace. My webcam on my own computers, no real fear. When that same device is USB connected to a work supplied computer? Zero trust.
- remram 5y agoI use a webcam cover, but I'm not worried about people hacking into my laptop. What I'm defending against is one of the many apps I have to use for conferencing (Zoom, Google Meet, Bluejeans, Teams) starting up with the camera on when I'm not expecting it (and e.g. not wearing a shirt, my wife getting ready in the background, etc) for example because it was on last time I used that particular app.
- ghaff 5y agoThat is probably the main concern for most people. I conference from my office and I simply don't go in there if I'm not presentable at some level. But if you're conferencing from your bedroom, especially with another person, it would be super-easy to mess up with an early morning video call.
- kevincox 5y agoFor browser-based conferencing you can simply require them to ask for camera access every time. But that won't help you for tools with their own apps. One of the many reasons I try to avoid running the apps of "random" companies.
- remram 5y agoRevoking permission in my browser's control after each use might be an option. I wonder if I could make a script to change the browser settings (or an extension?)
- Daneel_ 5y agoI installed a virtual camera driver (eg, Canon's EOS camera driver) and set that camera as the default. If any program starts up the camera unexpectedly, they get a giant "NO EOS DEVICE CONNECTED" instead of me partially clothed with my no-coffee-yet face on.
- pineapple128 5y agoThis is automatic in Firefox. When giving e.g. microphone permission, you can leave the 'Remember this desxision' option unchecked. This will make the permission 'Allowed temporarily' and will be reset when you close the tab or window. As far as I can test, Chrome does not have this option.
- MrStonedOne 5y agoSomebody didn't read the article.
- runjake 5y agoI use a small tab of yellow sticky note. I use it not due to attacks but rather for the many dumb teleconferencing apps I have to use at work. Some automatically send video, some don’t. I try to configure them not to start video by default but for whatever reason, one of them always does.
- meowster 5y agoI used to use a black sticker so it wasn't visibly obtrusive, but since the rise of videoconferencing this past year, I now use a yellow sticky note as well, so I can easily verify if it's there or not.
- jbay808 5y ago3M also makes black sticky notes (intended for use with gel pens). Cut a piece off the sticky area and it blends in perfectly with ThinkPad matte black bezels. I also recommend putting another small piece on the backside (to make a "band-aid" shape) just to ensure that no adhesive gets left on your webcam lens cover.
- runjake 5y agoYeah I purposely use yellow because my eyes are old and it’s much easier to tell whether it’s in place or not.
- Daneel_ 5y agoThere's something to be said for the more recent thinkpads that have physical sliders built into the laptop.
- draw_down 5y agoYes, if it’s built in then it’s a lot less awkward. You can close the laptop with it on, etc. The practical problems with doing this are bigger than theoretical ones. Ultimately Apple should probably build this in given their “privacy” messaging. But in any case, I think surreptitious microphone access is a bigger problem than this, and there’s no easy solution to it.
- nixpulvis 5y agoWhy can't you make a hardware switch for the microphone too? Both the PinePhone and Librem 5 have this. I would like to see more and more of these physical kill switches, hopefully kind of like the silent switches on my iPhone, but maybe with little sliding locks to keep them in position.
- jptech 5y agoThere used to be a hardware switch for WiFi on laptops not long ago. But being "always connected" took precedence over privacy. Same can be said with microphone and voice assistants.
- nixpulvis 5y agoIDK, my laptop still has a button to disable the radios, but it's on F8 and implemented in firmware (or software?) not hardware. I think there's a pretty healthy market for privacy/security/control-oriented hardware.
- NoImmatureAdHom 5y agoPurism's Librem laptops have hardware kill switches for the radios (wifi, bluetooth), and the camera / mic https://puri.sm/products/librem-14/ https://puri.sm/products/librem-14/
- batch12 5y agoI use a camera cover for my work computers since I don't have full control over the devices. It has saved me from default broadcasts in conferencing software several times.
- tyingq 5y agoThat seems like a very valid use case. Corporate laptops also often have mandatory software like RemotelyAnywhere on them that allow the mothership to poke in anytime they like.
- saint_angels 5y agoas the author mentioned, probably the bigger nuisance is not hackers getting access to your camera, but legit apps using it when you expect the least
- NoImmatureAdHom 5y agoIMHO apps that use your camera when you least expect it aren't legit. Don't allow big tech to kill you death-by-a-thousand-cuts style. If you don't control your hardware and your firmware, the machine isn't yours and the sensors should be on physical kill switches. You can install these (e.g., kill switch for mic, cover for camera) or you can buy machines with these (e.g. from Purism https://puri.sm/products/librem-14/ https://puri.sm/products/librem-14/ )
- gumby 5y agoI use my phone as my webcam. So to stream video I have to put it onto the clip on my monitor and plug in a cable. That doesn’t happen by accident. I recognize that this is more awkward than most people want. But the built in cameras (and third party too) are so terrible that it’s worth it to me.
- Nitrolo 5y agoWhat apps or programs do you use to make your phone work as a webcam? I've tried that last year but none of the solutions in the play store seemed to work for me.
- httpsterio 5y agoI use Droidcam OBS with OBS on Windows/Mac and it's pretty good, especially over USB. Droidcam X is good as well but with OBS you get more control over the image quality and you can do some arranging of the scene as well. There's also https://vdo.ninja/ https://vdo.ninja/ (previously obs.ninja) that doesn't require any special apps. You open up a browser on your smartphone and input the link into OBS as a browser source. The performance on Chrome is superior to other Android browsers in my experience. There's a bit of delay and the quality isn't quite as good as OBS as the connection goes through the internet and isn't local, but the delay is actually surprisingly small.
- gumby 5y agoI use camo which works really well but I am mac/ios so don’t know if they support other platforms.
- saint_angels 5y agocamo works great on windows/Mac but it requires an iOS device
- bluedino 5y agoI cringe when I see a sliding cover stuck on over a web cam, and you can see stress cracks on the laptop screen
- schwartzworld 5y agoAdded benefit of webcam covers: if your office has mandatory cameras on, you can always turn on the video feed with the camera covered and just pretend you don't know why it isn't working.
- NoImmatureAdHom 5y agoThis is a dystopian future I hadn't imagined, but in retrospect it seems like something you should've bet on. Is this really a thing, "mandatory cameras on"?
- schwartzworld 5y agoSome workplaces, some bosses.
- motohagiography 5y agoI just assume my laptops are all compromised, because if they are managed or have any commercial software on them, they are. Put another way, if you think your machine is secure, can you afford to be wrong? The reason I have used a lens cover as long as there have been cams (back to the SGI days) is because, to borrow a phrase, corporate IT people are not gentlemen. Is anyone really going to try find a novel rootkit on their daily driver windows thinkpad or airbook, when you could more easily set up a honeynet if you were hunting that threat. Without a honeypot, pulling apart your workstation means you are your own control group, and you just start losing your mind. To me that seems like spending a day to source and replace a UART in a cheap pair of headphones instead of replacing them. If I still ran linux or a bsd I would pay more attention, but running a commercial OS is already being at such a disadvantage that the effort doesn't justify the results. Instead, there is a room or a box that electronics go in when they aren't being used. Software security controls are a speedbump for the threat actors most of us deal with. If they want to get you, they will. Cam covers and physical controls are the best possible controls because they do what they are. The same cannot be said for software.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- mncharity 5y agoRandom story just for fun. Years back I was at a tech meetup, and left my laptop sitting on a lunchroom table, and wandered off to chat. Now my laptop then looked a bit odd, with three extra cameras, on folding sticks gaff taped to the lid. Two fisheyes perched on the corners, and a keyboard cam hanging out on a wooden-ruler arm.[1] For head, eye, hand and stylus tracking - the ThinkPad's quadro would run hot just driving the HIDs, even before starting the desktop UI, let alone any apps. Now while I was gone, a host had gone around the tables, and left a gift. Sitting on/beside the laptop, under the assorted extra cameras on sticks, was a small piece of logo-ed swag... a little webcam sliding-cover thin plastic stick-on. There was laughter. [1] https://pbs.twimg.com/media/ERqCfdkX0AEWTN_?format=jpg&name=900x900 https://pbs.twimg.com/media/ERqCfdkX0AEWTN_?format=jpg&name=...
- NoImmatureAdHom 5y agoI think we should all be pushing for norms that any camera must be covered with an easily visible (i.e., yellow) cover if not in use at that actual moment. Like zipping up the fly in your pants.
- tobiasbischoff 5y agoYay, I use a point and shoot (Sony ZV-1) as Webcam. Not only it provides a stellar picture but i need to actually turn it on to do so. Win/Win.
- nayuki 5y agoI like the anime girl that's included on every page. He explains Rubi the mascot here: https://rubenerd.com/about/#mascot https://rubenerd.com/about/#mascot
- zitterbewegung 5y agoNote for people who want to put a third party slidable webcam covers: make sure that the tolerances of your Laptop or other device will allow you to put the webcam cover without damaging your screen or other components. Instead as directed above use a Post it note. Another strategy would be to compartmentalize your activities using separate computers but this is a much higher cost (get a separate laptop for home use).
- NoImmatureAdHom 5y agoOr just add some slightly thicker stick-on rubber bumpers to the top edge...then you don't need to worry about how thick the camera cover is.
- shapefrog 5y agoNever ever ever ever should you do anything home related on work hardware. Likewise never do anything work related on personal hardware. It isnt 'higher cost' to have a personal computer, it is the cost you would have if you didnt have a job. I have seen what IT do when they 'replace the sim card on your phone' it involes looking through all your pictures and reading all your messages. As for companies that say they are not providing hardware and you have to use your personal hardware / phone / whatever for your job. Fuck them.
- abiro 5y agoIt’s also a good idea to disable the camera/mic in BIOS if you never use them.
- throwaway81523 5y agoMy laptop camera is permanently covered with black electrical tape, but if it was uncovered there would really not be much to see except my bleary eyeballs and my pandemic-necessitated mad-scientist-looking self-inflicted haircut. I worry much more about the microphone, not just in my laptop, but in my phone, and in who knows what other devices that have the insidious things hidden away. I wish there was a way to block microphones with tape to kill any audio pickup when not wanted. It's harder to manage than cameras, making camera covers something like privacy theater if the microphones are going to be left unblocked. Yeah I know about the Pinephone with its microphone kill switch, but that switch is apparently quite a pain to operate. If I get a Pinephone I'm likely to leave the mic permanently shut off, and simply use an external or bluetooth mic if I want to make a voice call.