5 ms·
It's a shame IMO that AMD won't ship desktop APUs with a large GPU and GDDR6. They're willing to sell the tech to MS, Sony, and some random Chinese company, but
by wmf 5y ago
It's a shame IMO that AMD won't ship desktop APUs with a large GPU and GDDR6. They're willing to sell the tech to MS, Sony, and some random Chinese company, but not to consumers.
- dralley 5y agoIt almost certainly requires a heavily customized OS. Those chips are designed for the CPU and GPU to share a unified address space on the GDDR6, there is no traditional DDR memory.
- wmf 5y agoLike all iGPUs...
- dralley 5y agoMost iGPUs do not use a unified address space. They use system RAM, yes. But they get a partition of it to themselves, and the size of this partition is often tweakable in the graphics driver settings. The M1 Mac is one of the few laptops that actually does have fully unified memory. https://eclecticlight.co/2020/11/11/how-unified-memory-blows-the-socs-off-the-m1-macs/ https://eclecticlight.co/2020/11/11/how-unified-memory-blows...
- kcb 5y agoI don't believe that's true. And the driver/bios settings don't really do what people think they do. https://www.intel.com/content/www/us/en/support/articles/000020962/graphics.html https://www.intel.com/content/www/us/en/support/articles/000... And zero copy buffers and unified address space are totally a thing on Intel, AMD, and Nvidia(Tegra) igpus. Sounds like there's more than a bit of "Apple Magic" in that blog post.
- formerly_proven 5y agoAMD APUs have had a unified address space for ten years or so.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- Bancakes 5y agoPlaystation does it just fine and it's freebsd-based.
- twotwotwo 5y agoA related cool-idea-that-won't-happen would be some less-locked-down form of Windows in an XBox. More so than last gen's Jaguar cores, this console gen's CPU cores should be fine for PC use for a while. It'd probably have to be kind of a VM in a 'game', to avoid revamping the outer OS. They'd probably want to nerf the GPU in Windows to reduce folks' temptation to use it to route around the XBox store (for graphically intense games at least), and maybe price Windows to make up for decreased game revenue per console. Even given all that it might let folks with XBoxes cheaply "get a PC" of sorts, and so come a bit closer to the rest of MS's world. Probably technical, business, and other issues with that, but again, I did say fun idea that won't happen.
- lucian1900 5y agoThe Xbox already runs all games and apps in VMs, it’s part of how suspending works. Running Windows 10 in one should be relatively easy, it’s mostly an input problem.
- PragmaticPulp 5y agoThe simpler explanation is that they’ve decided the demand just isn’t there. Their current APUs aren’t bad for casual gamers doing budget builds. Scaling them up significantly would require larger power supplies, bigger heatsinks, and other expenses. By the time an actual gamer is going through the trouble of building such a system, they’re likely to just buy an entry-level GPU so their CPU and GPU don’t have to be upgraded together.
- oliwarner 5y agoBig PSUs and monster heatsinks are things today's consumers have in spades. But GPUs are so rare that a modern mid-level costs $1000 and my 1080Ti is currently worth double what I paid for it three years ago. I think a good APU would be very welcome in this hellscape. I think a more realistic reason is AMD doesn't want to cannibalise its GPU sales.
- justicezyx 5y agoWhat is the "random Chinese company" you are referring here? Edit: thanks for the quick answer! Edit 2: regarding this company, it's actually not called zhongshan. The company is called "小霸王” or little master. A acclaimed early gaming console and amateur pc manufacturer. They coped the original FC and pirated a lot of the games. But because gaming console was banned in China (the ban was lifted Google to see details), the console was labeled tutoring console. I learned basic on them. This project with Amd supposes to be reviving the gaming console after the ban was lifted. But the project is now officially dead, according to report https://3g.163.com/tech/article/EF1RBUIS00097U7T.html?spss=adap_pc https://3g.163.com/tech/article/EF1RBUIS00097U7T.html?spss=a...
- mastax 5y agoZhongshan https://www.anandtech.com/show/13153/amd-creates-quad-core-zen-soc-with-24-vega-cus-for-chinese-consoles https://www.anandtech.com/show/13153/amd-creates-quad-core-z...
- orbital-decay 5y agoSubor, yes. It was also the second most popular Famiclone in post soviet republics, after the Micro Genius imported under the Dendy brand. (Nintendo never sold their NES there officially so the clones flooded the market). I remember Subor's "NES with a keyboard" as well, it was a rare sight and a weird machine - no persistent memory, little RAM, yet programmable in a BASIC dialect. We used to have home computers for this purpose, like Spectrum or various domestic models.
- tedunangst 5y agoA large CPU with a small GPU would nice, while we're wishing.
- fgonzag 5y agoAlso while we're wishing, a sub $100 modern GPU that can drive multiple 4k monitors, gaming performance be damned. Considering the fact that most of AMD's CPUs do not include an iGPU, I don't really get why they haven't launched something like that for the workstation market.
- InvaderFizz 5y agoThat would be what the Radeon Pro WX 2100/3200 targets. The nvidia equivalent would be something like the Quadro P400. Of course, pricing, even on these cards, is a bit crazy right now.
- mastax 5y agoThe Intel DG1 is quite good for that, apparently, but they don't sell it at retail.
- walterbell 5y agoThere are Ryzen mini-PCs with multiple 4K display outputs, e.g. Asus PN50, Gigabyte Brix Pro, ASRock 4x4, starting around $300 barebone.
- wolrah 5y ago> A large CPU with a small GPU would nice, while we're wishing. My biggest annoyance with switching to AMD has been this. My previous Intel system has a Core i7 4790K, Intel's top tier CPU for their consumer platform at the time, and it had an iGPU. It was not an amazing iGPU by any means, but it was more than enough to support two additional monitors "for free" which was wonderful while nVidia had a bug preventing the GPU from going in to low power mode in certain multi-monitor configurations. It also meant I had plenty of ports to support three monitors, a VR headset, a TV, and have some space left over. When I upgraded to a Ryzen 9 3900X I tripled my core count and gained a fair amount of per-core performance, but I lost those extra ports. Now my graphics card is maxed out and I have to switch the HDMI cable between the TV and the VR headset. They've slowly been moving the G models up the lineup, but it's still not possible to get a truly high-end CPU from AMD with an iGPU. It would be really nice, especially these days with standalone GPUs being unobtanium.
- schmorptron 5y agoAre they maybe already at production capacity for RDNA2 with their existing RX 6000 series and the PS5 and Xboxes? I'd imagine with the semiconductor shortage that'd play a role in deciding to keep their APUs on a larger node for a while longer.