9 ms·
As an American who moved here from a Muslim country let me assure you Muslims are socialized to feel the same way about Jews. Took me a long time to see it. In
by rayiner 5y ago
As an American who moved here from a Muslim country let me assure you Muslims are socialized to feel the same way about Jews.
Took me a long time to see it. In high school I obviously supported Palestine and thought Israel was a settler colony (all of it, not just Gaza). Then I realized: wait why do I even care? I’m from 3,000 miles away in Bangladesh. In Bangladesh, people don’t even care about Bangladeshis being held in near-slavery conditions in Qatar. (More Bangladeshi workers have died in the Middle East since 2010 than Palestinians killed in the conflict with Israel since 1947.) They don’t care about the Rohingya. They don’t care what Saudi is doing in Yemen. They’re very friendly with China and don’t care about Uighurs. But everyone has an opinion on how Israel is oppressing Palestine.
- xupybd 5y agoThis is what war has done in almost every conflict. The enemy is a monster so attacking the monster justifies far too much.
- drran 5y ago(Non-native English speaker) It can be in two kinds: a) they are DOING something bad: attacking, occupying, oppressing, blocking, so we need to stop them, kick them out, liberate from their oppression, break their block, etc. b) they ARE (Jews, Christians, Muslims, etc., or a nation, or a group), and they are bad because (list of historical or invented reasons), so we need to kill or enslave them or force assimilation of them. For example, recent Russian-Ukrainian war, from Russian side: * Ukrainians are bad, because they are Nazi. Reasons: Ukraine is Nazi country because it is independent Nation, which is bad for Russian Empire/Soviet Union/Russian Federation. Thus: kill Ukrainians, close Ukrainian schools, magazines, sites, TV and radio stations, force Ukrainians to abandon Ukrainian culture. * Ukrainian are oppressing Ukrainians, speaking in Russish. Reasons: nobody will speak in dumb Ukrainian language at their own will, when they can use Great and Mighty Russish Tongue (Великий и Могучий Русский Язык), so, obviously, Ukrainians are forcing Ukrainians to speak in Ukrainian language, AKA «forceful ukrainization»/«насильственная украинизация» (and Ukrainian language is dumb, obviously, because it causes laugh, when a Russish hear it). Thus: invade Eastern Ukraine to protect Russissh-speaking Ukrainians from forceful ukrainization (direct speech: «защитить русско-язычных жителей Юго-Востока Украины от насильственной украинизации»). From Ukrainian side: * Russians are invading Ukraine. Reasons: they want to destroy Ukrainian nation and make it part of Russian Empire/Soviet Union/Russian Federation. Thus: Ukraine must stop invasion.
- selimthegrim 5y agoThey don't seem to care much about the stranded Biharis on their doorstep either AFAIK.
- luffapi 5y agoI’d urge people not to give up caring. There’s a lot of crappy things happening in the world and it can be a lot to deal with, but just tossing your hands up isn’t the answer. I’d also argue that tax paying Americans are obligated to care. Our money is funding Israel’s crimes and we are morally culpable if we don’t resist or try to change policy.
- tartoran 5y agoYes, I am aware of that and do care for justice but am afraid to talk abour it IRL to be honest. To be publically acused of antisemitism for being critical to Israel could be a real nightmare Im not ready to go through. I am no antisemitist, on the contrary, some of my favorite people are jewish. Am I a coward? I think so but I have a family and want to hold onto my job. Here on HN I am not afraid to comment because this account is not tied to my real identity. Ps There is one think I do which I know is directly connected to this. I boycot Israeli food products, mostly grown on occupied lands. The inpact is close to nil but it’s the most I can do at the moment.
- luffapi 5y agoI agree this is a real issue. Even if it’s just voicing support under a pseudonym (such as I’ve done here), it’s better than nothing. The younger generations are definitely more aware of the issues Palestinians are facing and more vocal about putting an end to it. That offers me some hope.
- YZF 5y agoYou should know that saying some of my favorite people are jewish is something that sounds pretty bad. The idea that you would be branded as an anti-semite and lose your job because you are critical of Israel also sounds bad. A lot of people are critical of Israel's policies, including many Israelis. There is absolutely no problem with that.
- tartoran 5y agoWhy is it bad if I admire jews? I think this is going too far, I am not ill intended towards anyone but you just gave me an example why as a non jew I should stay quiet if I don’t want to be labeled as anything or god knows what else
- jedimind 5y agoSo you stop caring about something as soon as a specific number of other people don't care? "Yeah I used to care about homeless people, but then one day I was like 'wait why do I even care', `nobody` in LA seems to care" If you truly care about something, you care because of your values and you care regardless of what others say or do.
- dang 5y agoPlease don't cross into name-calling or personal attack. https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html
- jedimind 5y agoSorry dang, which part is name calling tho?
- dang 5y ago"infantile reasoning at its finest"
- jedimind 5y agoThe reasoning is objectively infantile I doubt that anyone can argue against that. I didn't say that he is infantile, I criticised the reasoning not the person. Sorry if even that is considered 'name calling'. I can edit it and word it differently if you want.
- dang 5y agoThis feels like hair-splitting to me. Your comment obviously broke the site guidelines. If you'd please re-read them and do a more careful job of sticking to the rules, we'd appreciate it. Note this one, for example: "Please respond to the strongest plausible interpretation of what someone says, not a weaker one that's easier to criticize. Assume good faith." https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html
- Ozzie_osman 5y agoIt's almost like maybe you should care and speak out about Palestine and Bengladeshis in Qatar and Rohingya and Yemenis and Uighurs.
- bradleyjg 5y agoAre we allowed to anything else—-or just eat, sleep, and speak out about badness in the world?
- Ozzie_osman 5y agoYou're right. I had to quit my job and stop caring for my family because I was spending so much time occasionally speaking up about things I thought were bad in the world. I also occasionally donate small amounts to causes I believe in and so I better check my bank account because I'm probably broke. /s
- BeFlatXIII 5y agoThere are only so many hours in a day. This should be true at the community level, but an individual passionately caring about all of those injustices at once will end up spamming social media with advocacy because there is not enough time to pick any one to do something with greater impact.
- slim 5y agoHe does not have to care about every injustice every time. But he should not be proud about not caring.
- justanotherguy0 5y agoWhy not? Who cares? Like he said, this is far from the worst conflict going on right now and it receives a disproportionate amount of interest. I don't care about the conflict in china or in Yemen or in syria. Because I'm a coherent person, I also don't care about what's happening in israel.
- g8oz 5y agoThe opinions of Americans in particular on this issue are very relevant. The U.S provides Israel with a diplomatic, military and financial blank check. Many of the most aggressive elements of the settler movement that makes life so difficult for Palestinians in East Jerusalem and the West Bank are funded by American non-profit groups like the Central Fund of Israel. In addition some 60,000 ideologically driven American citizens are living as settlers in the West Bank.
- wolverine876 5y agoAs I posted eleswhere, note that American Christian Evangelicals support Israel's right-wing policies much more strongly than American Jews, who are mostly liberal and Democrats. https://duckduckgo.com/?q=evangelical+support+for+israel+site%3Anytimes.com&ia=web https://duckduckgo.com/?q=evangelical+support+for+israel+sit...
- threatofrain 5y agoYou should link directly to the sources you curate, rather than just linking a duckduckgo search.
- slipframe 5y agoHe seems to be right according to Pew in 2014: https://www.pewresearch.org/fact-tank/2014/02/27/strong-support-for-israel-in-u-s-cuts-across-religious-lines/ https://www.pewresearch.org/fact-tank/2014/02/27/strong-supp... > Pew Research surveys find that similar shares of Christians (29%) and Jews (31%) say the U.S. is not supportive enough of Israel. Among white evangelical Protestants, nearly half (46%) say that the U.S. is not providing enough support for Israel.
- wolverine876 5y agoSays who? Why?
- Gustomaximus 5y agoContext matters, but often I like a search result over article. When someone knows vast majority of results go the stated direction vs here is an article that supports a view as often that is bias writing. A search result link to a degree shows greater neutrality vs particular press in the right context.
- xwolfi 5y agoThis is clear to me that the thing that matters most is Israelis doing it more than muslims being victims. After all these Palestinians are humans like you and me, and despite the flaw of being muslim, could be triggering empathy in most of us. But interestingly I really care more about Israeli reproducing Nazis patterns than Palestinians being at the other end. And we talk a lot about China, but they're not jews, just atheists, so they're much better for muslim leaderships than Israel.
- jdjdbxbfn 5y agoIf you are comparing Israel to the Reich you clearly have no idea.
- dang 5y agoYou somehow managed to slur both sides with this comment. That's seriously not ok. We ban accounts that post like this, so please don't do it again. https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html
- kdjsbdb 5y agoBecause Palestine has neat takkia action going in Pallywood.
- throwaway_875_1 5y agoYou are a Shameless person
- notsureaboutpg 5y agoIdk this doesn't sound true about any of the Bengalis I have met. They all seem to care a lot about Rohingya (since it is especially close to them and they see the suffering), the Uighurs, Yemen, etc. Israel's oppression of the Palestinians is decades older than all the conflicts you mention, which is why they probably don't get as much airtime comparatively.
- azth 5y ago> Then I realized: wait why do I even care? I’m from 3,000 miles away in Bangladesh. I'm assuming you're a Muslim, in which case you should care because of [1][2] [1] https://sunnah.com/riyadussalihin:224 https://sunnah.com/riyadussalihin:224 [2] https://sunnah.com/muslim:2586a https://sunnah.com/muslim:2586a