4 ms·
What's even the point of enforcing these requirements when the OS seems to be running quite fine otherwise? Users who are running without SB or a compliant TPM
by zozbot234 5y ago
What's even the point of enforcing these requirements when the OS seems to be running quite fine otherwise? Users who are running without SB or a compliant TPM will simply stay on Windows 10, and maybe stay on it past the official EOL date.
- temac 5y agoThat's an early build, maybe Windows 11 RTM will actually always use a TPM (1.2 is advertised as minimally supported though). As for secure boot, I don't see how that could be anything else than policy (that can have an impact on a security model and so on associated security measures, granted, but not having secure boot should technically not prevent booting / installation unless it is enforced by an explicit artificial limitation). But they could at least remove legacy boot support, in which case it just won't work without UEFI.
- omegalulw 5y agoI suppose they don't want to support legacy hardware. If they let it install, people will complain when something breaks.
- opencl 5y agoIf the other requirements they've posted are accurate then the CPU list alone will eliminate anything more than about 3 years old.
- wubbert 5y agoThey're doing this to force people to buy new hardware and a new Windows licence. If they let you upgrade from Windows 10 for free, they don't make any money. They've already gotten people used to free updates, so they can't charge money for Windows 11 upgrades directly. Most people buy pre-built computers, so a Windows 11 licence will be included by default for most, so they will make more money.
- kawsper 5y ago> They're doing this to force people to buy new hardware Forcing people to buy new hardware while there's a global chip shortage is going to be interesting.
- vetinari 5y agoFirst-gen Threadrippers are not supported by Windows 11. Freaking Treadrippers. If they think their owners are going to get new ones for Windows 11, they must be deluded.
- XorNot 5y agoI only have Windows for gaming. Maybe this finally pushes me to Linux with Wine only. I certainly can use PCI passthrough and an emulated TPM in Qemu.
- userbinator 5y agoThey're essentially promoting the creation of e-waste. Not to mention the rise of DRM and other user-hostile shit that they are now forcing you to have. I fucking hate what this industry has become...
- flenserboy 5y agoThey're also going to create a large number of new Linux users. This might also allow great hardware to be obtainable for pennies on the dollar. I don't like the direction this is going, but there can be good things to come from this.
- shadilay 5y agoUnless Linux PC's are 90% of shelf space at Best Buy/Amazon it won't. HN forgets that 95% of people are computer illiterate and would not be able to install Linux themselves.
- staticassertion 5y ago
- ospray 5y agoBest guess is that win 11 will require full disk encryption at some point. With both secure boot and tpm Microsoft will be able to lock down windows in ways they simply couldn't before.
- bellyfullofbac 5y agoYeah, I feel like it's obvious that Microsoft wants to iPhone-ize the Windows desktop...
- cunthorpe 5y agoI'd say finally. Like it's happening on the Mac, it's getting harder for the average user to screw up since software from "unidentified developers" can't run by default. I can still run anything I want as a power user and that will not change on macOS and won't change on Windows.
- novok 5y agofor now
- ocdtrekkie 5y agoBecause they want to set a minimum configuration they have to test and support for the next ten years. It might work fine today, but will it work after five feature updates? Yeah, you can run Windows 10 on some pretty ancient unsupported hardware too, but when they break support for a driver a couple years in, you end up with a nonworking machine.