2 ms·
Modern historians, like many scientists, involves trying to formulate hypotheses that extrapolate from known data, and these hypotheses frequently changed as ne
by jcranmer 5y ago
Modern historians, like many scientists, involves trying to formulate hypotheses that extrapolate from known data, and these hypotheses frequently changed as new data is acquired (or existing data is reinterpreted). And if you read academic history, you'll frequently see the continuing discussion as this happens.
However, there is a very strong demand for popular history that is not commonly found in science. Your average lay person is much more interested in, say, the fall of Rome rather than asking what dark matter is, and so you'll see a lot more books purporting to explain the fall of Rome. Furthermore--and this is especially true for people who write to a popular audience--most authors aren't exactly interested in discovering the unvarnished truth of the world, but rather have a particular narrative that they want to push. Again especially true for writing about history: if you're crusading against lead, Christianity, multiculturalism, etc., then being able to explain the fall of Rome as being mostly or entirely caused by lead, Christianity, multiculturalism, etc. bolsters your argument tremendously. And the people who instead write "it's actually a complex, multifaceted process that involves things that take me 50 pages to even list out" (the kind of answer an academic historian is wont to give) tend to lose in popularity to those who have simple explanations.