3 ms·
"Our compensation is not based on how well you negotiate or how often you ask for raises... We don’t have a range of possible salaries for every level, we have
by mapgrep 15y ago
"Our compensation is not based on how well you negotiate or how often you ask for raises... We don’t have a range of possible salaries for every level, we have a single salary, so everything about the system is algorithmic."
Bullshit. Politically savvy employees will just move their lobbying from blatantly asking for raises to arguing that they are on a new "level."
Consider that this document lists 10 different criteria for just the "public artifacts" portion of the ranking, including writing blog posts, public speaking, participating in hackathons, being on panels, and "participating in Stack Exchange." Queue the guy who says his upvotes and tweets bump him to the next level.
And "public artifacts" is just one of FIFTEEN (!) vague areas on which you are graded, including "Outreach," which lists some of the exact same criteria as "public artifacts," like public speaking and hackathons; "Getting Things Done;" "Ships" (how is that different from Getting Things Done?); "Ideas" (sounds objective!); "Extracurricular programming learning;" and "Other engineering type skills."
This sounds like a compensation system that pretends to be far more objective than it really is, which is actually more dangerous than one that acknowledges (and thus treats carefully) its own subjectivity.
(Which happens to be a broader issue I have with StackOverflow itself; much as I love it, the site is plagued by know-it-alls wielding pseudo precise rules "your question is overlocalized" and "not really a question" to delete reasonably compliant content. But that's a whole other comment.)
- byrneseyeview 15y agoBullshit. Politically savvy employees will just move their lobbying from blatantly asking for raises to arguing that they are on a new "level." My previous employer implemented that. And what you predicted is exactly what happened. The first salary negotiation after the new policy went like this: "We'd like to offer you $X." "No. I'd have to take at least 15% more than that." "Oh. We'll have to change your job title, then." I suppose that some organizations can pull this off, but they're very rare. Maybe StackOverflow should ask how the military does it.
- GavinB 15y agoMaybe StackOverflow should ask how the military does it. You're not allowed to quit. It simplifies things a great deal.
- elviejo 15y ago"Everytime you judge a person in more than 5 criterias he will be able to do pretty well in one. ando losy in the others." "Tell me how you measure me and I'll tell you how I'll behave" (Eliyahu M. Goldratt)