4 ms·
I'm not a fan of Bitcoin at all but that argument could be used for anything - "what's aggravating is that cars are literally moved by the consumption of power
by zamadatix 5y ago
I'm not a fan of Bitcoin at all but that argument could be used for anything - "what's aggravating is that cars are literally moved by the consumption of power through wasting it on combustion in the engine", "what's aggravating is that computers are literally operated by the consumption of power to waste it on browsing HN", "what's aggravating is that TV images are literally sent by the consumption of power through wasting it on radio waves" and so on. The only case it seems like a waste is if you don't value the output. If someone values browsing HN, individual transport, watching TV, or distributed consensus then it's not wasted it was used.
Inefficient perhaps, but the energy use was intentional for a value to someone not discarded for no gain.
- ufo 5y agoNot at all! Bitcoin is not just inefficient, it is purposefully inefficient on a colossal scale. By design, all the energy is turned into waste heat.
- zamadatix 5y ago"Waste heat is heat that is produced by a machine, or other process that uses energy, as a byproduct of doing work." You can't have "all waste heat" as that would require doing no work which would result in... no waste heat.
- zbrozek 5y agoIn those other processes the designers aim for efficiency - more useful product per entropy. In bitcoin it's exactly the opposite. That makes it unpalatable.
- zamadatix 5y agoIt is inefficient and unpalatable compared to traditional trust absolutely, even to some other crypto methods that try to achieve similar goals. Like I said I'm not really a fan of Bitcoin (or crypto to be honest). That being said Bitcoin doesn't aim for less product per entropy. That would literally mean you get more reward for doing the same work in the same time but less efficiently which isn't true. That doesn't mean everyone always uses the most efficient hashing method, just like not every car uses the same engine because it has the best efficiency, it just means the aim isn't towards making less product per entropy. The product may not be aligned with what you want (e.g. "very efficient way to trust a transaction") but that's back to calling the energy usage all "just for waste" because you don't personally value the output the same way as someone else (which is true of every use of energy).
- clarkmoody 5y agoBitcoin mining strives for as much efficiency as any other electronic process: ASIC chips are hitting the smallest process size available. Miners are extremely sensitive to electricity cost, so they must be efficient there. They do not compete with households for power. If Bitcoin mining were aiming to consume the most energy possible, then the hashing would be done by hand on pencil and paper.
- leetcrew 5y agomaybe I'm missing a semantic argument here, but don't computers always convert ~100% of their input power to waste heat? if my cpu consumes 140W, all of that gets dissipated through the heatspreader (perhaps minus a minuscule quantity of potential energy storing register/cache state).
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- zamadatix 5y agoIf 100% of the input power was given to waste heat then your computer would just be a resistance heater and not a computer. Computing information is work which requires energy (which will also eventually end up as heat in the long run, as will all energy, just not waste heat) and there is a limit on how efficiently you can compute https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Landauer%27s_principle https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Landauer%27s_principle. I.e. it's not possible to compute something without doing work. Waste heat in a computer is largely resistance, power conversion inefficiencies, and cooling. Heat generated by the actual computation is known as work https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Work_(thermodynamics) https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Work_(thermodynamics) not waste heat https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Waste_heat https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Waste_heat. The ratio of the two describes the efficiency of a machine. Since some useful work must have been done for the computation to occur then it's impossible for 100% of the energy to have been used for waste heat.
- patrick451 5y agoI find myself dubious of the claim that after an hour of isolated number crunching, my GPU has done anything aside from generate heat (that wikipedia page doesn't appear to mention anything about computing information). If only 95% of it became waste heat, where is the 5%? Given that computing information with a computer is just switching transistors on and off in a clever way, it makes no sense that if we are unclever, then suddenly all of the heat becomes "waste".
- NeutronStar 5y ago
- nonameiguess 5y agoThe same argument can't be made for other goods. Bitcoin bakes the energy cost of transaction processing into the security model. Security and ownership transfer for cars and televisions relies on good old-fashioned physical locks and paper records. That has other inefficiencies, but not much energy cost. The introduction of the internal combustion engine to the world definitely involved some tradeoffs in terms of pollution and mineral extraction, but it was always possible to make cars more efficient without breaking the basis of the ownership record for cars.
- zamadatix 5y agoThe same argument can be made about other systems they just aren't as grossly inefficient as Bitcoin so it isn't (usually) worth mentioning. The energy cost of doing something is always baked in as it's impossible to do anything without using energy, the difference is simply the cost vs output ratio is shit (efficiency) not that Bitcoin has a large chunk of waste energy for a reason (decentralized consensus) nobody values. I don't value it but obviously some do, same as some don't value individual transport over mass transit but I do. It doesn't mean a car is aggravating because it solely exists to waste energy in means a car is ridiculously inefficient. Same story with crytpocurrency.
- coryrc 5y agoIf the heat from bitcoin mining was used to replace resistance heat in existing places, then it would be okay.