3 ms·
I'm looking for balance, here. Let me provide an example: I have a "left-swipe-to-delete-from-list." That's the standard way that Apple has decreed that items
by ChrisMarshallNY 5y ago
I'm looking for balance, here. Let me provide an example:
I have a "left-swipe-to-delete-from-list." That's the standard way that Apple has decreed that items should be deleted. They provide no affordance.
You can add an "Edit" button to the navbar, but that means you don't have room for other, more important (and frequently-used) items. In my case, this is a non-starter. I need the room for more important stuff.
So far, I have added the left-swipe, but no affordance. It relies on the fact that the platform standard is left-swipe to delete. I need to make sure that the screen shows a fairly standard list (not getting too fancy), so users that are trained on platform standard will know that they can left-swipe.
In some cases, affordances can actually interfere with usability.
I can develop my own affordance, but I am not sure what a suitable one would be.
Implied training is also a big part of usability. I think it was Tufte that talked about that. He has some really strange UIs that don't make sense, until you learn them, and then, you don't ever want to go back.
In my experience, train maps in Tokyo are like this. They are a fearsome mess, when you first look at them, but, once you understand them, they are marvelous.
- edent 5y agoI get that. But how do you first learn about the standard way? Admittedly, it has been several years since I used an iPhone - but I don't remember it ever telling me that slide-to-delete was a thing. I literally had to ask on Twitter to find out - https://twitter.com/search?q=delete%20podcast%20from%3Aedent&src=typed_query https://twitter.com/search?q=delete%20podcast%20from%3Aedent... I agree that there are some things which work best hidden - pull to refresh, for example - but it needs to be consistent and explained.
- voakbasda 5y agoThe old Macintosh computers came with a floppy that walked the user through using the computer. How to click. How to drag. Very basic stuff, but it was all new to the world at the time. Now, you are assumed to know all that. The iPhone/touch paradigm never had such an easy on ramp for consumers. Or if it did, they dismantled it before I got on that ride. Personally, I think this reflects pure hubris on the part of Apple, and it’s one reason that I have not owned a mac for 20 years.
- jonathankoren 5y agoTrue, ui action discoverability is harder these days, but somehow I learned to swipe to delete, but I don’t know how. Maybe I was told, or saw a video? My point is, that the interactions are common enough that I think most people learn them from other people, whereas in the early days of personal computers guides were important because users had no previous knowledge, nor anyone else, to turn to.
- machello13 5y agoI think Apple’s argument for why slide to delete is not explained would be that it’s a shortcut — the explicit way to delete is to tap “edit” or “select” in a view, which exposes an explicit delete button on each row, or the ability to select rows and delete multiple. This is all explicit through buttons in the UI, and all of Apple’s apps tend to have this behavior (I can’t speak as to whatever UI you were trying to use 12 years ago). I would call that the “standard” way, whereas slide to delete is the fast way.
- captn3m0 5y agoAnother option is to go to Settings->General->Storage->Podcasts and delete from there.
- bitcurious 5y agoOne method I’ve seen of introducing the behavior is to have the list element slightly “bounce” sideways on load, giving a peak of the red/green color underneath.
- ChrisMarshallNY 5y agoHey, that's a great idea! It's a bit of a pain to implement, because I'd need to make sure that it only did it for displayed rows, and only once, but that's pretty cool. Thanks!
- datavirtue 5y agoIf you are having trouble revealing all the functionality then your app is already too much for the platform. Making your users learn a UI is stupid. You aren't building Autocad for the phone.
- ChrisMarshallNY 5y ago> Making your users learn a UI is stupid. I disagree. It's pretty much how everything (not just software) works. Driving is learning a UI. So is riding a bicycle, or a horse. Heck, using a toaster is learning a UI. Every standard GUI has platform conventions. In fact, becoming familiar with these conventions is one of the most important tasks that we all do, when starting out. It's also why so many of us get "fixed" on one or two platforms. I generally suggest to folks that are thinking of switching platforms, to consider just upgrading their device on their current platform, instead. Many HN readers are probably quite used to bouncing around a dozen different UI systems, but that is quite rare. Most folks like to find their rut, and then furnish it.