3 ms·
The Legend of the Restaurant Workers Too Lazy to Work
- runnerup 5y agoI don't understand the current trope about people en masse staying on unemployment benefits instead of returning to work. May 2021 U-3 unemployment is below 6% and seems like a very, very typical level for any point over the past 20 years.
- fundad 5y agoA child care business owner couldn’t hire layer off workers back, if she took a pay cut to attract workers she’d be making less than UI so she closed her business in June 2020 and probably went on UI herself. Even business owners can make more on UI than working. Thus child care is more expensive and out of reach for low wage workers who want to go back to work.
- runnerup 5y agoYeah I totally understand there are edge cases. But in aggregate, there are typical/very normal levels of unemployment. So if someone is saying "I can't hire people because no one wants to work"...I'm having trouble seeing how that's any more true now vs. in 2014, 2006, or 1999.
- fundad 5y agoAgreed, The leisure economy is stimulated most widely by the vaccine. People who took the virus seriously didn’t spend on experiences as much until now and it seems that’s a lot of customers.
- draw_down 5y agoFlagged, very first sentence is glib political point-scoring
- aaron-santos 5y agoIf the notice posted by Bill Anderson is any indication of the type of person he is to work with, he would have to pay a premium to make up for his disposition. Sometimes the explanations can be just that simple.
- throwaway7492 5y agoThis is a poor quality article written to make a political point. We need a more nuanced and clear-headed analysis of the current labor market than this. Low-wage laborers aren't lazy, but they certainly act rationally. The ongoing stimulus benefits undoubtedly had a strong effect on the labor market. The author pointed to inflation causing wage pressure on the labor market. This is literally an effect of the stimulus. I live in Berkeley, CA— hardly a conservative sronghold—and local cafes and bars are continually posting on social media about not being able to find labor. Many are running at reduced hours because of this. HN is better than this. I would love to read a nuanced analysis of the current market, regardless of what it concludes about the stimulus effects.
- fundad 5y agoThe vaccine is all the stimulus I needed to get out and spend, contributing to inflation. The direct payments were means-tested and the vaccine is not. Imagine the millions of people, who took COVID seriously, ready to spend money on experiences and paying resort prices even on a visit to family in depopulated parts. Housing costs went up over pandemic, do you think restaurant workers aren’t the FIRST ones prices out of the expensive Berkeley-adjacent areas? This has been the primary warning about unaffordable housing. For 10 years people have been asking how you’re going to find good help where working people can’t afford to live. Also sexual harassment and sub-$4/hr tipped min wage didn’t stop for people who were able to keep restaurants jobs over pandemic and workers talk. I know, the nerve. Next they’ll organize…
- throwaway7492 5y agoI appreciate your analysis of Berkeley housing prices possibly driving out low wage workers. That's the kind of discussion and analysis I was asking for, as opposed to the strawman in the article. That said, Berkeley has ~$16 minimum wage, which applies to restaurant workers before tips. Additionally, housing prices plummeted in Berkeley during the pandemic. My apartment dropped 16.9% in price during the pandemic, although prices are now returning. I believe the average for San Francisco was closer to a 7% drop. I do not have data for Berkeley specifically. Couple that with an eviction moratorium followed by rent forgiveness, and I don't believe that your argument holds. Again, I appreciate the further discussion and analysis, as this is an interesting and far from simple economic phenomenon.