8 ms·
Genuine question: what do you think "defund the police" means? And a follow-up question: have you spent time trying to understand what the people who say that
by simonw 5y ago
Genuine question: what do you think "defund the police" means?
And a follow-up question: have you spent time trying to understand what the people who say that are campaigning for, or did you make a snap judgement?
(Personally I think "defund the police" is a poorly chosen slogan because it is so easily misunderstood)
- chipotle_coyote 5y ago> Personally I think "defund the police" is a poorly chosen slogan because it is so easily misunderstood This, many times over -- with the caveat that I haven't been able to think of a more accurate phrase that still fits on a bumper sticker. "Narrow the scope of responsibility for the police and reallocate funding to other resources to handle non-criminal duties" isn't very catchy, but it's closer to what most activists are calling for.
- simonw 5y agoYeah, it's hard for me to whole-heartedly criticize the slogan when the people who have made it stick have thought about this issue (and the way to promote it) a lot harder than I have. It's certainly been effective in spreading the idea!
- briffle 5y ago> Genuine question: what do you think "defund the police" means? To some people, it means take some of the money from the police, and have actual trained counselors, mental health crisis workers, etc. I have heard of many that hold up CAHOOTS [0] in Eugene, OR as a model, that are MUCH cheaper than police, to help interceed in some cases, where police do not have the training. (the police training for gaining compliance seems to be using taser, force or weapon of some sort, since they are trained for extreme situations) To others it means completely abolish the police. However, I have heard very few with this view personally, but according to those on the complete opposite side of the political spectrum, this is what they all mean when they say it. [0] https://whitebirdclinic.org/cahoots/ https://whitebirdclinic.org/cahoots/
- heydonovan 5y agoIt's such a confusing slogan (probably on purpose, like most things political). I thought it meant to abolish the police. Even a quick search defines it as "prevent from continuing to receive funds". If folks intend it to mean "reduce funds" or "reallocate funds", then we should say that.
- jib_flow 5y agoI've had people try to tell me "all cops are bastards" actually means we need to do a better job policing the police, with a straight face. Poorly chosen slogans seem like they really hurt the movement. But maybe the ACAB crowd truly does think all cops are bastards.
- huragok 5y agoThe good ones aren't good for long, either turned or pushed out.
- pydry 5y agoIt's a sensible default assumption for interacting with the police.
- heyparkerj 5y agoACAB is another poorly chosen slogan for its best interpretation. The most moderate explanation is that to bastardize means “to change something in a way that makes it fail to represent the values and qualities that it is intended to represent” - the rest of the implication can be assumed from there.
- ska 5y ago> But maybe the ACAB crowd truly does think all cops are bastards. I once had an interesting discussion with someone about this who had obviously thought about it a fair bit. Their position was that the institution is set up in such a way that your own intentions, regardless of how good, are systemically constrained into a narrow channel and the function of the job is to be "a bastard". In other words, it wasn't a commentary of the nature of the people in the job, rather the nature of the job.
- klyrs 5y agoThe most common interpretation I've heard for this phrase is a contrast to the "few bad apples" meme, because police consistently show solidarity in defense of those "bad apples." If you're getting beaten by a cop, and their partner is just standing by and watching it happen, they're both bastards. That said... the cops who made the news for shoving other cops off from kneeling on protesters' necks? They were good cops in that moment. Even if they were doing it to protect their precinct from scandal.
- gmadsen 5y agoThe issue is that it is vague and has several implicit meanings and includes groups that want to divert funding to more community services to aid police, such as mental health crisis units, so police don't have to do things they don't have training for then you have others that genuinely want to defund police completely, arguing that the institution itself is a vestige of civil war times to protect wealthy white property/slave owners I believe this is intentional, as it gives extremist a softer platform. Same can be said about the BLM organization that has an explicit communistic agenda, while the movement is a broad group fighting against police violence and general civil liberties
- pseudalopex 5y agoThere is no Black Lives Matter organization. There is an organization called Black Lives Matter Global Network Foundation that would like to be seen as the BLM organization. But they have much less influence than local groups and The Movement for Black Lives. Also BLMGNF called themselves Marxist not communist.
- gmadsen 5y agobesides Marxist/communist , that was my point...
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- pseudalopex 5y agoYour point was you shouldn't call it what you did?
- vorpalhex 5y agoIt means to abolish the police by removing funding. The attempt to downplay the ask here is a form of Motte and Bailey. https://www.nytimes.com/2020/06/12/opinion/sunday/floyd-abolish-defund-police.html https://www.nytimes.com/2020/06/12/opinion/sunday/floyd-abol...
- colinmhayes 5y agoOp-eds exist to be hot takes. Abolish the police is not even close to the consensus among defund the police supporters.
- vorpalhex 5y agoThe sources seem to disagree with your claim. https://www.blackenterprise.com/black-lives-matter-leader-outlines-five-year-plan-to-eliminate-police/ https://www.blackenterprise.com/black-lives-matter-leader-ou...
- whydoibother 5y agoThat link is talking about one person from one part of a large, varied group of people. Don't see how that shows a consensus.
- colinmhayes 5y agoBlack lives matter doesn't have leaders. ANyone claiming to be is a charlatan. It doesn't matter what this person said, most BLM supporters and defund the police supporters don't want to abolish the police.
- vorpalhex 5y agoBLM certainly has recognized, well known leaders with both national and local chapters.
- johnjj257 5y agoThat is a very straw manned interpretation of the phrase. I don't particularly love the phrase myself but this is a dishonest interpretation. Of course a few people probably believe that but it's a giant movement and the large majority do not seem to think that way at all... Maybe take more opinions than a couple op eds. Have you even spoken to anyone or gone to an event? I live in a city with a lot of demonstrations and you quickly learn that isn't the phrases intent or ideology for nearly everyone except extreme outliers and agitators.
- colechristensen 5y agoI think it is an idea that alienates people who actually want and can achieve pragmatic change and attracts people who have passion more than sense, and ultimately either accidentally or intentionally (by someone) ensuring that the broad motivation to make positive progress is derailed by the disorganization of a movement that doesn't really know what it's about or what it wants. It is vague "on purpose" because the things which actually need to change are subtle, require understanding of specific circumstances and deatails, involve compromise and human understanding of the failings of people, and generally nothing else fits on poster boards. If I were a little more paranoid I might be suggesting that the bad slogans of protest worlds are actively being encouraged by sophisticated opponents of these movements in order to ensure that they achieve nothing. If someone really wants change, they should say it instead of accusing people who question them of not understanding their poorly chosen message.
- AbrahamParangi 5y agoDoes the idea that it’s a “poorly chosen slogan” not seem odd to you? Isn’t the parsimonious explanation that people kinda mean what they say?
- zdragnar 5y agohttps://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Police_abolition_movement_in_Minneapolis https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Police_abolition_movement_in... In minneapolis, defund and abolish were used interchangeably, and 9nof 13 city councillors did sign on to abolishment. Since the community backlash, they have largely given up on abolishment and stuck with defunding as if it means something different now than it did a year ago.
- colechristensen 5y agoThis is my world. And in Minneapolis just this week I had to wait on the phone 45 minutes to file a police report I've heard nothing back from after being attacked in a road rage incident. The person I did finally reach was definitely a decent human, but not trained to receive the kind of report I was giving and thought she shouldn't be taking it at all. (besides a sense of insecurity, lots of tiny glass pricks, a brief blood pressure spike, and a broken window I am well enough) I have doubts that the state is doing enough to protect me or to address crimes that have happened, not because of some panicked sense of irrational fear, but because I had to spend an hour with shards of glass in my pants on hold on Wednesday along with the delightful experience of vacuuming glass out of my hair at a car wash. The last time I had the displeasure of talking with the city attorney, they declined to do anything about death threats I had received from a known source. I'm thinking of buying a gun.
- zdragnar 5y agoUptown, NE, all kinds of areas have changed drastically for the worse over thr past few years. Having a friend of a friend casually explain how he just leaned his seat back when he heard gunshots sitting in a drive through was really telling. That, and a family coworker us ending his lease early and moving out of NE minneapolis after a bullet came through the wall and narrowly missed his cat's head. Another coworker had a car window smashed in overnight in uptown because he forgot to not lock thr car doors when he parked on the street. I understand that country living isn't for everyone, but I don't think you could pay me enough to move back to a dense urban setting.
- 5y ago