5 ms·
It's not clear to me that this was a poor decision. You can't send children to school if there are no teachers. And the teachers were not going to put their liv
by jfengel 5y ago
It's not clear to me that this was a poor decision. You can't send children to school if there are no teachers. And the teachers were not going to put their lives on the line for those jobs. Teachers are well aware that whatever is going around among the students will get to them. They get every cold and ever flu.
If school boards said, "We're staying open for the sake of the children", teachers would have said, "Fine, watch them yourselves."
Compared to that, remote learning was a no-brainer. It's obviously deeply imperfect, and that cost students, but it at least made schooling possible. That literally may not have been the case any other way: send the students to a school building and they may have been the only ones there.
- Natsu 5y agoHonestly, I wonder if remote learning couldn't be better for at least some student populations. I have family who were bullied terribly (think on the level of "attacked by a crazy person with a knife at school" and "sexually harassed by teachers") and they probably would've benefited from an easier way of getting away from their tormentors instead of having to quit school and get a GED. I know that's not a one-size-fits-all thing, people are social after all and isolation causes its own issues, but I sort of wonder if remote learning can't become an option for kids, especially those who are poorly-served by their local schools.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- AndrewBissell 5y ago> And the teachers were not going to put their lives on the line for those jobs. Many of them were at greater risk of death from driving to school than they were from Covid.
- w-j-w 5y agoDoes this pass for an argument now? Plenty of teachers are also severely at risk, and there is good reason to think that many would have died painful, preventable deaths had they taught in person.
- tboyd47 5y agoYou were downvoted because of how the current generation of adults judges your comment; but how will the next generation see things? I haven't heard any discussion about this question, at all, and frankly, it disturbs me, today's children are tomorrow's adults. Somehow, I don't think, "think of the teachers," or "we didn't think it through" will be good enough for them.
- w-j-w 5y agoThis comment confuses me. The teachers themselves are worthy of moral consideration, and that doesn't change because they are going to be dead later anyways. The alternative also would have done considerable damage. Plenty of kids would have witnessed their teachers literally give up their life to teach them. Do you think those kids would view that as worthwhile?
- Jill_the_Pill 5y agoThis argues we must drastically improve traffic safety, not just accept driving and covid risks.
- tmn 5y agoNot necessarily. There is an opposing argument that we need to accept the risk of death as a part of life. When does a population decide the risk has been reduced enough? I could argue we are well past that point. As a culture we have completely lost touch with the natural cycles of life. The boomers in positions of power have clearly prioritized their own safety at the expense of the upcoming generations. That's probably inflammatory. But it's a popular opinion where I'm from that isn't vocalized in the media. Without trying to say one take is right or wrong, this can in a lot ways be reduced to the security vs freedom tradeoff.
- void_mint 5y agoWhen everyone runs the risk of dying in traffic accidents in quick succession, every individual traffic accident becomes more problematic
- AndrewBissell 5y ago"Keeping schools closed was necessary to prevent hospitals from being overwhelmed" is a different argument from "teachers don't want to face the mortal peril of in-person instruction," and not the one that was made in favor of keeping schools closed.
- void_mint 5y agoKids infect eachother -> Kids infect teachers and their parents -> Hospitals overwhelmed When hospitals are overcrowded any injury has a higher mortality rate. Teachers not wanting to die is a totally fine reason to close schools, too.
- jfengel 5y agoNo, they weren't. There are half a million COVID deaths last year. There are around 30,000 deaths a year from automobile accidents. COVID is more deadly than automobile accidents, by an order of magnitude.
- AndrewBissell 5y agoUnlike automobile accidents, risk of death from Covid varies substantially according to age and whether one has any comorbidities.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- mk81 5y ago>There are half a million COVID deaths last year. What a joke. Please read about excess mortality before saying stupid things. Most people who die in car crashes wouldn't have died otherwise. Huge numbers of people who died "from COVID" would have died from something else.
- musicale 5y ago> Please read about excess mortality The World Mortality Dataset: Tracking excess mortality across countries during the COVID-19 pandemic https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC7852240.2/ https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC7852240.2/ "Summing up the excess mortality estimates across all countries in our dataset gives 3.3 million excess deaths. In contrast, summing up the official COVID-19 death counts gives only 2.1 million deaths." Interestingly enough, their conclusion was that covid deaths are being undercounted: "At the time of writing, the world’s official COVID-19 death count is 2.9 million. Our results suggest that the true toll may be above 4.5 million."
- AndrewBissell 5y agolol so in a year where tons of the developing world was forced into food insecurity as a byproduct of Covid response and lockdowns, they want to attribute every excess death to "Covid"?
- intrepidhero 5y agoMy research says this claim is false. The mortality rate for COVID-19 for all age groups is much higher that mortality rates for drivers. How I compared the risks: In New York the mortality rate for COVID-19 for all age groups over 18 was found to be at least 0.2%[1]. The CDC[2] reports 18-29 years at 0.5%, 30-39 at 1.4%, 40-49 at 3.5%, 50-64 at 16.4%. There were 36,560[3] motor vehicle related deaths in 2018 in the US. With 273,602,100[4] cars on the road one could make a rough estimate of mortality of 0.013%. This number is conservatively high since it does not include passengers. [1] https://www.worldometers.info/coronavirus/coronavirus-age-sex-demographics/ https://www.worldometers.info/coronavirus/coronavirus-age-se... [2] https://www.cdc.gov/mmwr/volumes/69/wr/mm6942e1.htm#T1_down https://www.cdc.gov/mmwr/volumes/69/wr/mm6942e1.htm#T1_down [3] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Motor_vehicle_fatality_rate_in_U.S._by_year https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Motor_vehicle_fatality_rate_in... [4] https://www.statista.com/statistics/183505/number-of-vehicles-in-the-united-states-since-1990/ https://www.statista.com/statistics/183505/number-of-vehicle...
- AndrewBissell 5y agoSeveral problems with this analysis: - Using confirmed cases as the denominator significantly overstates the fatality rate, because a large share of the total infections is never confirmed - "All age groups over 18" elides huge disparities between the younger and older age groups. It also obscures large differences in risk between those with comorbidities vs those without. The CDC does not make this easy to parse out, but in Canada after their first wave, "100% of the COVID-involved deaths under the age of 45 as of July 31 had at least one other disease or condition certified on the medical certificate of death." https://web.archive.org/web/20210219195135if_/https://www150.statcan.gc.ca/n1/pub/45-28-0001/2020001/article/00087-eng.htm https://web.archive.org/web/20210219195135if_/https://www150... - New York as a region had one of the highest fatality rates of the entire pandemic - Covid is a "one-and-done" risk as far as we know, while the risk of a car accident is repeated year after year for as long as one drives on the roads. Even in the absence of vaccines, the risk of death from Covid is unlikely to remain as high in 2024 as it was in 2020. The most sound way to run this sort of comparison is something like "how many in risk group X (say, people aged 30-39 with no comorbidities) died in 2020 from Covid vs how many in that group die in a typical year from auto accidents?" If you want to say that overweight 60 year old teachers with diabetes should not have been forced back to in-person instruction you'll get no argument from me.
- musicale 5y agoI found this for Sweden: Open Schools, Covid-19, and Child and Teacher Morbidity in Sweden https://www.nejm.org/doi/full/10.1056/NEJMc2026670 https://www.nejm.org/doi/full/10.1056/NEJMc2026670 19 teachers per 100000 received intensive care through June 2020, and it's unclear if any died. Sweden's motor vehicle death rate is relatively low, 2 per 100,000 over an entire year (vs. 11 in the US), but that's over the entire population, not just teachers. The effects of school closures on SARS-CoV-2 among parents and teachers https://www.pnas.org/content/118/9/e2020834118 https://www.pnas.org/content/118/9/e2020834118 This article says that keeping schools open without masks or quarantines doubled covid risk for teachers and also affected partners as well as students' parents. It concluded that "keeping lower-secondary schools open had minor consequences for the overall transmission" but "results for teachers suggest that measures to protect teachers should be considered." They estimated 9 parents (out of 646K), 1 teacher (out of 73K), and 1 partner (out of 47K) died from covid. However the data only appear to be through July.
- musicale 5y agoIn 2020 in California, some 51,000 people died from covid vs. 3,723 from traffic crash injuries. I haven't found exact statistics for both covid and crashes in 2020, but it looks like around 20% of covid deaths are in the 24-54 age range, as are around 45% of crash deaths, for an estimated 10,000 covid deaths vs. 1675 crash deaths in that age range. So in spite of California's high traffic crash rate, covid deaths seem to have been a much greater risk in 2020 for the 24-54 age group.
- Wowfunhappy 5y agoAs someone who is literally studying to be a teacher, I don't think teachers were being entirely reasonable throughout the pandemic. Particularly a little later on when we didn't have vaccines yet, but knew more about how the virus spread and were somewhat better at treating it. Yes, teachers didn't sign up for this. Neither did grocery store workers or—in many cases—even nurses and other hospital staff. Everyone did what they had to to stop the world from collapsing.
- MattGaiser 5y agoLots of grocery store workers, nurses, and doctors sat the pandemic out too. Grocery stores needed to increase pay to keep people. Where I am, nurses were often in short supply. Anecdotally know a bunch of physicians who took the past year off.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- CarelessExpert 5y ago> It's not clear to me that this was a poor decision. I can tell you, around here, infection rates clearly tracked with school closures, and did so independently of other lockdown measures. So I frankly do not buy any narrative that claims that school closures weren't justified as a means to control spread. School closures are clearly a tool in the arsenal for controlling spread, and the decision then becomes one of context: how bad are local infection rates, what is the trend line, etc, and is the reduction in infection rates from school closures justified when considering the downsides.
- astalwick 5y agoIt was possible in other countries. My children (Quebec) were in class all of last year, except for a 10 day period in January - the tail end of a local lockdown at the height of the third wave. Infection rates were certainly higher due to schools opening, but other decisions - and a population that was mostly tolerant of restrictions - mitigated that. We wore masks, we limited contact and we stayed home to the extent possible. As a result, schools were able to stay open.
- bellyfullofbac 5y agoBut staying home surely wouldn't help if the virus came home with Little Billy? And I'm guessing nobody wore masks and limited contact with their own children in their own homes...
- astalwick 5y agoIf a child or a teacher at a school caught covid, the entire class was fully quarantined for a minimum of 14 days and two negative covid tests were necessary for anyone in that class to return. Classes were kept fully isolated from one another, and children had to wear masks in class for a significant part of the year. No teacher at our school (~600 children) caught covid, and only 3 classes were closed. What I'm getting at is: it was fully possible to open up schools, provided you have a government and a population that is willing to accept restrictions in other areas. _It's a choice to close schools and demand that indoor restaurant dining stay open_.
- GVIrish 5y agoI would go one step further. We wouldn't have had to close schools for so long or at all if we had responded aggressively to Covid before the outbreak got large. South Korea largely controlled their outbreak without lockdowns because they aggressively tested, contact traced, and quarantined in the early days of the pandemic. Today, South Korea has something like 1/300th as many deaths even though it has about 1/5th the population of the United States. The US had its first confirmed case on the same day as South Korea but was much slower to respond. Had we had a more robust response, we might not have had to make these tough choices about closing schools.
- wsatb 5y agoThis, and not just the US, the West in general. Everyone concerned about the long term consequences of these closures needs to look no further than our leadership mostly ignoring it and thinking we were somehow immune. Heck, even after taking some measures, many parts of the nation/world then reopened too early only to see multiple surges.
- HonestOp001 5y agoThere were intimations at closing down the border from President Trump, howls of racism were made. Nancy Pelosi went down to Chinatown and asked what was the president afraid of. The president tried to take action, but politics was and is involved. We have a report from last week saying that scientists were afraid to speak up because of fear for saying orange man bad was correct. If you believe these super simple arguments of hard lock downs would have worked, then look at how the guy at imperial college who screwed us all over with his horrible forecasts. He said “lockdown to save is all.” Then proceeds to visit his mistress, one of the two had coronavirus! How do you think we could legitimately implement a lockdown when the people who scream lockdown do not implement it themselves (athletes sneaking ladies, Newsome, Whitmer, etc.).
- HKH2 5y agoPelosi flouted the lockdown too by getting her hair done at a salon that wasn't allowed to open.
- 5y ago