5 ms·
I am highly in favor of this type of self contained technology. The last thing we need is for the grid to become inadvertently dependent on the cell network, wh
by amluto 5y ago
I am highly in favor of this type of self contained technology. The last thing we need is for the grid to become inadvertently dependent on the cell network, which is, in turn, dependent on the grid. If there’s a multi-day outage that takes out the cell battery backups, the grid needs to be able to start up independently. This is hard enough without accidental networking dependencies.
(I believe that at least some of the blatant inequity in the Texas blackouts was necessary for this type of reason. There were various critical facilities (gas pumping stations, for example) that, if shut down due to rolling blackouts, would have further reduced grid capacity.)
- JumpCrisscross 5y ago> the grid to become inadvertently dependent on the cell network, which is, in turn, dependent on the grid The grid wouldn't be dependent on the cell network. Billing would.
- willis936 5y agoIf I don't get billed for my power usage then I'm 100% craning my AC, as will everyone else.
- JumpCrisscross 5y ago> If I don't get billed for my power usage then I'm 100% craning my AC, as will everyone else Sorry, in what relevant scenario does the power company never get paid? OP pointed out a potential feedback loop between the cell network going down and the grid failing. Are you suggesting everyone will crank up their AC when the network fails because the power company will have some difficulty collecting metering data that day?
- cesarb 5y agoIf modern smart meters are anything like classic mechanical meters, they have a counter of the total amount of power consumed so far, and the power company bills the difference between the current reading and the previous month's reading. Which means that, once the meter can be read again, you will be billed for all the power consumed in the meantime.
- sfteus 5y agoSmart meters still retain the total overall usage. Even if the power company doesn't read it for 3 months, they'll see the increased usage the next time they come by and apply it to your next bill.
- RC_ITR 5y agoThe rumor on the Colonial Pipeline hacks isn't that core infrastructure was affected, it was that the billing system was. I think most utilities would act in the same way.
- germinalphrase 5y agoThat is a widely reported fact rather than a rumor.
- RC_ITR 5y agoReally? A quick google didn’t turn anything up. Source?
- germinalphrase 5y agoNot the most specific look at this question, but the facts are relatively clear. “ The company halted operations because its billing system was compromised, three people briefed on the matter told CNN, and they were concerned they wouldn't be able to figure out how much to bill customers for fuel they received. One person familiar with the response said the billing system is central to the unfettered operation of the pipeline. That is part of the reason getting it back up and running has taken time, this person said. Asked about whether the shutdown was prompted by concerns about payment, the company spokesperson said, "In response to the cybersecurity attack on our system, we proactively took certain systems offline to contain the threat, which temporarily halted all pipeline operations, and affected some of our IT systems." At this time, there is no evidence that the company's operational technology systems were compromised by the attackers, the spokesperson added” Source: https://edition.cnn.com/2021/05/12/politics/colonial-pipeline-ransomware-payment/index.html https://edition.cnn.com/2021/05/12/politics/colonial-pipelin...
- RC_ITR 5y agoCool - I assumed it was true but couldn't find any evidence. Thanks!
- amluto 5y agoA surprising number of modern smart meters contain relays that can be used to wirelessly disconnect customers. I don’t know whether this feature is used for load shedding and/or startup, but it certainly could be. As an aside, there are distressing reports of meter-associated fires. These seem to come in two categories: installation issues (poor contact between meter and socket) and issues with the relay itself. The former is not specific to smart meters per se, but the latter is. A device that can safely switch 100-320A at 240V is not that cheap and not that small, and I suspect that some smart meter manufacturers try to cut costs.
- jcalvinowens 5y agoI'm sorry, the idea that utilities are putting underrated contactors in power meters is fearmongering hogshit. Cite a source or shut up.
- ableal 5y agoCan confirm the first part - had the utility turn on a meter remotely, so they can turn it off too. Also, around here (Portugal) you're billed for the maximum power in your contract - it starts at 3.45 kVA, I think, with 6.9 and 10.35 levels commonly available (at 230 volts, that's 15, 30 or 45 amps). Used to be that a hardware circuit breaker enforced that limit, nowadays it's the meter cutting off supply in case of excess power draw. (No reports of fires that I've heard of.)
- reaperducer 5y agoI don’t know whether this feature is used for load shedding and/or startup, but it certainly could be. The last two places I lived, it was. In the more recent one, residential customers who didn't opt in to the smart thermostat, which allows the power company to override your temperature settings in an emergency, could be automatically cut off from the grid in a crisis. In the older one, a factory I worked for was part of a program where they volunteered to be cut off from the grid remotely in the event of a power emergency. The factory got some kind of discount or rebate for being part of the program.
- HeyLaughingBoy 5y agoAt least in my area they can. I have an agreement with the power company that they can shut off my A/C for up to, IIRC, 10 minutes at a time with some maximum total time off per day to load shed in times of high load. In return I get a discount on power during the summer months. Except for the first year where there was a bug that turned it off for an hour at a time, it's never been noticeable.
- theshrike79 5y agoThe grid will work just fine without any cell connections. The connection in home smart meters is used mostly just for consumption data and maybe remote diagnostics. In some cases it's used for load management, but this requires a written contract with the user. Basically it goes "You let us turn off your AC/Furnace/other high load unit during load peaks and we'll give you a discount on your electric bill." Just the information on which meters can't be connected to (due to cell networks being down) gives the power company a bunch of data on where the actual fault is located.
- unethical_ban 5y agoIt's a violation of privacy - it makes it that much easier for people to see how much electricity or water you consume. It isn't necessarily a secret, but it is not so easy to find out when you have to go to a meter directly.
- jakemauer 5y agoIt definitely is enough of a matter of privacy that PGE wouldn’t reveal any details of the previous tenant’s usage patterns when I called concerned about the amount of energy we were using in our new place. If it’s too private to share in that context it shouldn’t be blasted out unencrypted to anyone with an antenna. (Also I realize we’re talking about Texas but I would assume/hope they have the same restrictions on sharing info as PGE.)
- eldaisfish 5y agoit isn't really. Most commercial meters that use this tech are encrypted. It is possible to obtain the key for your own meter but that's about it.
- ArkanExplorer 5y agoHow could that possibly be a privacy concern? A lot more private information is already placed onto the street, in public: the contents of your garbage cans.
- unethical_ban 5y agoNow imagine a technology that scans the contents, listing the type, number, and mass of each item, and broadcasts it so that anyone driving by can instantly read it. It's not binary accessible v. non-accessible, it's level of effort.
- tzs 5y agoIt often actually isn't hard for someone to find out even if you have one of the meters that has to be read by eye. It is quite common for those meters to be placed so that they are visible from a public street or alley, so that meter readers can read them without entering the property. Here is one electric company that talks about this in their meter reading FAQ [1]. > The numbers on a electric meter are clearly visible from six to ten feet away. And, by noting the position of the dial indicators, an experienced meter reader can accurately read an electric meter from as far away as twenty feet. We also provide binoculars and/or monoculars for readings beyond the range where the dials are not clearly visible. [1] https://www.snopud.com/home/homefaqs/faqmtrread.ashx?p=1285 https://www.snopud.com/home/homefaqs/faqmtrread.ashx?p=1285
- MomoXenosaga 5y agoMost countries don't have the weird and insane rating plan that Texas did. What I pay for water/gas/electricity doesn't fluctuate 500% from hour to hour.
- cycomanic 5y agoBut using your own argument, your electricity grid is now dependent on the road "network", so not self-contained. Moreover, I can imagine much worse scenarios than what you wrote about the cell tower batteries failing. Just imagine you have a snow storm and now you have to have a electricity company truck drive past people's home to restart their electricity. At least in the case of drained cell tower battery they only need to drive to one location.