3 ms·
If it's detecting 50 types of cancer and the patient doesn't have symptoms, do they just do a full body MRI to find the source? If so, why not just do full body
by giantg2 5y ago
If it's detecting 50 types of cancer and the patient doesn't have symptoms, do they just do a full body MRI to find the source? If so, why not just do full body scans which can find other issues, like aneurysms or the other almost 50% of positives that it missed?
I get that cost is a big issue, but it seems like the test is missing a lot and you might get more bang for the buck with a periodic MRI from the perspective of the number of potential issues it can find. Either way can result in false results.
- elif 5y agoI mostly agree. I had a CT scan of 1/3 of my body for a specific issue, but as a consequence I got very high confidence that I was cancer-free in that portion of my body. It is such a good feeling that part of me wants to pay out-of-pocket to get the rest checked. I think though that this test has massive value in earlier detection, cost, and remote lab work.
- giantg2 5y agoDude, CTs can be risky. They use ionizing radiation, which increases your risk of cancer. It's really only an issue with repeated use, but I think there's a study out there claiming 50k early deaths each year can be attributed to repeated use of CTs. I don't have any medical background, but personally I would prefer imaging that does not use ionizing radiation when possible, just to save up some "credits" for when I may need to use the other type (like CT for possible stroke).
- doctoring 5y agoHey, radiologist here. So, the question of "what next" after a positive result on one of these tests is still... open. The Grail test provides indication of likely tissue of origin, so a likely first step may be a targeted study (e.g. colonoscopy if it said a colonic source, MRI if it said pancreatic). There may be role for PET/CT as well to further stage and assess for metastases, perhaps after finding a lesion. What to do if your blood test is positive but the workup is negative? Lots of discussion but nobody is quite sure. As for a periodic full body MRI, I will say that currently uh, most of those are garbage. Unfortunately, for a full body MRI to be practical (that is, to not take hours and hours), you have to run very few sequences. (For example, a dedicated MRI of say, your brain or your liver alone could take about hour, each.) As a result, you greatly reduce your sensitivity for most pathologies, which kind of is counter to the point of the MRI to begin with.
- giantg2 5y agoOh, so the test does give the source. I must have missed that part of the article thinking it was only identifying that there was a source in the cfDNA that was abnormal, but not realizing they could determine where it came from.