3 ms·
Is there anything going on here that suggests this is not a routine maintenance issue? The Kernel maintainers have a lot of people who want to submit code to t
by roenxi 5y ago
Is there anything going on here that suggests this is not a routine maintenance issue?
The Kernel maintainers have a lot of people who want to submit code to the kernel, and have to maintain standards. I'd imagine there are a lot of emails like this one.
Good on Huawei if they are incentivising open source contributions. Shame on them if they are wasting OSS maintainer time. Presumably well done Qu for promoting some order in a chaotic world.
- nevinera 5y agoIt's not nefarious, it's a pattern of a particular company trying to game a metric, to boost their reputation. Pretend you were a dev, and your effectiveness was mostly described within your 500-engineer department in terms of "how many pull-requests" you merged each month. In the abstract, that seems like a reasonable metric to use - it does seem to correlate with actual output, and encourages smaller slicing (which is generally positive). But two years down the line, you find this one guy, consistently in the top 10 rankings, and you feel like he's just not accomplishing that much, so you start looking into his actual workstream. And you find that he does do normal work, but he produces 10 times as many 1-5 line PRs as the average, each of them adjusting some bit of copy or changing an error message. For the better! And his QA isn't bothered, because his work is very easy to verify. But he's not actually one of the most effective devs in the company, and it's really irritating that his process-games (a) seem to work (the VP of engineering definitely knows him as a 'high output engineer') and (b) impose some unnecessary load on other bits of the company's process (like the QAs and burning CI credits). That's the emotion in play here. "Stop wasting our time, we can see what you're doing."
- roenxi 5y agoThis looks boring. This is a scene that plays out in every company weekly. The stakes are trivial, there is no evidence of ill intent anywhere. Nobody has done anything particularly badly behaved. Nothing here is a shining example of good behaviour. There isn't a feel-good aspect. I suppose the question is, who are the 100+ people who upvoted this, and why?
- nevinera 5y agoI agree, I've no idea why it would be at the top of HN. Maybe China-hate?
- dbsmith83 5y agoHate is a strong word. Dismissing it as simply 'hate' is emotive language (and dishonest, I think) in that it tries to guide the reader to the conclusion that it is completely unreasonable. A more honest word to use would be 'mistrust'
- nevinera 5y ago"Hate" is a word that has a variety of meanings, and I was using it as a suffix - it's basically a synonym for '-aggro', a way to describing a pattern of oppositional or antagonistic behavior. (My usage is colloquial. If I were saying what you have mistakenly read it to mean, I would have mentioned hatred of China", or maybe "China hatred".) I am not using it "dishonestly", and I think that the conclusion it guides people to is completely reasonable and accurate - we should dismiss the majority of opinions that take the form "yup, that's just like China" or "China is doing this shit again? what a surprise." The behaviors of individual workers in a system where they're being incentivized improperly don't have anything to do with China's current geo-political actions, and I get tired of so many people acting like 'China' (or 'the GOP' or 'California') is a single coherent entity with self-consistent behavior at all scales.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- dbsmith83 5y agoYou're right, I read the phrase a little too literally. Apologies!
- dbsmith83 5y agoIt was good clickbait. The title made me think something similar to the recent security issue with the University of Minnesota[1] was happening again, but from Huawei this time [1] - https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=26887670 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=26887670
- bsder 5y agoThe point is that if you were serious about fixing the spelling stuff, you'd put it into a single patch and not break it apart. The fact that all these fixes are in separate patches means that its being used to game a Key Performance Indicator.