3 ms·
You’re making an unwarranted assumption: that the choice is between early detection with current responses to detected cancers and no early detection at all. Op
by amluto 5y ago
You’re making an unwarranted assumption: that the choice is between early detection with current responses to detected cancers and no early detection at all. Optimizing the response to an early detection will give a result no worse than either of those, since the choices of what to do include doing whatever doctors did in the studies that have poor results as well as doing nothing at all.
- jacquesm 5y agoNo, that is not the assumption. The assumption is that the only way in which such a test will be useful is by applying it absent symptoms to the population en-masse aka screening. And that - no matter who good the test, and no matter how early - leads to a decrease in positive patient outcomes. This is established medical science, and it pains me to have to continue to point out the same thing over and over again, but since I started with this response I feel obliged to continue to do so. The outcome of a cancer treatment is not pre-determined, there are a lot of individual factors at play here that will have a huge effect on the outcome, possibly much larger than the effect of that particular cancer itself. So en-masse screening leading to an increased number of treatments of pre-symptomatic cancers with those current responses is not a choice, we know that this will lead to a worse outcome across a population. Early detection does not add anything to that. If you could pick out those individuals for which early detection would make a difference then that would be a gamechanger, and here the ball is currently in the genetics court. The other part where major change can be made is by finding ways to treat cancers in a way that is non-invasive and does not put the patient further at risk (so no surgery, chemotherapy or radiation therapy).
- Silhouette 5y agoAnd that - no matter who good the test, and no matter how early - leads to a decrease in positive patient outcomes. You keep writing comments in absolute terms and talking about evidence, but how do you reconcile your position with the results of successful screening programmes like cervical smear testing? Detecting and treating high risk HPV before it causes changes that can turn into cervical cancer has dramatically reduced the harm caused by cervical cancer itself at a population level. Routine screening of this type isn't normally recommended for young women, but it becomes increasingly effective with age and screening programmes operate accordingly.
- jacquesm 5y agoYes, but that's one specific cancer. There are a few others for which this is the case and absent genetic data a few that are borderline cases (notably: breast cancer, where the presence or absence of a mutation is a very relevant bit of data).
- Silhouette 5y agoSo you do agree that evidence-based screening programmes can be effective then? In that case, I'm sorry but I don't quite understand the point you're trying to make here.
- jacquesm 5y agoYes, they can, but not in a blanket fashion where a test with a relatively high false positive rate and a relatively low sensitivity (between 18 and 50% for this particular test) is released without patient outcomes as the main driver of whether or not to apply the test absent further symptoms. Whether this test is one that can serve in that particular role is definitely not something that has already been determined and those advocating for such are ignoring a mountain of established science and are simply jumping the gun. Policy is set by the overall effect of application, which can be quite different than applying that same tool in an individual setting. This whole thread started with "This is one of those medical revolutions that I am waiting dearly for. Facilities that are not hospitals(to avoid the risk of occupying medical devices that sick people need) built to _regulary_ check up otherwise healthy people for preventive care." And that is not something you do without taking into account the downsides. Whether this is revolutionary or not remains to be seen, it definitely is a useful test based on what I've read about it so far.
- Silhouette 5y agoWell, yes, it's only worth running a screening programme if you have a usefully accurate test and if you can then make some useful intervention after a positive result. Is anyone here disagreeing with that, though? Maybe we interpreted OP's comment that you quoted differently? I read it as being in favour of preventative medicine as a whole, not necessarily endorsing this specific test at this specific point in time. Maybe I'm also interpreting some of the other comments in this discussion, including yours, differently to how their authors intended them. My concern is that as written they appear to be criticising all use of screening, regardless of its efficacy, which is extremely dangerous.