3 ms·
Yup. Let’s say the test shows “very likely” for pancreatic cancer. Now you do imaging. Ok, nothing there? Now what? Biopsy? That’s general anesthesia now
by refurb 5y ago
Yup. Let’s say the test shows “very likely” for pancreatic cancer.
Now you do imaging. Ok, nothing there? Now what? Biopsy? That’s general anesthesia now and costly (for the patient or govt). Biopsy is negative. Now what? Start chemo? Watch and wait? For how long? Do a biopsy every 6 months?
None of these tests are 100% accurate. If broadly used, a false positive of 0.1% will result in tens of thousands getting unnecessary testing.
- someguydave 5y agoexactly, this screening is an invitation for overtreatment.
- kokey 5y agoI think for pancreatic cancer early detection just means it gives you more time to enjoy a slightly longer bucket list. For bowel cancers however, this could potentially buy many extra years since it's currently difficult to detect early.
- refurb 5y agoOne reason why pancreatic is so fatal is it doesn’t tend to get diagnosed until quite late, so this test could help here. But really early cancer (no identified mass) is more of a watch and wait thing.
- postingawayonhn 5y ago> Now you do imaging. Ok, nothing there? Now what? Put the patient on a more frequent screening schedule (blood tests and imaging) to pick up any growth.
- refurb 5y agoOk, now multiply this scenario by thousands. This sounds like a great way to bust your healthcare budget.