4 ms·
Adults can choose of their own free will how to live. But do they have the right to force a child into a life of disease, malnutrition and lack of education?
by refurb 5y ago
Adults can choose of their own free will how to live. But do they have the right to force a child into a life of disease, malnutrition and lack of education? What if the rest of society has to pay for the consequences of that choice?
- bookofsand 5y agoParents are and should be deciding the set of values and skills their children acquire. As the Amish demonstrate, there are ways to mix tradition and modernity in a functional package. However, it is highly likely that indigenous American parents would rather choose a modern education for their children. The myth that the indigenous American parents, given an informed choice, would somehow condemn their children to a life of deep poverty, malnutrition and disease outside of the industrial society is just a myth. Like indigenous Europeans, the vast majority of indigenous Americans would rather join the modern culture and enjoy the fruits of its incredible wealth generation structures. Small isolated pockets, like the Amish, notwithstanding. To those glamorizing preindustrial lifestyles, take a summer off your cushy six figure office job and go live in an unelectrified hut on some remote mountain, living off the land. With your spouse and kids. Wake up as soon as the sun rises, do hard labor all day long (e.g. manually mow a meadow with a scythe), eat polenta and maybe a bit of cheese, crash for the night, lather, rinse, repeat. Chances are you'll last less than a week. How do I know? I lasted about 10 minutes.
- acituan 5y agoNot trying to be sarcastic but looking at the child obesity rates and educational crises, medication rates etc; disease, malnutrition and lack of education are adjectives that also fit the US. This is exactly why “we know the right way, why won’t you just follow it” is just as an imperialistic and honestly arrogant point of view.
- refurb 5y agoSo your argument is “things aren’t perfect in the US, so the US has no right to claim its approach is better”? That’s an absurd statement. That’s like saying “well people still die of cancer with modern medicine so you can’t criticize my use of essential oils to treat my brain tumor”. Based on childhood mortality alone, let alone any other measures of childhood development, the current western approach is objectively the far better one.
- acituan 5y ago> Based on childhood mortality alone > So your argument is “things aren’t perfect in the US, so the US has no right to claim its approach is better”? That’s an absurd statement. The core of the problem is exemplified with cherry-picking a few metrics and generalizing it to a sense of superiority. In other words, the real absurdity is reducing complex multidimensional problems to a single "better than" metric, and acting as the world's savior based on that self-aggrandizement. US is by far not the best in many of childhood related metrics, yet have a disproportionate amount of arrogance regarding the superiority of its approaches. You are welcome to check PISA scores, ADHD diagnosis and medication rates, childhood obesity rates , adverse childhood experiences, single parenthood, juvenile delinquency etc. among the first world countries and see where US lands.
- refurb 5y agoAgain, it's entirely irrelevant if the US has continued problems. It's not "cherry picking" a few metrics when the metric is childhood mortality as in "less of our children died before they are 5". I can't imagine any civilization that would say that isn't an objectively superior outcome. Well maybe the Aztecs are willing to make an exception for child sacrifice? Not sure why everyone is so afraid to say one civilization has superior outcomes to another. To claim they don't is just hiding the truth and setting back the human condition.
- pbak 5y agoWho are you to decide of the superiority scale ? How would you even know if you are correctly setting it, even against what you think are your own standards ? What if your worldview is extremely warped, but you can't realize it, because you haven't ever looked outside of yourself ? What if you don't even know how to ? And what if, by chance, if by inheritance, you're very powerful ? Wouldn't that make you an immature inconsiderate ignorant twisted bully thinking he knows better ?
- refurb 5y agoYour response is bordering on the insane. If you’re arguing that “fewer dead children” is a standard that is culturally subjective, shouldn’t be applied to other civilizations, and might not be “the right standard” then I don’t know what to tell you.