3 ms·
"This is the law functioning as intended" The law creating Roth IRAs was intended for middle-class people, not billionaires. Likewise, the law allowing conver
by betterunix2 5y ago
"This is the law functioning as intended"
The law creating Roth IRAs was intended for middle-class people, not billionaires. Likewise, the law allowing conversions from Traditional to Roth IRAs was intended for the middle-class. A billionaire taking advantage of the Roth conversion to amass a Roth IRA worth billions is not even remotely what the relevant laws were intended for; that it is legal is an oversight on the part of Congress, who did not realize what they were drafting when they wrote the law.
Moreover, it is not as if billionaires need to exploit the IRA rules like this. Typically billionaires will avoid taxes by borrowing against the value of their assets, then deducting the interest they pay on those loans from the income they use to pay the interest (done right, this results in no income taxes). That is an example of the law working as intended.