3 ms·
Sounds like you would want more manual control over routing if you could have it. You and I want the same type of thing. I'm an end user not an administrator.
by 1vuio0pswjnm7 5y ago
Sounds like you would want more manual control over routing if you could have it. You and I want the same type of thing. I'm an end user not an administrator. I just prefer manual control over DNS. When I do purely authoritative lookups I see all the queries made. The way admins have configured things, it can be grossly inefficient, not to mention brittle. With one popular CDN, I can see something like seven queries just to resolve the IP address of a single domain name. I can alleviate some of the inefficiency and unecessary dependencies manually by querying certain servers directly. Geo-based routing makes sense sometimes (most times, perhaps) but, as you point out, not always. Sometimes with CDNs I will retreieve content from certain servers that so-called "smart" DNS-based routing would not recommend. Because in some cases they are in fact faster for me. The point is that it should be the user's choice which server to use. "Smart" stuff, letting others make decisions for us, should be optional not mandated; because, let's face it, this stuff isn't always as "smart" as it could be.
I should clarify what I meant by "there is no technical advantage anymore". There was a time when "personal" computers and internet were so slow, users could not be expected to do their own lookups. No one could be expected to run "BIND" on their own computer. Running something like Unbound, "Pi-hole" (dnsmasq) or countless other options was not feasible like it is today. A shared DNS cache run by a third party made sense. What I am suggesting is those days have passed. One of the authors of the popular O'Reilly books on DNS, a so-called "DNS expert" that most DNS administrators followed back in the early days, more or less admitted this many years ago. Technically, no one needs DNS "nannies" anymore. Users have the ability to exercise some manual control, if they so choose. I do my own DNS-based blocking.
Anyway, that's how I see it. One person's opinion.