4 ms·
Is there a consensus committee that announces what 'the community' thinks? Because in my experience the community is quite divided on most topics and tends to c
by roenxi 5y ago
Is there a consensus committee that announces what 'the community' thinks? Because in my experience the community is quite divided on most topics and tends to come to a consensus using the literal meaning of words.
There is always a risk that people chanting "defund the police" mean they want to, simply and literally, defund the police. If they want something different they should be chanting that instead.
- lostcolony 5y ago"There is always a risk" I think there's an easy way to figure out what people mean when they chant a slogan. Talk to them. "In my experience the community is quite divided on most topics and tends to come to a consensus using the literal meaning of words" Well, even if your experience is correct, so what? Defunding the police -as it currently exists-, in its entirety, and directing those funds to different agencies, including what the current police would turn into, is still removing 100% of the funds from the existing organization and redirecting them. No one is arguing to remove that funding and then setting that money on fire.
- roenxi 5y ago> Talk to them. They'll all have different opinions on what, in the detail, the phrase means. Large political crowds generally can't handle complex ideas. That is why the slogan matters, it is the bit that coordinates what the goal is. > Defunding the police -as it currently exists-, in its entirety, and directing those funds to different agencies... There are a few options. Major ones include: 1) This project is renaming the police. 2) This project is changing what they do. It probably isn't going to be 1, because then it wouldn't be worth the fuss. So the question is, which responsibilities of the police are we jettisoning here? Because the slogan suggests all of them. "Better funding for mental health" uses quite different syllables from "defund the police". I'm sure there are people with some great ideas in the crowd. But the ones in charge might be the people who believe, literally, that the point here is to defund everything the police do. There is a real risk people mean what they say.
- brutusborn 5y agoOur language is full of ambiguities, and this is one. Both interpretations are listed in the Cambridge dictionary. The truth is: clarity require lots of words, and that makes a terrible slogan. Most people react stronger to a slogan than a nuanced discussion, so the messy slogans will remain.
- zepto 5y agoThat doesn’t mean a bad slogan like Defund the police isn’t just divisive, ill-advised, and harmful.
- ceejayoz 5y agoThere's nothing activists can do that won't be labeled "divisive, ill-advised, and harmful". See how Martin Luther King Jr. was portrayed in the 1960s, for example. https://twitter.com/BerniceKing/status/1300196044693741574 https://twitter.com/BerniceKing/status/1300196044693741574
- torstenvl 5y agoThat's the trope, but it's also completely wrong. It was, after all, MLK and not Malcolm X who achieved so much of the progress in the 1960s. And it was the Log Cabin Republicans, not HRC, that won the fight for gay marriage. Advancements for minority groups are better facilitated by building bridges than by burning them.
- ceejayoz 5y agoMLK was regularly accused of burning bridges at the time, as I've demonstrated in the link.
- torstenvl 5y agoYou posted a Twitter link to one caricature cartoon in an unnamed paper. It is dishonest to say you've "demonstrated" that anything happened "regularly." And it is dishonest to conflate the entirety of the time elapsed - it's indisputably clear who has the better historical reputation. And it is dishonest to suggest that a false allegation of X is moral justification to begin doing X.
- 9wzYQbTYsAIc 5y ago> Is there a consensus committee that announces what 'the community' thinks? Science-based activism typically does have a tactic of discussing within “committees” called peer-reviewed journals that which is considered the consensus and that which is not for that journal’s “community”.