7 ms·
Here is another headline, The world relies on two chip marker in South Korea for NAND and DRAM, leaving Everyone Vulnerable. Although arguably NAND and DRAM ar
by ksec 5y ago
Here is another headline, The world relies on two chip marker in South Korea for NAND and DRAM, leaving Everyone Vulnerable.
Although arguably NAND and DRAM are commodities, and US already has a back up strategy ( Micron ).
- Archio 5y agoArguably as well, South Korea is underneath significantly less geopolitical threat than Taiwan.
- dkjaudyeqooe 5y agoThat depends on how crazy the current leader of North Korea feels at any moment, given the huge standing army it has, as well as the nukes.
- epberry 5y agoSouth Korea is not 100 miles from China and has a massive US military presence. This article is about the very real danger that China invades Taiwan - which it has already stated it wants to do (in case the military flyovers were not convincing) - and cuts off the world from the best silicon.
- Koiwai 5y agoI don't want to argue if China will "invade" Taiwan. But what make you think China will "cut off the world" IF that happens? That's not how this works, that's not how any of this works.
- brazzy 5y agoNo, they wouldn't deliberately stop selling the product of intact, fully staffed fabs after gaining control of them. But we're not talking about a corporate takeover. We're talking about a naval invasion of a very densely populated and well defended island. That might involve heavy artillery bombardment and prolonged urban combat, maybe a guerilla war and sabotage actions. There is no guarantee that the fabs are still operational after all that.
- Koiwai 5y agoThen what will China get from that? I mean, we're on different political sides, not good vs evil, please acknowledge that.
- jopsen 5y ago> we're on different political sides, not good vs evil One of the sides runs a series of concentration camps. Sells organs from political prisoners, etc. But yes, I suppose it's just politics. Personally, I think genocide is slightly evil, but feel free to disagree.
- Koiwai 5y agoThat's another political campaign, run by a Washington based agency, look that up, they are not even trying to hide that. If, I mean If, China is evil, wouldn't that make any country not declaring war to China evil too?
- jopsen 5y ago> That's another political campaign, run by a Washington based agency Independent media across the globe and across political spectrums have reported that China has locked away >= 1M people in concentration camps. Claiming that the Uyghur genocide is made up is just trolling. These things have been documented for years. And the Uyghur is not the only minority to be persecuted. Tell me who is the Dalai Lama working for? > wouldn't that make any country not declaring war to China evil too? I think you'll have to ask a philosopher, if evil is a transitive property :) But my two cents is (1) NO! (2) War is not the solution. Honestly, war is very rarely a good solution. Sanctions a political pressure might be better tools.
- Koiwai 5y ago> Independent media across the globe and across political spectrums have reported that China has locked away >= 1M people in concentration camps. "Independent media"
- jopsen 5y ago> what make you think China will "cut off the world" IF that happens? You think leading US chip designers would send their designs to China? The well organized state of industrial espionage by China, is a pretty good reason this won't happen. Furthermore, the rest of the world would be forced to embargo anything related to Taiwan.
- Koiwai 5y agoYeah, US tried to use politics to ban Chinese 5G equipments, from recent news, I don't think that's going very well.
- jopsen 5y agoNot sure how that's relevant, 5G is an entirely different topic. The reason advanced chip factories are located in China is that they are expensive and Chinese authorities can't be trusted. Adding to that is that sending your chip designs to China, is a sure way to get them stolen. Lots of companies don't sell the latest tech in China. And don't manufacture in china because their designs would be stolen. This is not a problem for cheap manufacturing, but for high tech stuff it might be...
- Koiwai 5y agoWhen it's not very well aligned to your argument, it suddenly becomes irrelevant, very convenient.
- Koiwai 5y agoI'd like to remind you, TSMC's most famous clients, Apple, Qualcomm, NVIDIA, AMD, happens to be US companies, IF what you said really happens, basically China gets a steaming pile with barely any use.
- robgibbons 5y agoChina is doing everything it can to create a domestic chip industry, even going so far as to poach TSMC engineers to support SMIC. To suggest that they have no domestic use for TSMC and its products is ignoring reality.
- Koiwai 5y agoTSMC needs lots of clients to survive, fabs are very heavy assets, I said "barely any use", not "no use".
- newswasboring 5y agoHere is another one. World relies on only one relatively obscure dutch company for its EUV lithography equipment. For DUV the market is divided between 3 players two in japan and the aforementioned one. Apps market for semiconductors is also cornered by two companies. This whole space has consolidated in last decade or so. Everyone wants to have full control over their supply chain, so everyone is trying to buy their entire supply chain.
- riffraff 5y agoThere's also a surprisingly tiny market for stepper makers, which I didn't even know where a complex thing until a few months ago.
- sydthrowaway 5y agoAny competitors to ASML?
- newswasboring 5y agoNo real competitors. They own the EUV market because they own the only company making EUV sources (Cymer). They also work very closely with Zeiss and co own some of the important patents I think (but don't quote me on this). A Japanese company Gigaphoton made a EUV source, but I am not aware of any orders from any major fab to them. I think since 2018 they are just trying to be second source for source parts (guessing from the fact that they have stopped publishing HVM numbers and are more focused on proving they can make reliable parts). Its become so sad that they don't even mention their EUV source on their website, but then again these type of companies rarely pay attention to their web presence.
- pa7x1 5y agoCymer is not the only company producing EUV sources. There are some Japanese companies that do produce them too, (e.g. Ushio). And ASML itself uses Trumpf's (Germany) lasers instead of Cymer. https://www.laserfocusworld.com/blogs/article/14039015/how-does-the-laser-technology-in-euv-lithography-work https://www.laserfocusworld.com/blogs/article/14039015/how-d...
- dirtyid 5y agoEast Asian IC supply chains in general, PRC/TW/JP/SKR accounts for ~75% of global IC capacity. Losing TSMC in war over TW will set the world back 1-2 nodes and ~10 years. Having expansive regional war (i.e. US trying to defend TW from JP/SKR bases) that knocks out the regions semi will set world back decades of capex. It's almost like MAD for semiconductors until enough gets reshored away from east asia.