3 ms·
I have one single solitary paper that has been published in a peer reviewed journal, so my experience is present but limited. What I gained out of the peer rev
by vacri 15y ago
I have one single solitary paper that has been published in a peer reviewed journal, so my experience is present but limited.
What I gained out of the peer review process was an article that had grey areas filled in and statistical methods applied better. The quality of the reviewed article was much better than the quality of the submitted article. The reviewers were reading the article with an even-handed critical eye; they weren't just looking for support for their pet opinions.
There's also an aspect of criticism - criticism is expected from reviewers, but random dude A on the internet is frequently going to get something along the lines of "who are you to criticise my methods", or any request for more info declined. "Please provide more info" will work if you need to get a paper published, but won't work if you have already published your paper on scribd - where's the motivation to do rework (beyond honour of course, but scientists are human and that does not always apply)
And then there's the point that popularity doesn't equal 'correct'. Here on HN I've seen time and time again that a throwaway popular comment gets upvotes, and a well-reasoned but unpopular comment gets downvotes. Peer-reviewed articles should be about scientific rigor, not visceral feeling. Consensus of the masses is orthogonal to the needs of scientific rigor.
The main article describes very, very little in the way of quality assurance.
- anghyflawn 15y agoI agree. I've had two articles reviewed by now (not in a science field, but still), and only one reviewer was relatively unhelpful (they thought the paper was too dense and insufficiently well presented to do a detailed review); all the others, even whey they could not recommend acceptance, went out of their way to suggest various ways of making the paper(s) better. People are in general much more likely to bother giving negative feedback than to give positive feedback, much less defend other people's efforts. I'm afraid such a system would be no different: would a ton of "likes" offset the negativity of a couple of arseholes wreaking havoc in the comments to make it worth it?
- Estragon 15y agoYes, the popularity of useless, emotive comments here really bugs me. There is an inverse correlation between the points I get for a comment and the amount of time and expertise I put into it. In the scientific case, though, "popularity" would be measured by the extent of citation. (Really, it already is.) That is a considerably higher bar than "I think I'll click on that arrow." For a paper to be cited, it has to make enough of an impact that people remember it and its ideas shape their thinking.