3 ms·
Some languages actually do have a central authority. IDK about Spanish, but my native language (Czech) definitely has an official standard. Anyone can, of cour
by inglor_cz 5y ago
Some languages actually do have a central authority. IDK about Spanish, but my native language (Czech) definitely has an official standard.
Anyone can, of course, use any weird construction they want, it is just not correct Czech.
- kwanbix 5y agoSpanisch also hast it. Real academia española But he post of the other member was about that languages naturally evolve, which is true, but this is forced and unatural.
- joshuamorton 5y agoWhat makes it forced or unnatural? It's intentional, to be sure, but hope does that make it less natural? Or put differently, how do you distinguish between a natural and unnatural change to language?
- kwanbix 5y agoUnnatural because they thought of inventing it, they started saying "tod@s" (todos is everyone), didn't catch, they then moved to "todxs", didn't catch, then they said "todes", and because people don't naturally use it. They even use it wrongly all the time. But more importantly, unnatural because if you have to impose it and call me names for not using it, you are doing it wrong.
- joshuamorton 5y ago> they thought of inventing it, How is this different than any other term that was coined? > didn't catch, they then moved to "todxs", didn't catch, then they said "todes", and because people don't naturally use it. They even use it wrongly all the time This sounds like natural evolution to me. People try different terms until one sticks. > But more importantly, unnatural because if you have to impose it and call me names for not using it, you are doing it wrong. Why? You're calling their use of language "wrong". Can't they do the same?
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]