2 ms·
> If she stopped working hard, would she be equally as successful, since you know, work and success have a tenuous correlation She's already not very successfu
by bluefirebrand 5y ago
> If she stopped working hard, would she be equally as successful, since you know, work and success have a tenuous correlation
She's already not very successful despite working like crazy. So arguably yes, she would be pretty much as successful if she stopped working versus running herself ragged.
Or if she's pretty (luck) she might meet a well-off partner (also luck) and suddenly not need to work as hard. Or if she wins the lottery, as another poster mentioned. Or maybe someone finds oil on her property (luck), which she only owns because she inherited it (luck).
I'll admit that none of these situations are terribly likely.
My main point was more around how someone could be working three jobs, arguably working harder than almost anyone else in society, and still be barely considered successful. Her ability to be "equally successful" if she stopped working is kind of a red herring here because the problem is she's already not very successful despite working harder than anyone.
- ghufran_syed 5y agoHaving a home is better (more successful) than being homeless. Having children to care for and who (hopefully) love you is better (more successful) than not having those things. Both of those things might be at risk if she didn’t work hard. I think your example says more about your own values rather about society in general
- bluefirebrand 5y agoMy own values are that someone should be able to have those things, a home and family, without working three jobs to barely stay on top of things. Again what I am talking about, and you are ignoring, is the magnitude of the work being done here, versus the relatively scant level of success achieved. Barely being able to afford a roof over your head is not success by any measure except against the most basic of standards. If you have to compare your level of success to someone who literally lives on the streets, you're in a dire situation. We should absolutely want better for people than "they barely aren't homeless and it takes a monumental effort for them to stay that way"
- ghufran_syed 5y agoWanting to help the poor with other people's money doesn't seem particularly virtuous, compared to, say, spending one's own time or money. Deciding arbitrarily that the amount of wealth we have is nice but not excessive, but the amount of wealth those evil rich people have is excessive seems rather self-serving. Particularly when "rich" is always conveniently defined as "more money than I have"