3 ms·
When it comes down to it, I think the lone genius is overestimated in common understanding and the rebuttal overcorrects. It usually takes quite a lot of exper
by colechristensen 5y ago
When it comes down to it, I think the lone genius is overestimated in common understanding and the rebuttal overcorrects.
It usually takes quite a lot of expertise to recognize what someone truly accomplished or even to appreciate or be explained.
The lone genius tends to do something which has its time come, usually a bit ahead of schedule.
In science the pattern tends to be long periods of incremental buildup of large volumes of straightforward work interspersed with sort of phase transitions often (but not always) triggered by the lone genius. (see also Thomas Kuhn’s Structure of Scientific Revolutions)
The pieces will all come into place for a significant change waiting for a trigger. The lone genius is the one who does this early. Not in a vacuum but also not in a crowd.
- asymptosis 5y agoThis seems a bit contradictory. You say that the lone genius is often overestimated, then you attribute Kuhnian paradigm shifts to these lone geniuses. Perhaps it is better to be skeptical about the idea of paradigm shifts. They are often portrayed as some kind of phase transition, but they are usually (or always?) foreshadowed by a generation of debate, and when history books look back, they only present a retrospective consensus on that imagined consensus which never actually existed in the debates of the day.