5 ms·
You're the person who entered the discussion by assuming that the original post was a tactical argument, rather than a good-faith post of a reasonable position.
by AnimalMuppet 5y ago
You're the person who entered the discussion by assuming that the original post was a tactical argument, rather than a good-faith post of a reasonable position.
And, what on earth does Joe Rogan have to do with the original topic? You keep bringing him up, and he's irrelevant to Moodles' point. What on earth does clinical suffering have to do with the original topic? You keep bringing that up, and it's irrelevant to Moodles' point.
You're giving off this really strong "only here to do ideological battle" vibe. That's not what HN is for.
- threatofrain 5y agoYou can choose not to offer people your faith. In this case it was validated by an admission that an argument was tactically made. > Because I am making the point that even mentioning something as extreme as that still gets me lambasted with abuse. So if we can't even discuss that civilly, how on Earth are we meant to discuss more nuanced issues? >> So did you want to discuss trans elite sports or were you trying to demonstrate that people cannot handle a conversation with greater nuance? Or both at the same time? > The latter, but if you want to talk about the former we can do that too. But you're still focused on whether we afford good faith to tactical arguments. You're accusing me of bad character while espousing whatever it means to offer faith, but whether anyone is here to do ideological battle is easily confirmed by simply clicking on their account history. And what does Joe Rogan have to do with discourse on elite trans sports? He's a benchmark for conversation quality and focus and a major player in discussing trans issues. There are other branching threads here. See if anything ever rises above Joe Rogan's playground of debate. > What on earth does clinical suffering have to do with the original topic? You keep bringing that up, and it's irrelevant to Moodles' point. And surely one does not ask, "What does transgenderism have to do with transgendered people in elite sports?" > What do you have to say about the primary phenomena of clinical suffering? Its etiologies and its course in medical debate across the west? That is a discussion which hits squarely on "What is trans?" This is what I wanted to discuss. An open invitation to discuss the course of medical debate across the west, one which squarely hits at "What is trans?"
- Moodles 5y ago> In this case it was validated by an admission that an argument was tactically made. Huh? Essentially all I have said is this: "I agree with the Economist article. This is my personal experience also. Here's an example." Tactually made? What does this even mean? Do you think I have a hidden agenda of bigotry towards trans people or something? What exactly am I doing wrong in your eyes? Is there any actual specific sentence I have written you disagree with?
- AnimalMuppet 5y agoFrom your original post: > > The arguments the two sides put forward, in other words, are complex and debatable. But many trans activists think that any disagreement is tantamount to hate speech and try to suppress it. > This is 100% my personal experience also. And it's looking a lot like your experience here. You're getting told that you can't have put forth your comments in good faith, that it was "tactically made". (Which I interpret as meaning that it's to push an agenda rather than in good faith. I could be mistaken, but threatofrain is not clarifying what that accusation means.) So, yeah, I stand by my statement that this whole thread proves your point...
- Moodles 5y agoYeah, so perceptive to have read between the lines and seen the darkness in my soul. \s