4 ms·
How about "Hard work is not sufficient or necessary for success" You can work hard and never be successful. You can be successful by pure chance or luck withou
by bluefirebrand 5y ago
How about "Hard work is not sufficient or necessary for success"
You can work hard and never be successful. You can be successful by pure chance or luck without ever putting in any real effort.
It's easy to frame it as "those people just want an excuse for why they don't work hard", but that's asinine.
The truth is that some of the hardest workers on the planet (anecdotes of single mothers working three jobs to provide for their family come to mind) are living below the poverty line and there is no amount of harder work that would fix that.
Hard Work and Success have some correlation sure. It's tenuous at best.
- bko 5y ago> The truth is that some of the hardest workers on the planet (anecdotes of single mothers working three jobs to provide for their family come to mind) are living below the poverty line and there is no amount of harder work that would fix that. If she stopped working hard, would she be equally as successful, since you know, work and success have a tenuous correlation?
- arvinsim 5y agoOne can stop working, win the lottery and be successfully financially.
- ghufran_syed 5y agoThat person still had to earn the money for the lottery ticket, and do the work of buying the tickets. If you discount all the necessary steps except the final random payoff, it’s easy to “prove” that hard work was not required for a given person’s success
- bluefirebrand 5y ago> That person still had to earn the money for the lottery ticket, and do the work of buying the tickets. Not necessarily, it could be a gift or even something they find on the street. It's also not the point. All through this thread you are ignoring that people are talking about relative hard work effort versus success output. Buying a lottery ticket is such little effort I'd barely even call it "work". So the the work effort is tiny. The success outcome if you win is absolutely enormous. The deciding factor is luck. This is why I say hard work and success are barely related. It's possible, perhaps even likely, to work hard and see little success, while others work less hard, get lucky, and see huge success. At best, hard work gives you more opportunities to get lucky. People who get lucky in this manner (or wish they could) often say that hard work is a way of making your own luck, but that's just a form of survivorship bias imo.
- bluefirebrand 5y ago> If she stopped working hard, would she be equally as successful, since you know, work and success have a tenuous correlation She's already not very successful despite working like crazy. So arguably yes, she would be pretty much as successful if she stopped working versus running herself ragged. Or if she's pretty (luck) she might meet a well-off partner (also luck) and suddenly not need to work as hard. Or if she wins the lottery, as another poster mentioned. Or maybe someone finds oil on her property (luck), which she only owns because she inherited it (luck). I'll admit that none of these situations are terribly likely. My main point was more around how someone could be working three jobs, arguably working harder than almost anyone else in society, and still be barely considered successful. Her ability to be "equally successful" if she stopped working is kind of a red herring here because the problem is she's already not very successful despite working harder than anyone.
- ghufran_syed 5y agoHaving a home is better (more successful) than being homeless. Having children to care for and who (hopefully) love you is better (more successful) than not having those things. Both of those things might be at risk if she didn’t work hard. I think your example says more about your own values rather about society in general
- bluefirebrand 5y agoMy own values are that someone should be able to have those things, a home and family, without working three jobs to barely stay on top of things. Again what I am talking about, and you are ignoring, is the magnitude of the work being done here, versus the relatively scant level of success achieved. Barely being able to afford a roof over your head is not success by any measure except against the most basic of standards. If you have to compare your level of success to someone who literally lives on the streets, you're in a dire situation. We should absolutely want better for people than "they barely aren't homeless and it takes a monumental effort for them to stay that way"
- ghufran_syed 5y ago
- michaelbrave 5y agoI've always thought of hard work to be one of the prerequisites to success, it's not enough on it's own, and it has to be in the right direction, and it has to have luck and/or the right network to stick. So it's necessary but not enough to go the distance, just like having a running car without fuel won't be enough to get you there.
- arvinsim 5y agoNope, as the poster said, you can be successful just by luck alone. Hard work not necessary.
- ghufran_syed 5y agoSurely the distribution matters too? Even if it is possible to be successful through luck alone, is that necessarily imply that most people are no worse off if they don’t work hard?
- bluefirebrand 5y agoSee this seeks to invert the problem, and it's really sneaky. We should not be so focused on "if you stop working hard, your life will get worse" Instead we should focus on "Is it possible to better your position through hard work alone" and often that's not the case. For many people they have to work hard just to maintain a very low position in society. There is no meaningful chance for them to improve their position through hard work alone, so it's clear that hard work is not sufficient to predict success. I don't care how you define success at this point. It's clear to me that working hard just to barely stay afloat is not it.
- bluefirebrand 5y agoI've always found that having the right network or luck matters a lot more than the hard work. The hard work is maybe necessary to capitalize on luck but ultimately some people land high paying jobs where they don't have to work hard and can take afternoons off to golf, purely out of being lucky about who their family is. Other people have to work themselves to the bone to earn a fraction what those people earn. Hard work isn't necessary or sufficient for success.
- ghufran_syed 5y agoAs argued in the article - would you suggest that the life of that single mother would not get worse if she stopped working so hard? If we define success as some arbitrary amount of money, we can make the correlation between hard work and success “tenuous” just by making the amount of money defining success to be high enough.
- bluefirebrand 5y ago> would you suggest that the life of that single mother would not get worse if she stopped working so hard It likely would but not necessarily, depending on other factors. "Her life would get worse" is a complete distraction here from the fact that she is working crazy hard and is not very successful. I agree that if we define success as being a high enough value it ceases to be meaningful. Luckily society has a base level value we call "The poverty line" and we can use that as a metric. It's not a very good one, because living right at the poverty line is still not a desirable life. But it's what we have. How does "hard work -> success" explain the millions of workers who live below the poverty line? If that is the base level of success that society sort of expects, then you would figure that anyone who has a job they work hard at should be able to be above it, no? Are all of those workers just lazy? Not working hard enough?
- pitaj 5y agoThe poverty line is arbitrary and defined in a relative fashion, so it's not useful for your example as there will always be somewhere we can draw the line that puts 25% of people below it.
- kerkeslager 5y ago> As argued in the article - would you suggest that the life of that single mother would not get worse if she stopped working so hard? No, I would not make the straw man argument you're proposing. > If we define success as some arbitrary amount of money, we can make the correlation between hard work and success “tenuous” just by making the amount of money defining success to be high enough. No one is defining success as some arbitrary amount of money. We're both defining success relatively: you're defining it in relation to a hypothetical outcome for hypothetical courses of actions for a hypothetical single mother, whereas I'm defining success in relation to real outcomes for real people who start from different situations.