3 ms·
This is the right decision. There needs to be a sharp division between personal time and other time (work, school, etc.) People need the right to express them
by mc32 5y ago
This is the right decision.
There needs to be a sharp division between personal time and other time (work, school, etc.) People need the right to express themselves freely without fear of retribution just because the offended disagree with the private speech. Of course there are complicating factors (you work for marketing and in your personal time talk bad about the company or colleague.)
It's none of a school's business what a student says on their own time, so long as it does not violate the law (insider trading, threats of actual physical violence, etc.)
- gnicholas 5y agoInterestingly, the Court didn't create the sharp division that you mention — unlike the Third Circuit, which apparently drew more of a bright line. The Court left open the possibility that schools can regulate off-campus speech in other cases, including "severe bullying", threats to staff, or computer hacking. It will be interesting to see how this language is interpreted by lower courts, and whether it ends up being a broad exception or a narrow one.
- mc32 5y agoThreats to staff and hacking are already illegal and I think would be exceptions to the 1A. Extreme bullying while vile, isn't necessarily illegal. If it happens on school grounds or affects a student, there may be merit to pursue the allegations. But flipping off the school off-campus should never have been a reason to punish the student. People talk shit about their friends, employers, rivals, etc. all the time, in private. That should always be possible. I would not want a society where we are never supposed to say negative about anything or anyone. In one extreme view, expressing omnivorous preferences and and thus eating animals is "hate speech" toward animals.